4 ms·
> 2. difficult to travel with kids I'm pretty sure my nephew's first ride on the subway was when he was 3. I don't recall how old I was when I first took the s
by jcranmer 6y ago
> 2. difficult to travel with kids
I'm pretty sure my nephew's first ride on the subway was when he was 3. I don't recall how old I was when I first took the subway, but I think wasn't more than twice his age.
Transit is no harder than any other mode of transportation with kids. Sure, you might have to be schlepping around some duffel bags of supplies, but you'll have to do that anyways at your destination.
> 5. have to check time schedule
This is only true if your city has a bad transit system. And, yes, every city in the US (including NYC!) has bad transit. That's one of the main themes of the author--if you actually look at how transit works in other countries, you'll find that the American experience with transit is unusually bad.
> 1. do not directly bring you from point A to B
This is mostly a result of bad urban planning. When you have a transit system in place, you want to focus development around the accessibility of transit so that all of the desired origin and destination points are actually near enough to transit to you allow you to go directly from point A to B. When cities cross the hurdle and stop making every other block be a parking lot, then the nonavailability of parking means that it's driving that has the problem of not getting you directly from point A to B like transit would.
- temp8964 6y agoFor 2, I meant with multiple kids. With a baby is indeed more difficult. You apparently did have the experience of carrying the stroller up and down in subways. Especially when elevator is not working, which is not rare in NYC. 5 and 1 may be a planning issue, but the terrible situation in NYC could because the size of population and geography. It certainly can be improved, but the cost of change must have deterred the management.
- watwut 6y agoImo, baby is easy. The hard is toddler you have to watch constantly else it does something stupid or get lost. Baby can be contained in carrier.
- temp8964 6y agoBut baby cries, sometimes need sleep and sometimes need milk. So much easier to do all those in cars.
- watwut 6y agoIn carrier, they are able to sleep and you walking around makes them sleep. They also can wait without milk for an hour or so. They don't eat constantly. In car, they are in the back, so if they cry, you have to stop, exit car, deal with them, enter again and so on. And driving while baby cries in the back is annoying. Public transport and carrier is not that much worst, assuming you are not carrying too many things. More importantly, I compared difficulty of toddler and baby. Toddler in car can be noisy too.
- temp8964 6y agoActually car also make them sleep. But subway has too much noise, which could wake them up. For breast feeding, car provides a private space. For baby crying and toddler drama, it's kind of embarrassing to have those in public transport. I can even have the toddler pee in a bottle in my car, definitely not on public transport. Also change diaper, etc. etc.
- watwut 6y agoI mean, I had both kids and car. I also used public transport. I also breasted - personally, I am woman. Calming crying kid on carrier is easier then while driving. Breastfeeding in car is not all that comfortable and you cant drive while breastfeeding. Typically it is not that difficult to find reasonably private place within time limit since kid cries constantly. You are going to spend time somewhere, park or friend or shopping center. That somewhere has usually good solutions, otherwise you would not be spending time there. I never used pee bottles and such.
- coolsnow7 6y agoElevator not working or nonexistent (because in NYC it costs $80m (!!!) to install one that works ~80% of the time) is exactly what the US needs to get better at wrt mass transit. You just made a great case that NYC for example needs to! You’re also making wild assumptions about the relationship between the impact of change and NYC transit managers’ incentive to realize it. Separately I’ve been traveling with my son on the subway since he was months old. I grew up taking the trains with my siblings to and from outings all the time. This “can’t do it with kids” meme is pernicious nonsense.
- watwut 6y ago> I'm pretty sure my nephew's first ride on the subway was when he was 3. He said "difficult" not "impossible". And if you was travelling with 3 years old, you would know it is in fact more difficult and tiring. Not impossible. You can travel by public transport with 2 years old or baby too. But, where public transport can be more or equally comfortable then going by car, if you have small kids you have to watch all the time, it is more difficult.