10 ms·
Funny that they don't mention what "certain, commonplace views" people "stay silent" about. That might put a different spin on things. As I mentioned [1] about
by wpietri 6y ago
Funny that they don't mention what "certain, commonplace views" people "stay silent" about. That might put a different spin on things.
As I mentioned [1] about the Basecamp debacle, you can't get full "viewpoint diversity" and full "identity diversity" because some viewpoints are hostile to some identities. Given our society's long history of those viewpoints being endemic, and given the slow movement away from identity-based oppression that has sped up a bit recently, workplaces will have to choose whether they value "viewpoint diversity" or "identity diversity" when they conflict.
[1] https://twitter.com/williampietri/status/1387409628271562755 https://twitter.com/williampietri/status/1387409628271562755
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoBut many conservative viewpoints are not hostile to identities. If I don't agree with Affirmative Action, am I hostile to someone's identity? A majority of Californians at the ballot box will disagree with AA but none of them will say it out loud at the workplace. It's the misconception that identities are "opposed" by certain viewpoints that leads to this.
- klyrs 6y agoMany conservative viewpoints are perfectly acceptable to share in the workplace. Down with taxes, small government, privatize and monetize, down with regulations, etc. Well. Except there's some lines. If you work in the oil industry and you complain about regulation of food products, fine. But if you complain about environmental regulations that pertain to your business and an inspector happens to overhear, then your company can expect the worst. So it's in your boss's interest to come down on you, even when the inspector isn't around to hear.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoFine, but some which should be acceptable aren't and I'm talking about ones unrelated to one's business.
- wpietri 6y agoSome are, some aren't. I have not noticed conservative colleaguess being afraid to say they're in favor of a tax cut, for example. But consider Buckley's definition: "A conservative is someone who stands athwart history, yelling Stop [...]". I think that's fine; as an engineer, I'm dispositionally conservative. But in each case, it's worth asking what capital-C Conservatives are actually trying to conserve. Given how ripe America's history is with oppression of everybody who wasn't a well-off white man, it is extremely easy to conserve that oppression. So in practice, quite a number of Conservative viewpoints are hostile to certain identities. That's obviously true with LGBT+ folks, who in my lifetime have had to fight to get the same rights as anybody else and have faced deep Conservative opposition every step of the way. It is less obviously true for other identity groups, and I'm willing to credit the notion that many Conservative individuals are not as consciously focused on oppressing some minority in the way they were with LGBT+ people. But conscious intent doesn't matter a ton to the people facing the sharp end of oppressive systems.
- brippalcharrid 6y ago> Funny that they don't mention what "certain, commonplace views" people "stay silent" about. That might put a different spin on things. The article actually mentions at least two examples, so I don't think there's as much room for spin with this as you might think. One is Conservative voters, who have been vilified by the hard left since the 1970s, not least because of a sense of betrayal with the erosion of parts of the historic Labour voter base as people from working-class backgrounds moved to white-collar professions and abandoned trade unionism, and this has been particularly apparent in the arts. There is a "Shy Tory" phenomenon that has continued to confound pollsters. Another is people who voted for the UK to leave the EU in the 2016 referendum. Leave voters were regularly presented as ignorant and racist by major media sources from the lead up to the referendum until the final death of the Remain/Change UK insurgency after the 2019 General Election, with variations on Little Englander as well as different flavours of False Consciousness. I think your reference to a "full 'viewpoint diversity'" is invoking a concept that isn't found within the article; instead, the article addresses > views that diverge from majority public opinion and it is saying that these are more likely to be voiced, and to be tolerated without fear of termination or marginalization when they are from people on the Progressive/Labour side of the political spectrum. I don't think the scope of this discussion was intended to extend to people who "want to kill black people" (as they did in your cartoon); instead it encompasses the type of issues that people have been talking about in the UK over the last few years, which include enacting the result of the 2016 referendum, as well as those pertaining to taxation, immigration, education, healthcare and defence.
- pmyteh 6y agoFor what it's worth, the 'shy Tory' effect isn't really a thing, at least in British opinion polling. Maybe in the 1992 General Election, when it was coined, not since. Polling errors go both ways, most polling misses turn out to be a result of turnout modeling problems or (occasionally) unrepresentative samples, and voters have no problem at all telling pollsters they're going to vote for the Tories, UKIP, or anyone else. Take the present prime minister. I don't think it's particularly controversial to say that he's repeatedly proven himself to be a fairly brazen liar. Voters don't actually like liars. They do, nevertheless, like Johnson (and quite a bit more than they like Starmer). And they're not shy about saying so.
- jollybean 6y agoThe most newly contentious formerly 'commonplace view' is the position that 'we should treat people for who they are, not for their race, gender' etc.. This is actually the fault line between classical progressives and newer groups. CRT hinges on the notion that groups are marginalized in a million unseen ways, in which case, one simply cannot ignore anothers race, rather one must make assumptions about that person's group characteristics to inform one's judgement, presumably, empathetically. So MLK's famous proclamation: "I look to a day when people will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character" ... is now effectively a 'problematic' signal for one group, it's now 'out group behaviour' in their view. I don't have a problem at all with those seeking to think they are actively helping, but am very opposed to the intolerance and absolution implied by those groups who can no longer accept those abiding by MLK's virtues. It's very odd because most people over a certain age have spent their life being told about those virtues, and are now told that it's 'unacceptable'. Edit: I should add, the degree of intolerance of these views is expressed by the sanctioning of certain kinds of workplace diversity programs (CRT), which are of course 'required training' in many companies and government sectors. [1] [1] https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/only-white-people-can-be-racist-inside-global-affairs-anti-racism-course-materials https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/only-white-people-can-b...
- tdeck 6y agoSomehow the legacy of MLK has been reduced to just that one quote, even though he wrote a a book ("Why We Can't Wait") that advocated for affirmative action programs for black people. His legacy has effectively been sanitized and "abridged" to be less challenging to persistent and harmful power structures.
- wpietri 6y agoAgreed. He was very clear that solving the existing problems involved directly confronting them. "Letter from a Birmingham Jail" makes very clear that however uncomfortable white people are with being forced to look at what's going on, that discomfort is a necessary precondition to progress: "Nonviolent direct action seeks to create such a crisis and foster such a tension that a community which has constantly refused to negotiate is forced to confront the issue. It seeks so to dramatize the issue that it can no longer be ignored. My citing the creation of tension as part of the work of the nonviolent resister may sound rather shocking. But I must confess that I am not afraid of the word 'tension.' I have earnestly opposed violent tension, but there is a type of constructive, nonviolent tension which is necessary for growth."
- eyko 6y ago> you can't get full "viewpoint diversity" and full "identity diversity" because some viewpoints are hostile to some identities. I've heard variations of this idea and I personally disagree. Yes, some ideas are hostile to some identities, including mine (black), but hostility we can live with. It's disheartening to see society devolve to a state where being offensive is considered being harmful. If you believe that, then you'll likely also believe that "hate speech is violence", or that words can be "harmful" (yes, they can, but not in a literal sense). It's unlikely that you can have viewpoint diversity in an environment where people believe that someone's opinion has the potential to cause actual harm. I'm not talking about someone inciting violence against individuals or groups based on their identity, beliefs, etc. When I've been called the n-word, it's hurt my feelings and offended me, amongst other things to unpack, but it would be wrong to equate that with violence, independent of what anyone's opinion on the matter might be. So yes, I can definitely speak and have spoken to people who hold racist views (I mean actual neonazis, not conservatives) and we've agreed to disagree and we've had actual interesting conversations (at least, interesting to me, because I'm interested in understanding how they think, where the hate comes from, how it was learnt, etc). They get disrespectful, they insult, we disagree, etc. It's disappointing that people would think that I, because of the colour of my skin, am unable to hold -- never mind being interested in -- hearing these fringe points of views and opinions that can be offensive. That my personality is somehow override by my identity, as if it were some sort of basic instinct. I don't understand how you otherwise intelligent people can make such assumptions about "some identities" and not see the irony in that.
- wpietri 6y agoYou seem to think the only kind of harm is violence. I find that might hard to fathom. There is rich individual and statistical evidence that hate and bias cause lasting harm.
- slibhb 6y agoIn your tweet, you immediately go to "well off white guys". The fact that you feel comfortable and proud to write like this in public, under your real name, perfectly encapsulates how far off the reservation you are.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoAnd you, in reply, use "off the reservation"? I'm not sure you're in a position to cast the first stone...
- slibhb 6y agoThere's a chink in your argument.
- wpietri 6y agoI am a well-off white guy. Please explain why you think I can't talk openly about a group I'm in, one that was favored by law and custom starting right at the beginning of my country.
- slibhb 6y agoYour skin color and socioeconomic status are irrelevant. You can talk openly about whatever you like. The fact that you don't understand how awful it is to talk about a "well-off white male mentality" is an indictment of you as a person. You've lost the plot completely and your worldview is characterized by comic levels of intolerance.
- wpietri 6y agoAh yes. Ad hominems without any substance at all. As I expected. What you are experiencing is white fragility. You can read more about the phenomenon here: https://libjournal.uncg.edu/ijcp/article/view/249 https://libjournal.uncg.edu/ijcp/article/view/249 The truth is that when discussing societal power in the US, both race and socioeconomic status are hugely relevant. And have been since the founding of this country, when by law only well-off white men could vote. I understand facing that frankly makes some people, you included, uncomfortable to the point of irrationality. I suggest you get over it, as the issues are not going away.