3 ms·
So Egyptology isn't really a science today, and I should not trust what I hear too much?
by BurningFrog 6y ago
So Egyptology isn't really a science today, and I should not trust what I hear too much?
- tastyfreeze 6y agoYes, there are several artifacts that dont fit the Hawass history of Egypt. But attempts to change the known history have been stymied by Hawass.
- sintaxi 6y agoLots of amazing work is being done in Egypt right now most of it IMHO being done by Geologists because they are much less likely to have any attachment towards any established theory. Zawi Hawass seems to have contempt for anyone who comes to conclusions that doesn't align with the gated narrative even when those conclusion are very well reasoned (For example: water erosion around the Sphinx). The official narrative that we were all taught in school of "Pyramids were built 4500 years ago as tombs by Khufu" I would say is understood to be highly inaccurate at this point by anyone outside of the Hawass circle.
- generalizations 6y ago> The official narrative that we were all taught in school of "Pyramids were built 4500 years ago as tombs by Khufu" I would say is understood to be highly inaccurate at this point by anyone outside of the Hawass circle. I never heard of that before. What is thought to be more accurate?
- sintaxi 6y agoFirst of all, nobody knows who built them, how they were built, nor why they were built. We only have vague guesses at this point. No bodies were ever found in any of the Pyramids on the Giza plateau - and despite the Egyptians documenting everything, there are no claims by them that Khufu or anyone else in their documented history built the Pyramids. Pharaohs were buried in the Valley of the Kings. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valley_of_the_Kings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valley_of_the_Kings
- jhgb 6y agoUh, the Valley of the Kings was only actively used for a comparatively short period throughout Egypt's entire history. What does it have to do with this? What do you think Egyptians did with their kings before the Valley of the Kings was established and after it ceased to be used? > First of all, nobody knows who built them, how they were built, nor why they were built. > and despite the Egyptians documenting everything, there are no claims by them that Khufu or anyone else in their documented history built the Pyramids. https://www.livescience.com/55439-ancient-logbook-on-great-pyramid-unveiled.html https://www.livescience.com/55439-ancient-logbook-on-great-p... > Over a period of several months, [the logbook] reports — in [the] form of a timetable with two columns per day — many operations related to the construction of the Great Pyramid of Khufu at Giza and the work at the limestone quarries on the opposite bank of the Nile I guess this Merer guy is one of those you were looking for.
- sintaxi 6y ago1) There are hundreds of Pyramids in that area. To my understanding no bodies were found in any of them. 2) Gold and copper are the metals available during Khufu's reign. Is it reasonable to you that copper (or even Iron) was used to cut granite? 3) 2.5 Million blocks were used in the construction of the Great Pyramid. Weight of blocks range from 1-10 tons each. 4) The granite for the "King's Chamber" was brought 934km to Giza from Aswan 5) A 20 year construction timeline as claimed would mean a block would have to be cut from the quarry, moved to location, and placed in the correct spot every 4 minutes with construction running 24 hours a day 7 days a week without stopping. Is it not more reasonable to conclude Khufu simply performed maintenance on the outer casings? A 20 year project with a 200 men crew to polish outer casings seems about right to me.
- jhgb 6y agoI'm beginning to get serious crackpot vibes from your comments. Why is it surprising that looted tombs after thousands of years don't contain bodies? (Even though for example the presumed mummy of Djedkare Isesi was found in his pyramid, so "no bodies were found in any of them" is simply a lie.) What has gold and copper have to do with working hard stones? What is it with the Great Pyramid blocks? They are far from the largest blocks manipulated in prehistory. > Is it not more reasonable to conclude Khufu simply performed maintenance on the outer casings? No, it's not. > A 20 year project with a 200 men crew to polish outer casings seems about right to me. Nobody claims the pyramids were built by 200 people. Egypt had a population of over a million at the time, with a few hundred thousand of that population being seasonally bored farmers available for construction projects.
- ncmncm 6y agoPre-literate antiquities are in bad shape everywhere. In Egypt it is just easiest to see. Fertile Crescent. Caucasus. Indus Valley. China. Peru. Amazon. Sundaland. There will be plenty of opportunity to shake things up someday.