6 ms·
I’m not convinced that bringing in European managers will solve the distances between cities, the fact that the rails and right-of-ways are almost entirely priv
by sokoloff 6y ago
I’m not convinced that bringing in European managers will solve the distances between cities, the fact that the rails and right-of-ways are almost entirely privately owned, and the fact that Americans are generally comfortable with an auto and airplane model of transportation.
I use rail when I visit multiple European cities. It’s great. I also don’t see a reasonable path that is “we need better managers” but instead “we either need to pour gigantic piles of money into buying railroads, which is either an eminent domain taking or a massive giveaway to freight companies who own the rails now, only to find that no one wants to spend every bit of a whole damn day getting from Boston to Las Vegas and so will fly anyway.”
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Ericson2314 6y agoAndy Byford by most accounts did a great job in NYC....until Cuomo got jealous and forced him out. This was a nice anecdote that hiring actually-knowledgeable outsiders (not private sector dilettantes) can help.
- cguess 6y agoIt's funny how here in NYC he was literally nicknamed "train daddy" and radically improved the subway on-time rates and track speeds... so yep, he had to go. Everyone loved him, NY and London are not all that different culturally. He picked up on the subtleties and worked through them, and goddamn I wish we could have him back.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wbl 6y agoThe Northeast is dense. Bay Area should have German levels of S-Bahn style service on the UP tracks.
- galangalalgol 6y agoIs there anywhere else that is dense enough to connect besides the bay, la, andnthe dc to boston strip? Thats probably getting close to a quarter of the population so even that would be a good deal. A lot of smaller cities could use better bus systems, but they take hours to get anyi with all the stops amd switchovers.
- Jtsummers 6y agoThe southeast US is not as dense as the northeast, but TN, NC, SC, GA, AL, and FL have 55 million or so people in them, the majority living in or near major metro areas. Connecting those major metros using the existing interstate corridors as the general path, you'd get most of the remaining population within a short distance of this intercity railway. If the metros themselves invested in better intrametro (I'd say intracity, but it would be a misnomer) transit systems that connected to the intercity system it could be effective for the region.
- jcranmer 6y agoThe Midwest region (centered on Chicago) is very much within viable HSR range--as I point out in a nearby comment, it actually contains larger cities within the same general distance as the French TGV network. Texas triangle would also be a viable region. As my sibling comment points out, southeast US is marginally viable. The Pacific Northwest (Portland-Vancouver) is also on the margin of viability. The other parts of the northeast--Boston-Toronto and NYC-Montreal--are very definitely viable HSR routes. You might find some more strap-on routes to the main Northeast Corridor that I haven't included (Scranton, maybe?), simply because the NEC is such a phenomenally powerful generator of traffic. Connecting the Midwest to the Northeast and the Southeast may also be viable, but again it's somewhat more marginal because the big city in the Midwest is on the wrong side of the region.
- ativzzz 6y agoHaving done a lot of driving through the Texas triangle, I can tell you that the biggest detriment to HSR would be the fact that you still need a car after you get off your train. I've taken the greyhound/megabus between cities, and it's pretty decent, but then I either need someone to drive 30 mins one way to pick me up or shell out $30+ for an Uber to get to where I need to go, and then more Ubers if I need to get around afterwards. To make the intercity transport really compelling, the cities themselves need good public transport coverage, and the triangle cities are too damn big for that to happen in the foreseeable future. They have some, but it takes forever and the reach isn't that high. I'd rather have a mostly self driving car that can take me 80% of the way on the interstate highway between the cities.
- jimmaswell 6y agoI'd gladly sit in a nice train compartment for a day over driving or flying, especially if it had a nice view.
- plandis 6y agoI certainly wouldn’t, and I’m willing to bet people like me are in the majority. Why waste a day in a train when I can drive for way less cost and stop wherever I please or fly and get there much faster? Not to mention that if I drive some place Im not worried about transportation locally which would, in most places in the US, require renting a car or paying for ride shares.
- theshrike79 6y agoSo you'll rather drive and do nothing else vs sitting in a train with a full restaurant with a bar, comfy chairs, wi-fi and a quiet spot for working[1][2]? I've done multiple 3 hour train trips this way, I'll NEVER choose driving over it. I can sit down and order food from downstairs, it'll be brought to my seat. I've got a quiet spot to work in with an 230V outlet and working Wifi. I can do billable work every minute I'm in the train. I can even close my eyes and take a nap. Compare this to driving, which would take an hour longer, I'd need to be 100% focused on the road all the time, I can't bill my hours, I can't relax. [1] https://www.vr.fi/en/facilities-and-services/working-on-the-train https://www.vr.fi/en/facilities-and-services/working-on-the-... [2] https://www.vr.fi/en/facilities-and-services/upstairs-of-the-restaurant-car https://www.vr.fi/en/facilities-and-services/upstairs-of-the...
- R0b0t1 6y agoIf you're not billing your transit time you're making a mistake. I've heard of people double billing plane or train transit: one customer put you on the train, and the other customer pays for the work you do on the train.
- theshrike79 6y agoYep, this was the exact case. I can't bill transit from all clients, but I can still do billable work on the train for other clients. No way to do that while driving.
- jcranmer 6y ago> I’m not convinced that bringing in European managers will solve the distances between cities, Except that the US isn't all that less dense than Europe. There's a great belt of land that approximately no one lives in, between the west coast and the Mississippi River. High-speed rail will never be cost-effective connecting anything across that region, and no one is seriously proposing such a thing. Take it out, and concentrate on the rest of the country, in regions where there are cities close each other and the numbers make more sense. The Midwest, for example. Chicago-Minneapolis is 350 mi, Chicago-Cleveland 300 mi, and Chicago-St Louis and Chicago-Detroit each 250 mi. Paris-Lyon is 250 mi, Paris-Bordeaux 300 mi, and Paris-Marseille 400mi. As for population, all of these cities are larger than their French counterparts (the smallest, Cleveland is only a ~2m MSA, whereas the largest non-Paris French city is about a ~2.3m MSA). If HSR is tenable in France, then why would the distances in the Midwest make it untenable?
- theshrike79 6y agoYep, with proper high-speed rail one could travel from Minneapolis to Chicago in under two hours. Without the airport security theater, with proper in-car restaurants and remote working facilities. Who wouldn't take that offer?
- bsder 6y ago> I use rail when I visit multiple European cities. It’s great. I'm going to counterargument this. Certain rail corridors are great--Naples to Rome, for example, was wonderful. But somehow when we were visiting Europe, we often found that air actually did better in both price and time. The cheap rail fares often require quite a bit further advance purchase than air fares. This strikes me as ... odd.