3 ms·
So is the issue that beta-amyloid is the smoke, rather than the fire? Or rather that mice aren't humans?
by magicalhippo 6y ago
So is the issue that beta-amyloid is the smoke, rather than the fire? Or rather that mice aren't humans?
- jfoutz 6y agoI'm not a doctor. I haven't worked in a wet lab. All this is from second hand conversations and anecdotes. Mice aren't human. There's lots of ways to cure cancer in mice. it's practically a joke. Mice can tell you a bit about danger - if your treatment kills the mouse, think pretty hard about that treatment on a human. It might kill the human too, but maybe not. Might be ok for the mouse but not the human, like maybe thalidomide. The impression I get is, if it's ok for mice it _might_ be ok for humans, so it helps avoid a large swath of super dangerous stuff. But doesn't tell you a whole lot about what happens in humans. I'm sure there are things that kill mice that are effective treatments for humans, but both of those edges are outlier-ish. If it kills the mouse it's probably not worth continuing without a good understanding of why it might work in humans.
- tdaltonc 6y agoIt's that transgenic beta-amyloid mice are not humans with Alzheimer's. BUT! As another neuro PhD: this is still an important finding for our understanding of protein (dis)aggregation in the brain. The opposite finding was totally possible. The protein disaggregation could have been independent of CSF flow. The typical HN hot-take is "not so fast, this translational research actually underdelivers," but I prefer, "this fundamental neurosci research has the added bonus of being preformed on a clinically relevant model."
- ProjectArcturis 6y agoI would disagree that transgenic A-beta mice are a clinically relevant model. I mean, I understand why we started there -- at first glance Alzheimer's is amyloidosis in the brain. But after all this time, it's pretty clear that removing amyloid doesn't cure AD, and consequently that overexpressing amyloid in a mouse is not a good animal model of AD.
- ProjectArcturis 6y agoIt could be that amyloid is the smoke. It could also be residue from the body's fire extinguishers. That is, something breaks, and amyloid accumulation is a consequence of whatever the body does to try to fix it. Maybe it makes it worse. The point is, we don't know, and 30 years of presuming that we do has led us to a giant dead end.