9 ms·
While I generally support Signal's mission, let's not get too taken in by their own PR and its triumphal tone, however satisfying it may be to thumb one's nose
by wolverine876 6y ago
While I generally support Signal's mission, let's not get too taken in by their own PR and its triumphal tone, however satisfying it may be to thumb one's nose at the powerful. (People tend to trust the PR they like and distrust PR they don't like - let's think critically about of all of it.)
Based only on this post and the Cellebrite hack, Signal appears overconfident, taken with their own press clippings, and making enemies. That's not behavior that leads to good security: Paranoid, worried about the next vulnerability, and utilizing excellent risk management to prevent conflict are what I would look for. How does it help their millions of users when Signal provokes a leading forensics firm and the U.S. DoJ?
Could you imagine a security team at a company doing this, making problems for the company? It would be absurd. Maybe Signal feels they need the publicity.
- ygjb 6y agoSeveral security teams do this. Project Zero and it's various researcher have been thumbing their noses at software companies for a long time. The Cellebrite hack is not a shocking thing, similar demonstrations have been done for other digital forensics, IDS/IPS systems, and others over the last 20 years (longer?). This notion that directly, and clearly calling out your adversaries deficiencies is unprofessional or a risk is kind of asinine, whether it's another business like Cellebrite, or ongoing government overreach in support of mass surveillance, or specific cases of investigation. Failing to call them out leaves room for to imply agreement with their tactics and practices.
- ygjb 6y agoThat said, the Cellebrite hack scratched an old-school itch that hasn't been in awhile in a time when in person security cons where some of those demos happen haven't been happening :)
- wolverine876 6y agoProject Zero tries to improve security for the public and in ways that directly or indirectly affect Google, as do many other hackers, by informing the public of risks and by pressuring developers to be more diligent and to fix specific vulnerabilities. I don't see Signal's recent blog post as trying to pressure Cellebrite to improve their security. And the fact that other people do something isn't evidence of good judgment - other people can be stupid, and your circumstances are your own. Moxy doesn't work for possibly the most well-resourced security organization in the world (maybe outside the NSA), and he's not some independent hacker: he has a company, a product, and the privacy of millions of people that he has taken responsibility for - it's like having kids: you don't get to think of just yourself anymore, ever. > asinine At least you take your own advice.