3 ms·
If the products of incomplete combustion make up just 0.1%, how come if you pass your fingertip through the flame, too quickly to feel any pain, you get a solid
by kazinator 6y ago
If the products of incomplete combustion make up just 0.1%, how come if you pass your fingertip through the flame, too quickly to feel any pain, you get a solid black swath of soot on your skin in just that split second? The stuff is just spewing out.
- ahartmetz 6y agoThe yellow part is glowing soot particles. Where it stops being yellow, it has mostly burned up (turned into carbon dioxide). No surprise that there's a lot of soot in the flame.
- kazinator 6y agoWhere it stops being yellow, the particles have just cooled down so they don't glow. At that point, you see a black trail of smoke wafting upward. You won't see easily that by the light of the candle alone, though.
- ahartmetz 6y agoHold a spoon above the flame, it takes a long time to become black, if at all. Hold it into the flame, it becomes black instantly. You need to explain why that is so to convince me.
- celticninja 6y agoThe spoon causes more soot to be created by interfering with the combustion process.
- ajuc 6y agoPutting something relatively cold and with high thermal mass (like anything solid) to a flame drastically increases how much incomplete combustion happens near it. Basically you take the heat away before it can finish burning the fuel. That's why a clean flame will still soot anything you put over it.
- retrac 6y agoIf you interfere with the flame, by taking away heat or limiting airflow so it can't get enough oxygen, you will get partial combustion, where you have incomplete combustion byproducts and vaporized fuel in the mix as well. Same reason why a can of gasoline on fire will produce huge billows of black smoke (insufficient oxygen) while when burned under precise conditions in an engine it's much cleaner, even without exhaust filtering.