3 ms·
Or less... Did you forget the time when Apple deliberately made old iPhones grind to a halt so people would run out and buy new ones?
by pydry 6y ago
Or less...
Did you forget the time when Apple deliberately made old iPhones grind to a halt so people would run out and buy new ones?
- martin8412 6y agoCould that lie stop being perpetuated anytime soon? It was poorly communicated, but done for valid reasons.
- pydry 6y agoAs part of the agreement, Apple must display a notice on its French-language website for a month: "Apple "committed the crime of deceptive commercial practice by omission" and had agreed to pay the fine." https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-51413724 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-51413724 As you say, "just a misunderstanding". If it was genuinely done for the benefit of users they wouldn't have needed to hide what they were doing.
- biaachmonkie 6y agoLie? No Apple was fully aware of the power usage profiles of their devices and the power delivery profiles of their batteries and how those degrade over time. Apple chose, for a variety of reasons (cost savings, weight, size) to use a capacitor and battery combination that as the battery degraded with use over time would not be able to meet the instantaneous power delivery requirements of the phones and result in unreliable behavior. Instead of admitting their mistake and offering to replace peoples batteries or refund them or some other reasonable solution. They instead decided to sneak in a performance throttling software change to try and mitigate their design mistakes. I don't consider that "valid reasons".
- thebruce87m 6y agoThis has never happened. You may be thinking of batterygate in which handsets with degraded batteries throttled themselves to prevent brownouts. Replacing the battery returned the handset to full speed. The feature still exists today, except now (in reaction to the controversy) you can turn it off if you prefer random reboots when your battery is old. It was only ever about batteries. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batterygate https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batterygate
- pydry 6y agoIf it was only ever about batteries they would have A) been open about it B) consequently not fined for deceptive commercial practices. I find it astounding how many people believed that the cover story was the unvarnished truth given the lack of transparency exhibited by Apple over the matter, the obvious incentive and the natural proclivity so many similar industries have towards planned obsolescence (lightbulb conspiracy?). It's a hell of a reality distortion field. >Replacing the battery returned the handset to full speed. Ah yes, the battery they sealed into the phone.
- thebruce87m 6y agoTalking about distortion fields, let’s try and penetrate one. You are asserting that Apple slowed down phones in order to sell new ones. - Why only target specific handsets (with degraded batteries)? Why not entire model lines? - Why allow users to get their speed back by replacing the battery? Why not keep it slow to encourage the new sale? - If they got “caught”, why is the exact same feature available on a brand new iPhone 12? The only thing they changed was to allow you to turn throttling off if you prefer reboots. Surely they would remove the feature if it’s only purpose was to slow phones down? - Android phones suffer the same problems when their batteries degrade. Apple updated phones, some of which were out of warranty at the time. Is preventing reboots of older hardware planned obsolescence? Or the opposite? The only thing they did wrong was to not alert the users to the fact that the throttling was happening and how to remedy it. Now they do. I’m all about punishing companies when they do something wrong, but the environmentalist in me hates the fact that so many manufacturers drop support for phones after only a few years and the phones end up in landfill. Apple extended the life of older phones by doing this. People would be more likely to buy a new phone if it randomly rebooted vs ran slower. Anecdotally, my wife’s phone was throttling at the time and she didn’t even notice because she just used it for calls and texts. If she had encountered reboots she probably would have bought a new phone. Even once she knew it was throttled, she didn’t get the battery replaced because it still did the job until she upgraded last year.