4 ms·
Slightly different but I work in defense as a contractor and I usually summarize it as "being paid for work". The incentive is to do the most work because bein
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y ago
Slightly different but I work in defense as a contractor and I usually summarize it as "being paid for work".
The incentive is to do the most work because being done early and under budget doesn't maximize $. Usually the market keeps these entities honest. Do shit work that's over budget and you lose business. But there is no market at play here, thus the govt needs to play the part of the market and penalize for this behavior but they do not. /Endrant
- Joker_vD 6y agoWell, you see, if you get the work done earlier and under budget, then the next time you'll be given stricter deadlines and less budget.
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoBut if it's completed late and over budget, your company won't get the bid in the future because of your soiled reputation as long as there are enough competitors. Hence the reference to markets.
- belval 6y agoIn a perfect world maybe, in practice I doubt it. It's just not very human-like to take a lot of risk in large projects. If IBM takes a big project and delivers it late and over budget, they still delivered it so they will likely be picked for another project with the same low-bidding strategy.
- Joker_vD 6y agoAnd for projects internal to companies, there is usually no market or bidding (last time I heard of, anyway): here's the department's budget, go and deliver. You didn't manage to spend all of it? Next quarter, we're cutting your budget, and giving you a bigger project. Oh no, now you've overspent? Well, that's your fault really. As the proverbial wisdom goes, "to improve a dairy's profits you'd need the cows to give more milk and eat less food, so feed them less and milk more often".
- jcranmer 6y agoThis is basically part of the thesis that Alon Levy is presenting here. Essentially, the reason for the high costs is that the government lacks the management ability to recognize that the bids coming in are unreasonably low-balled, combined with subsequent difficulties actually overseeing the construction process.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoEven if the government has the ability to properly manage the process it does not bring it to bear because both the government bureaucracy and the contractor benefit from the waste of resources. The larger the amount of taxpayer money that is being spent the more opportunity for a larger more powerful bureaucracy to oversee the spending and more opportunity for profit by the contractor. The same mutually beneficial waste exists at the contractor to labor unions interface (union drives up cost, more $$ for them, contractor passes on cost, more $$ for them) and at beureaucracy to politician and appointed administrator interface (bigger bureaucracy more resources go to it and more power for the administrating officials). The only loser in the whole deal is the taxpayer who has to pay more for less.
- willyt 6y agoTypically it’s a rule introduced by naive politicians who say you have to take the lowest bid. In Britain this came top down from central government in the 1980s, previously it was more typical to take the bid closest to the average across of a minimum of three bids.
- somethingAlex 6y agoExactly this. I was at a "company retreat" back when I was in IT consulting. It was mostly the top salespeople for that year so I, being on the delivery side of things, found myself in a strange world. After some drinking one of the salespeople started talking about a project that went 2 months past the deadline. I asked "...and they just paid for that extra time?" Everyone got all awkward as I realized that not only did they pay for that, they would continue to pay us to go over deadline. I was the naive one. It's just one of those topics you don't talk about.
- throwaway-8c93 6y agoIn other words - different business environments create different equilibria. In Chinese/Soviet/1920s America equilibrium, with an insatiable demand for construction work, the profit maximizing behavior is to be done quickly in decent quality, then hop on to another project. In the modern western equilibrium, where projects are few and far between, the profit maximizing behavior is to extract as much revenue as possible from any single project, employ lawyers, ask for extensions, attempt regulatory capture, create an opaque chain of subcontractors, etc. - as it's not clear whether there will be any new opportunity to do so in the future.
- Ericson2314 6y agoWe have a winner! Zooming out a bit, this is why low growth is self-reinforcing. We need constant heavy demand to drive continual investment and productivity improvements.
- moate 6y agoYes/no? I mean I'm pretty sure there is massive demand for affordable housing (especially in Manhattan!) but there's no incentive for developers to shift towards that vs bilking the everyone out of as much as possible for more "high end" construction. The current system "works" for the people taking in the money, which they can then use to lobby the people giving the contracts to continue the current paradigm. As with most things related to capitalist enterprises I think the solution is pulling people kicking and screaming from their beds and dragging them to the gallows during a revolution, but that feels unlikely...
- epa 6y agoAlfred Chandler Jr described this as 'hidden unemployment'. The true social cost to society is high prices to support mostly inefficient jobs, this keeps people employed.