8 ms·
More sleep or more exercise: the best time trade-offs for children’s health
- timw0j 6y agoMy wife and I maintain that fixed bed times are still one of the best parenting decisions we ever made. They're getting a little later as our kids get older, but we can definitely tell when the kids haven't gotten enough sleep. They get squirrely and overly giddy, and their ability to focus on anything goes way down.
- fastball 6y agoFixed bedtimes works until your kids realize they don't actually need to go to bed when you want them to.
- koolba 6y agoAh, that's the classic Mike Tyson words of wisdom, “Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the mouth".
- blodkorv 6y agothey work if they naturally feel tired when you think they should get tired.
- astura 6y agoNot true, I never, ever felt tired at "bedtime" as a kid, ever. I would protest my bedtime pretty much everyday because "I'm not tired." Fixed bedtime still "worked" for me because when you're 1) on a firm schedule and 2) laying in bed without anything else to do then sleep comes.
- Oddskar 6y agoI would (perhaps naively) think that children are the same as adults in the regard that we both need ample amount of time to start slowing down and relaxing before bed time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- recursivedoubts 6y agoDragging growing kids out of bed at 6:30 in the morning day after day is insane, and I have to think it is driven by adult work needs (and ultimately by employers) rather than by any rational consideration of the children's interests.
- vmchale 6y agoWhere I grew up they staggered schedules for middle school/elementary school/high school so that the buses would be busy all day. So high school started early.
- finnh 6y agoThey are switching that in many districts nowadays, to recognize that young kids wake up early naturally while teens need to sleep in.
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoYou are correct. There is tremendous value in open door daycare policies. Some kids arrive 730 because thats their parents schedule. Others at 10 because little sam decides to sleep in. Its unfortunate that the assembly-line aspect of post-K schooling forces kids to fixed times which are often at odds with the children or even parent's needs
- hrktb 6y agoThis is the interesting takeaway from the current situation: lockdown exceptions directly reflect priorities, and while teachers and parents were crying bloody murder the school stayed open to allow people to go to work.
- kaesar14 6y agoThe amount of over-30s who will defend this on town Facebook groups by saying it's what they did and turned out fine is terrible. I get to sleep in and wake up for my intellectually demanding job whenever I want and I feel how much more I'm able to deliver because of it. It makes me sad to think about how much learning I missed out on as a 16 year old because I would be falling asleep in class so often.
- ianbooker 6y agoFrom the abstract of the study: "A 0.1 standardized decrease in adiposity was associated with either 52 minutes more sleep, 56 minutes less sedentary time, 65 minutes less light physical activity, or 17 minutes more MVPA." With MVPA being "extra exercise". Interesting, how light activity is negatively associated. For adults its often suggested otherwise..
- shureluck 6y agoI love how the majority of modern science articles are people basically proving common sense.
- dalbasal 6y agoThat kids can lose weight by sleeping?
- aantix 6y agoStrangely, everytime I've gotten into a consistent habit of going to bed at 9pm, I've lost some weight. I prefer staying up late, really late, like 3am. But along with the shorter sleep comes late night eating and probably a less efficient body function overall.
- avishibiscus 6y agotrue, staying up late sometimes is one of the best this to do efficiency and productivity wise, but in the long term its wrecking me bit by bit. Try going to sleep early and waking up early, same peace in mind and calmness around the city for your productivity, helped me a bit
- antidaily 6y agoI don't eat dinner until after 9. So this diet would definitely work for me.
- dalbasal 6y agoSure, I don't have trouble believing it. I just thought "common sense" was a little strong.
- smiley1437 6y agoThat's probably the most surprising bit - that sleeping an extra 52 minutes is equivalent to NOT sitting for an extra 56 minutes (in reducing your BMI by 7.4%) So -- if you're sitting down, you are better off going all the way to sleep?? That is definitely not intuitive! Or is that only for extending the 'full night' of sleep? I suppose if you are sitting and awake, you can still eat food, whereas when you're asleep you are probably not eating.
- aasasd 6y agoJust from reading through various health topics on Wikipedia, I'm now pretty sure that exercise influences much more than just fat and muscle mass. All the way to having anti-inflammatory effect because muscle secretes some stuff, working as an endocrine organ. So if you decide to sleep more, perhaps you want to sacrifice something other than exercise. Also I don't know how anyone can take BMI by itself seriously.
- rajin444 6y ago> Also I don't know how anyone can take BMI by itself seriously. BMI is very useful if you're looking at large data sets. BMI for individuals is not very useful. I'm not sure of the efficacy of BMI for ~1200 data points.
- aasasd 6y agoSo the entire use of BMI starts with the assumption that its increase can only mean more fat. I practically can see the headlines: ‘BMI on the rise for the past decade, obesity epidemic in Jocktown! We need even more gyms!’
- rajin444 6y agoExcluding massive biological changes (we're not going to start carrying more water or drastically increasing bone density), you gain weight by adding muscle or fat. Adding muscle is generally healthy (not in the case of heart disease, organ growth from steroid abuse, etc.) and also very hard. Adding fat is very easy. It would incredible if our population was adding a substantial amount of lean body mass. Are there any other causes you could think of that would cause a BMI increase across a sufficiently large data set that would not be caused by fat?
- mmmmmbop 6y agoAre there actually any schools that start later than usual, say at 10am or 11am? All I can find online is lots of articles about how schools should start later, but somehow no schools that actually offer that. If there aren't any, how come?
- alistairSH 6y agoQuite a few high schools in the US have flipped their start times, moving the older students to a later start. But, that's only relative to other schools, so might mean a 9am start for teens instead of 7am. I haven't heard of any schools starting later than this, nor I have I heard any place discuss doing so (at least not as a serious proposal).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TaupeRanger 6y agoThe discussion here is, frankly, better and more informative than the study or article, which was cross-sectional (non-randomized, population full of unknown confounding variables) and largely doesn't tell us anything meaningful that we didn't already know from firsthand experience or introspection.
- alistairSH 6y agoIt isn't specifically mentioned in the linked article - did the study account for "more sleep = more activity"? I know I'm less likely to be active when I'm exhausted - there's a direct link between my overall stress level (physical+mental) and my amount of exercise.
- ralfn 6y agoKeep in mind that that is an American problem. Here in the Netherlands and most of Europe kids go to school independently. They are not constant prisoners of adults stuck in american suburbia where one can only safely go from A to B by car. Here, they just make a sandwich themselves. Grab their bike and go to school when school starts. The schedule of parents might mean the parents are already gone. The schedules do not need to be in sync and mom isn't the kids drive around slave.
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoFor what it's worth, there are many areas in the U.S. where the infrastructure would reasonably allow for this and it's more a question of whether the parents would allow it. Even where this isn't possible, it's very common for schools to offer buses from extremely near to their homes to the school, which is a process that as you have pointed out, parents do not necessarily need to be involved in.
- aaroninsf 6y agoLooked for this in comments. Here in SF our kids have some of this independence; but their school is still miles away. I walked to my suburban school in the 70's. SF has density to permit some independence but then undoes the benefit of that with its schooling model and chaos. Pre-pandemic my kids could take MUNI. I biked with them. The bike ride is not bad but is too dangerous for kids who have not yet developed paranoid city road awareness. So my spouse or I got with them every time.. But this is already an unusual circumstance. Among urban friends in other places I can't think of more than a handful whose kids were independent in this fashion. Here in the Bay Area places like Fairfax let you live the dream though... it seems plausible that if the ground shift to "hybrid" or full remote is real and sustained, there will be even more reordering of lifestyle and population in pursuit of this. That would be a silver lining...
- ericcholis 6y agoThis is how my experience was after about age 10. I was close enough to school that I could choose to ride my bike or take the bus. I would get myself out the door every morning and usually make it home before any parents. I've recently read that the erosion of free-roaming children has increased exponentially in the years that I've since graduated highschool.
- desktopninja 6y agoFascinating. Personally recommend following as close as possible to one's circadian cycle. I do believe though, overtime one can adjust it to best fit the location (in the world) you're in.