3 ms·
>> And, yes, Deep Blue was just "a bit of symbolic manipulation you can do in Lisp" at a very large hardware scale. Modern chess engines use the same approach
by YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago
>> And, yes, Deep Blue was just "a bit of symbolic manipulation you can do in Lisp" at a very large hardware scale.
Modern chess engines use the same approach as Deep Blue, on much smaller hardware. IBM certainly tried to position Deep Blue as a triumph of large hardware, but its success is widely recognised as being owed to its minimax with alpha-beta cutoff algorithm. I can't imagine anyone who would call minimax "brute force"- it's a search algorithm and alpha-beta is a heuristic pruning technique. It's very hard to see pruning of any kind as "brute force"; rather that's the whole point, you prune a search tree to avoid an exhaustive search.
The evaluation function was hard-coded, yes, according to human expertise and chess theory. Note that Deep Blue also had an extensive "opening book" which if I remember correctly made it possible to play a very strong early game.
In any case, it took a few decades to create a system like Deep Blue and it was far from "a bit of symbolic manipulation in Lisp" but scaled up. I recommend the Adversarial Search section in Russel and Norvig if you want to develop a more thorough understanding of the relevant approaches (probably fourth edition will do).
>> Creating Deep Blue's hardware in 1997 was the most impressive achievement.
Can you point to other achievements in symbolic AI that were not as impressive as Deep Blue? Do you know of any others that you could compare to Deep Blue?