3 ms·
I barely made it half-way through the article, it sounded like an United Colors of Benetton add adapted into a Nobel-winning Economics paper. Just a couple of
by paganel 15y ago
I barely made it half-way through the article, it sounded like an United Colors of Benetton add adapted into a Nobel-winning Economics paper.
Just a couple of gems that made me skip it:
"""
they may well be more driven by ideas, simply because they have less information about the world outside
"""
So, supposedly, us, the rich people, live in the "real" world, why them , the poors, live in a world from which they cannot see "outside". Ok, I got it.
"""
She would also read to us books on Mother Teresa, on African children, etc
"""
Mother Teresa and African children in the same sentence, what's this, "feel-good bingo for well-off people"? Also notice the "etc" after "African children", that's a first.
And I could go on and on. In case anyone's curious (and before you start downvotting me), I'm furious about the condescending tone of this article because some time ago, when I was 15-16, my family went from middle-class status to poverty (meaning less per US$ 1 per day per person) in a very short time. I can still remember my mum, an engineer by training, going to the market place early in the morning to sell home-grown parsley. She gave me most of that money in order to pay for private math-lessons given by my high-school math teacher (that was the only way to get into CS school). I still try to help my parents as much as I can, but 10 years later they still rely mostly on subsistence agriculture. But, nevertheless, they're happy with it, that's their life, they have their small piece of land, they garden it, they live under the sun in fresh air and not in a God-forsaken cubicle with artificial lights, and my dad would look very strangely at these "rich", paper-writing people who think he's living in a "different", lesser world.
- felipemnoa 15y ago"that was the only way to get into CS school" Couldn't you just have gone into a community college and move on from there. It is a lot cheaper and lot of the professors are actually pretty good. If your grades are good you should be able to transfer into a decent 4 year college.
- lsc 15y agoIf his family is living on USD$1 per day, most likely he's not from a country that provides such services.
- Duff 15y agoI share your disgust. Personally, I have a real problem with academics or journalists who go on a junket to a third world country and act like the people around them are animals in some zoo. Look at any western family for a similar period of time and no doubt you will spot all sorts of bizarre dysfunctions or irrational behavior, regardless of wealth. People are people.
- mkr-hn 15y agoHere's an instructive contrast to the poverty safari: http://www.getrichslowly.org/blog/2011/03/01/from-the-rich-to-the-poor-or-what-i-learned-in-africa/ http://www.getrichslowly.org/blog/2011/03/01/from-the-rich-t... And GRS comments are worth reading.
- roundsquare 15y agoI disagree. These people are academics who want to help the poor. They go in and try to figure out what could help them and then write about it to help policy makers. It would be nice if policy makers could just figure out what works and do it, but that isn't working, so someone needs to run experiments. What would you prefer they did instead?
- Unseelie 15y agoI do not understand your point. Yes, there's fucked up situations in every economic status, but if we follow your argument to its roots, that each level of economic welfare has the same level of utility to its members, you're arguing that healthcare, decent food, and basic shelter are without value. You've said your parents are perfectly fine, and ergo, no-one else is worse off.
- yummyfajitas 15y ago...the rich people, live in the "real" world, why them , the poors, live in a world from which they cannot see "outside"...lesser world The value judgments ("real world", "lesser world") are your own invention. They do not exist in the article. Information deprivation is a real issue for the poor in many places. For example, before mobile phones, farmers were unable to deliver their crops to the location with the highest prices. I don't understand what you feel is condescending - Banerjee and Duflo are applying standard economics to the poor, mapping their utility functions and designing interventions with desirable policy outcomes. Economists do the same thing to CEOs, smokers/fat people, politicians, home purchasers and many others. Why is economics condescending when applied to the poor?
- cdavid 15y agoThis is all the more puzzling because their work contributed to significant and practical solutions against poverty (http://www.ted.com/talks/esther_duflo_social_experiments_to_fight_poverty.html http://www.ted.com/talks/esther_duflo_social_experiments_to_...). There is nothing condescendant in their approach (randomized experiments). On the contrary, it goes against the usual "big plan, big project" idea so common in aid policies. There are arguments against the approach (Chris Blattman sometimes write on his blog about them). But in any case, they advanced the debate.