3 ms·
Having failed a couple papers in educational theory classes for proposing vaguely similar ideas, I'll give you the standard criticism: How does this maximize th
by Alex3917 18y ago
Having failed a couple papers in educational theory classes for proposing vaguely similar ideas, I'll give you the standard criticism: How does this maximize the child's intrinsic motivation to learn? Which isn't the same question as 'will this be fun,' which you make the case for. But rather, will this make kids the kind of people who want to check out non-fiction books from the library on their own ten years from now.
- whacked_new 18y agoThis standard criticism makes a very strong case, doesn't it? I was recently talking to someone experienced with making educational software. He said that Indiana Jones is full of bad archaeology, but causes surges in archaeology major enrollment numbers. Inspiration probably precedes motivation. Before inspiration: understanding, control, and application? In this sense an educational application with a competitive/game component is not enough to build inspiration that lasts beyond the duration of the game, which would have very narrowly defined goals.
- whacked_new 18y agoWere your papers failed because they had radical ideas, or debunked ideas (that said, can any educational theory ever be thoroughly debunked, all hard facts accounted for)?
- Alex3917 18y agoWell, I turned one of them into this K5 article so you can judge for yourself: http://www.kuro5hin.org/story/2004/12/8/2135/17844 http://www.kuro5hin.org/story/2004/12/8/2135/17844 Actually, that one I wrote in October 2004, and one of the biggest problems with it was that the professor had never heard of Wikipedia and didn't think that the site could ever possibly succeed. (The first drafts were more Wikipedia-centric, but a lot of that got cut out of the final version.)
- kleneway 18y agoGreat article, thanks for providing a point of view from someone who's not talking out of their a$$ (aka me). The wiki idea is very, very interesting - it's got that same "I'm not doing this for money but to help the world be a better place" vibe that (imho) is what makes Wikipedia successful. There are valid criticisms of this approach in the comments, namely that it would require a very strict quality control process before educators could trust it. Otherwise, millions of children would grow up thinking that Stephen Colbert really did single-handedly triple the elephant population.
- Alex3917 18y agoI'm not sure I would still agree with everything I wrote though, so take it with a grain of salt. (Although I haven't actually reread it recently.)
- whacked_new 18y agoGiven its brevity (in terms of length and citations), I suppose this writing is making a personal case for PI, from a mostly theoretical standpoint? The mention of Skinner threw me off in the beginning, but my feeling is the PI you mention isn't a behaviorist one, but a metaphorical one? If so, I absolutely agree with this idea, and think we have enough technology to make it a reality.
- Alex3917 18y agoYeah there is a lot of stuff in there I wouldn't say today. That's why I linked to it, as an example of my failing to understand intrinsic motivation.
- helveticaman 18y ago>But rather, will this make kids the kind of people who want to check out non-fiction books from the library on their own ten years from now. That's a really tall order.
- Alex3917 18y agoWhile we don't know much about building intrinsic motivation, we do know a lot about the factors that undermine intrinsic motivation. So in practice if you can avoid all these, and you make the process both enjoyable and useful, then at least you're on the right path.