5 ms·
Consumer CPU, APU, Server CPU, Semi-Custom ( Consoles ), are all doing great as expected. What is missing is the GPU big picture. I dont see evidence of AMD dis
by ksec 6y ago
Consumer CPU, APU, Server CPU, Semi-Custom ( Consoles ), are all doing great as expected. What is missing is the GPU big picture. I dont see evidence of AMD discrete GPU winning any market shares and seems to be dominated by Nvidia.
AMD only have two more years to enjoy their advantage from Intel's multiple missteps. After that it is going to be tough. And that is excluding the threat from ARM.
- rubatuga 6y agoUnfortunately, the software tooling gap between Nvidia and AMD has widened significantly for GPGPUs. AMD has also left the enthusiast video card market in the dust with their lack of ROCM support. Nvidia has some seriously cool tech that they showcased at GTC 2021 this year, like speeding up algorithms for bioinformatics, and new CPU/GPU combinations for autonomous driving. I would guess that the immense amount of R&D spent by Nvidia is causing this gap.
- kd913 6y agoThis is the kind of thing where the whole Xilinx acquisition is gonna make a play. Bespoke accelerator FPGA solutions are the future and will probably scale a lot longer than CPU/GPU combinations.
- davrosthedalek 6y agoI really doubt that. FPGA is really power and silicon intensive. A more traditional "many 'fixed function' processor" a la GPU will beat it for any algorithm which at least semi-successfully maps to the provided operations. And most math is matrix multiplication anyway, if you squint your eyes and hold your tongue at the right angle ;) (I use "fixed function" loosely here. It's not a fixed function T&L pipleline, it's meant in the "the circuit is fixed but can execute arbitrary code" sense.)
- kd913 6y agoYou can doubt it all you want, but this is where Xilinx Alveo is coming into play. This isn't my space as I operate on low-latency networking side. > A more traditional "many 'fixed function' processor" a la GPU will beat it for any algorithm which at least semi-successfully maps to the provided operations. And most math is matrix multiplication anyway, if you squint your eyes and hold your tongue at the right angle ;) I don't think it is as simple as this. Certainly not for low-latency scenarios or for HPC efficiency where the gains are done my moving as much computation as possible onto accelerator cards and off the CPU. The cost of moving things back and forth from the CPU can be expensive (data especially). We are already seeing dedicated solutions from Google, Graphcore that beats the pants off the traditional GPU/CPU approach.
- davrosthedalek 6y agoHow does FPGA fabric solve the bw bottleneck exactly? What solves it is putting the compute power closer to the CPU (or memory). But you can do that with an FPGA or a GPU, or a CPU matrix etc. Compared to FPGA, the others will have much more compute power(especially for HPC) in the same die size/heat envelope.
- kd913 6y agoI think the idea is to bring the compute power closer to the storage or NIC devices. At least that is the impression I am getting from their smartNIC/smartssd device. In this case being video streaming in from the NIC, encoding/decoding occurring directly on the NIC. Same to a degree with the bespoke smartssd where if you have some complex encryption, encoding, decoding or data driven application than the processing happens directly on the storage device via the FPGA.
- floatboth 6y agoIt's really disappointing that the GPGPU space isn't adopting Vulkan all that fast. These "compute specific" things such as OpenCL/CUDA/ROCm should not be necessary and should die. Just use Vulkan for fuck's sake.
- rubatuga 6y agoLibraries like cublas and cudnn help the GPU scheduler assign tasks to specialized blocks on the graphics card. Vulkan would slow this innovation down severely. Unless they make Vulkan extensions? I’m not too sure how that would work. Personally I haven’t used CUDA, but if anybody could comment on its ease of use compared to Vulkan that would be great.
- floatboth 6y ago> help the GPU scheduler assign tasks to specialized blocks Source? I can't find anything for '"cublas" scheduler'…
- merb 6y agoit will get worse, since nvidia lifted some IOMMU limitations in their consumer cards: https://nvidia.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/5173/~/geforce-gpu-passthrough-for-windows-virtual-machine-%28beta%29 https://nvidia.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/5173/~/g... this is a big deal especially since ai tech advanced.
- slowwriter 6y agoI think you’re underestimating the trouble Intel is in. They are being absolutely stomped on by both AMD and Apple in terms of performance/efficiency, and if it wasn’t for such high demand it would reflect heavily on sales. Also, AMD has begun R&D for ARM processors whereas that is nowhere to be found in Intel’s roadmap.
- greenknight 6y agoAlso remember that AMD had Jim Keller back in the day, for an integrated ARM / x86 CPU. They have done a lot of R&D already to date, not something recent!
- modeless 6y agoIntel isn't being stomped on by AMD and Apple. The stomper is TSMC (and Samsung to a lesser extent). Without TSMC, M1 and Zen 3 don't exist. (Quite literally in the case of Zen 3, as you still can't buy one!) It's all about the fabs.
- slowwriter 6y agoGood point, Intel’s primary weakness at the moment is definitely that they are failing at progressing their own fabrication process
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zibzab 6y agoYou have been able to but Zen 3 laptops for a good while now. Not sure about desktop CPUs thought. But that's mostly because of apple reserving TSMC entire 5nm line, so AMD is still on 7nm (although they look extremely promising even on an older node)
- pedrocr 6y agoZen 3 laptops haven't even been properly announced and are definitely not shipping. Even the Zen 2 models are in very short supply. Desktop Zen 3 is what is shipping and quantities are very limited as demand is very high.
- lhl 6y agoI agree that the state of AMD's dGPUs still leave a lot to be desired, but they've been making some progress at least. On the consumer side, RDNA2 is raster, transistor, and power (albiet on a more efficient node) competitive with Ampere, which is big step up from previous generations. Thanks to having performance competitive top-end/halo cards, AMD GPUs have gotten a consumer mindshare win that they haven't had in years. RDNA3 should be even more exciting, with another big rumored perf/efficiency gain and their first MCM implementation. It should be exciting to see not just RDNA3 vs Lovelace, but also to see how Intel's DG2 changes the dynamic, since budget and mid-end competition has been completely non-existent lately. Everyone's selling all the chips/boards they can make atm due to largely to cryptomining and other supply chain issues, so I guess AMD gets a mulligan until next-gen (especially considering how currently for AMD, every GPU made means giving up 10X the profit on enterprise CPU cores due to shared die capacity constraints). The other thing worth noting on the consumer side is that Zen 4 should also bring Navi 2 and DDR5 to their APUs. AMD's current APUs can already handle most eSports/low-end games at 1080p [1] but this next iGPU bump has the potential to displace the low-end AIB/dGPU market completely. When looking outside of the AIB numbers, AMD (and Intel) continue to increase unit shipments/gain market share at Nvidia's expense. [2] As for GPU compute, there's no question that Nvidia continues dominate and it feels like if anything, AMD is falling further behind. While I have some hopes for CDNA/2 and ROCm continuing to mature, their ongoing lack of support for even basic stuff like desktop OpenCL or any RDNA cards means that AMD is moving backwards as far as ecosystem support goes. I really can't think of a better way to stunt adoption than to have no ML/compute support for the majority of their products. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ On the process side, assuming Intel suffers no more delays on 7nm (a big assumption), it will still be half a step and half a year behind TSMC's N3 process in 2023 (beyond that, I suppose it'll be an open question of who gets their GAAFET working). AMD's CPU architecture team has a pretty solid track record at this point though, and I don't think Zen 4 or Zen 5 will be at any particular disadvantage vs Granite Rapids. Obviously, AMD has lots of competition, but as long as they keep executing, I think they have a pretty bright future (also, we'll have to see how Xilinx plays out). [1] https://static.techspot.com/images2/news/bigimage/2021/04/2021-04-13-image-39-j.webp https://static.techspot.com/images2/news/bigimage/2021/04/20... [2] https://www.jonpeddie.com/press-releases/gpu-shipments-soar-once-more-in-q4 https://www.jonpeddie.com/press-releases/gpu-shipments-soar-...