6 ms·
Bill to kill up to 90% of Idaho wolves heads to governor
- ohgreatwtf 6y agoThe amount of laws being written by various state legislatures as well as congress is just far too damned high, and there is no benefit to it at all Legislature members should not be able to introduce or edit laws, only debate them and provide votes along with their opinions on why their vote decision matters and what could be done to influence it. Laws should be drafted via popular referendum and stakeholder discussion and only introduced for an approving vote once the people have had a chance to vote on whether or not it should be considered in the first place. This was the opinion of dr. gaddafi in his seminal work, the green book. I think getting a statistical majority of people involved in the legislature process would be tedious without the internet but we do have the power to engage in direct democracy by using internet based systems to disseminate briefings, collect votes and opinions, and encourage discussion, just like on ycombinator. This won't happen before the fall of civilization, of course, because those in power are too corrupt to surrender their authority, but, it could still be done in some forward thinking states and munincipalities. Lawmakers would still be free to draft and vote on so-called binding policy resolutions that directly alter regulations based on laws already in effect, operating within the constraints of the authority and intent of the law but altering implementation to best suit the need of the moment.
- legerdemain 6y agoTo be sure, "Dr. Gaddafi" here is Muammar Gaddafi, the late dictator of Lybia. Go wolves!
- voidfunc 6y agoUnfortunately "doing nothing" is often seen as negative option, but I would absolutely prefer if our government, legislators, and executive branch members just did less... stop constantly needing to add more mud to the mud ball. It's very reminiscent of the software industry where we just cannot seem to stop tinkering.
- agogdog 6y agoThe old "we need to continue destroying the ecosystem because we created unforeseen problems by destroying the ecosystem"
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alexfromapex 6y ago"The Idaho Fish and Game Commission, which manages the state’s wildlife, opposed the measure. " Then why are they doing it? This sounds like a bad decision being made in haste. Why not explore options like relocating them to somewhere they're needed?
- hindsightbias 6y agoLegislators and people on the internet know better than scientists.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoOr they have different values. One of the things politicians say is "we are going to follow science" to avoid making a value decision. Science can tell you the risks/benefits/tradeoffs of a decision, but you have to ultimately make a value judgement about the best course of action. Science can tell us various things about what the wolf does and what its loss or population reduction is expected to do within a certain confidence interval. Politicians are the people, ultimately charged with taking that information and making a value decision about what to do.
- jjeaff 6y agoAs you said, both sides can follow the science and make different value judgements. Unfortunately that rarely seems to be the case. For example, the pandemic, it seems most people agreed that shutdowns and masks were acceptable to save that many lives. However, politicians did not make the trade-off argument. They generally just challenged the science completely. First, that the pandemic was even real, then that it was deadly, then that shutdowns helped and that masks helped at all. So yes, arguments of values can be made, but it seems rare that these frank discussions actually happen in politics. At least not in public.
- tjs8rj 6y agoI think you’re misrepresenting the other side. Trump JR never said covid wasn’t real, he said “it would disappear the day after joe Biden was elected” the suggestion from the context being “Democrats are blowing the situation way of of proportion for political gain”. The conservative argument on the danger of the virus is that it’s dangerous to old people and those with preexisting conditions, but not very dangerous to healthy people who are relatively younger. This is a valid subjective interpretation of the science. Whether something is safe or dangerous is a value judgement. The CDC originally said don’t mask, that you can get it from surfaces, that it spreads through the air instead of droplets. For the lockdowns, the conservative argument was that they were too extreme given the costs, something like “destroying the global economy disproportionately hurts the people least affected by the virus: labor, small business owners, children, students, and so on, while having little effect on the relatively richer but more affected old”. The point was that lockdowns didn’t justify the costs. I don’t agree with most of this, but you’re so far off the mark with the strawman of these arguments that I don’t think you’ve seriously understood them beyond immediate dismissal on partisan grounds. If we did this pandemic over again, but it was a dem President going into an election year, I think Dems being anti lockdown would’ve been the most obvious outcome, because lockdowns hurt the exact people the party calls its constituents: lower classes, people of color, labor, young people, etc, while most benefiting the wealthier and older population.
- roflchoppa 6y agoWe should not be interfering with key-stone species.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoHumans have been interfering with key-stone species for millenia. Lions used to be relatively common throughout the Middle East, but it seems during the Neo-Assyrian Empire were hunted to extinction. I believe the Romans drove a lot of animal species in North Africa to extension because of the circuses. We need a much more nuanced analysis than just don't interfere with a key-stone species.
- mceoin 6y agoThe effect of removing keystone species has been extensively studied, particularly with respect to wolves. Just google "keystone species" and the first result features a case study on grey wolf removal and restoration in Yellowstone: https://www.nature.com/scitable/knowledge/library/keystone-species-15786127/ https://www.nature.com/scitable/knowledge/library/keystone-s... Wolf impact on livestock is minimal, coverage is overblown, and in most states is investigated and compensated for by state authorities. This is a terrible political move.
- mgarfias 6y agoDon't forget the native north american horses, or mammoths or other megafauna that the native americans hunted to extinction.
- fasteddie31003 6y agoI have mixed feelings on this. Humans modify their environment to benefit themselves. We eliminated the Grizzle Bear from California and I kinda think that is appropriate. I do believe predators benefit the ecosystem to a point. Using this same logic, would humans benefit if we had predators hunting us? I bet a lot of the pro-predator rhetoric comes from people living in urban areas with little connection to rural life.
- adamcstephens 6y agoI’m pro-wolves because they are a keystone species that keeps the entire ecosystem in check. I’d happily let predators into my urban area, cause the deer and geese cause their own damage. If some house cats get eaten, that’s not so bad for the native bird population either.
- crygin 6y agoSmaller towns here in the northwest that have developed suburbs over the last decade or two are overrun with deer, because coyotes have been displaced. It's a real problem.
- sliken 6y agoEr what? Coyotes don't eat deer.
- abstract_put 6y agoWhat would keep a coyote from killing deer (particularly young deer)? I'm not sure where abouts you are, in Eastern Ontario coyotes eat deer. A quick search shows multiple sources that support the same dynamic in various places in the US as well.
- sliken 6y agoHeh, ok, I stand corrected. My impression was that was it was mostly wolf and mountain lions that eat deer. I dug around and found a few studies that mentioned that heavy snow let to more coyote deer hunting. Then several other studies that tried to tease out if coyotes cause additive predation (increase in mortality rates) or compensatory predation (killing deer that would die anyways). Found a summary of the related research papers claiming "None of these studies found any evidence that coyote removal caused an increase in the deer population." another two studies found "Removal studies with white-tailed deer populations also show that coyote removal does not affect overall population growth." Seems like the general conclusion is that coyotes have stabilizing effect on deer herds, which seems about right from a healthy ecosystem point of view. Similarly wolves help stabilize various populations, even of distant species like song birds, beavers, trees and other plants. Thanks for the correction.
- zabzonk 6y agoAnd yet here in the UK we are thinking of reintroducing wolves, as has already been done with beavers.
- paulmd 6y agothey did. we paid a lot of money to reintroduce wolves. you did, your taxes did. https://www.boisestatepublicradio.org/news/2020-01-14/25-years-ago-wolves-were-reintroduced-to-idaho https://www.boisestatepublicradio.org/news/2020-01-14/25-yea... https://www.idahopress.com/postregister/farmandranch/idaho/wolf-reintroduction-to-idaho-creates-conflict/article_e4c7b475-91cf-5b7f-8d76-a7140e331442.html https://www.idahopress.com/postregister/farmandranch/idaho/w... same thing in michigan. it's emblematic of how the culture has shifted far to the conservative. environmentalism is out, the farm lobby is powerful, and now we'll straight-up shoot the wolves we spent so much time reintroducing. at this point it's just another bullet in the culture war more than anything. farmers want them gone and doing so will piss off the libs, so why not? > “That was the camel’s nose,” says former Gov. C.L. “Butch” Otter. “The unintended consequences were the fact that after the introduction, even with the denials, the populations of wolves exploded, the federal government had control of them, and they weren’t going to turn it over to the states.” killing the wolves will piss off the libs and show Washington who's boss and that's what conservative states want.
- zabzonk 6y agoSometimes I think we should have open season on farmers - bullies, over-entitled, funded by our taxes, people that close off public rights of way, and so on - that's the stereotype of the farmer for most urban UK citizens. Possibly the same in the US. Having said that, possibly some animal introductions are not particularly desirable. My younger brother was once savaged by a coypu (not a European species) in the French countryside, and had to have stitches and tetanus and rabies injections. Also, they destroy river-banks.
- spfzero 6y agoWell it’s the ranching lobby rather than the farm lobby, unless wolves have started eating corn. And ranchers have been killing wolves in the west for hundreds of years, so it’s not a new culteral shift. Personally though, I think if you want to start a sheep ranch in an area where wolves have lived for thousands of years, I’m not going to feel too sorry about what happens. You’d be smarter to pick a different place. No one’s reintroducing them into new habitats, just their legacy habitats.
- snypher 6y agoI don't understand why I can't hire private contractors on snowmobiles with night vision goggles to protect the wolf species.