3 ms·
Kinda hate to see those share buybacks. You'd think with an organization that large they could think of something useful to do with fifty billion dollars.
by jeffbee 6y ago
Kinda hate to see those share buybacks. You'd think with an organization that large they could think of something useful to do with fifty billion dollars.
- paxys 6y agoWhat's weirder is that a large chunk of expenses for these companies is stock-based compensation for employees, and then they cancel it out by doing buybacks. Maybe try just handing out cash?
- colinmhayes 6y agoGiving out equity is a decent incentive to innovate I guess.
- nocommentguy 6y agoNot weird considering that capital gains are taxed lower than ordinary income.
- paxys 6y agoRSUs handed out by all large companies are also taxed as ordinary income.
- plantain 6y agoa) jurisdiction dependent, it's a bigger company than the US. b) if they issue RSU's at $Y, then buyback stock to drive the price up to $Z, the employee's take $Y as ordinary income, and $Z-$Y as cap gains, which is usually taxed more favourably
- varispeed 6y agoMostly because they are used by party donors and other wealthy people who "influence" politicians. When everyone gets paid in dividends, they'll find different mechanism for the wealthy to extract money and tax dividends just like any other income.
- polishTar 6y agoI think the idea is to align the financial incentives of the employee with the financial incentives of the company. Some companies (usually pre-revenue ones) might also do it to reduce cash expenses, but that seems unlikely to be Google's motivation in this case for the reason you pointed out.
- nocommentguy 6y agoShare buybacks are equivalent to dividends. They are done when the company can’t think of how to hit their target ROI on that margin. Much better to pay back investors than invent “something useful” to spend money on a la government budget game theory.
- panarky 6y agoDividends are taxable when paid, while share buybacks aren't taxable as long as you don't sell.
- computerphage 6y agoAnd even if you do sell, they're taxed as capital gains instead of income.
- thorwasdfasdf 6y agoit's merely a symptom of not having enough opportunities to invest in. Their workforce (and many large software companies) is already too large for the amount of opportunity available. Even, world famous software engineers like Stevie yeggie had to eventually quit due to lack of impactful things to work on. In the absence of any opportunity, all you can do is share buybacks or dividends, or maybe give out even more employee compensation.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 6y agoGoogle is already pursuing some extremely expensive bets - GCP (see people upthread complaining about this), Waymo. At some point, it’s hard to spend any more money productively and the best thing to do is return it to shareholders to do as they please. Google could blow all the money buying Coinbase or something, but shareholders would probably prefer Google give them the cash to made that decision individually.
- jeffbee 6y agoThat private parties hold funds of this magnitude but can't imagine what to do with it, while the country languishes without railroads and housing, indicates to me that taxation might be a little low.