8 ms·
This article feels extremely confusing... maybe someone here can clarify? Nothing appears to be "deteriorating" whatsoever. According to the article, in March
by crazygringo 6y ago
This article feels extremely confusing... maybe someone here can clarify?
Nothing appears to be "deteriorating" whatsoever.
According to the article, in March we imported 1.5x as many goods as in March 2019, as retailers restock inventory. Which is amazing that such increased shipping capacity exists. And because there's so much demand for shipping, shipping prices are rising.
This seems... great? We're successfully restocking tons of stuff, but higher shipping prices mean that retailers will continue to give priority to what people are buying, and so a full post-pandemic restocking will be smoothed out over the rest of the year, rather than all at once?
I mean, scheduling restocking seems pretty flexible and can therefore respond intelligently to prices.
This article seems like everything is going great. What's deteriorating? What's the "tsunami"...??
- adrianmonk 6y agoThis article is written for "FreightWaves" which is "The Fastest Way to Navigate the Freight Market". The target audience is people who need to ship stuff. For them, service levels are deteriorating. What is normally easy has become a struggle.
- lazide 6y agoIt’s a tsunami of freight - 1.5x March this year over 2 years sounds decently typical considering normal growth. The issue is that April/May/June it wouldn’t be odd considering the circumstances if it was 5x or 10x - if there was enough containers, or enough ships, and there isn’t. As TFA was pointing out, it isn’t even about rising prices to get a spot. Sometimes you can’t get a slot period. Remember all those supply chain shocks and people talking about needing to restock to get things working in chips, manufacturing, etc? Right now there is 100 containers of socks stuck on a ship and in the way. At least, that is what I got from the article.
- CameronNemo 6y ago> Right now there is 100 containers of socks stuck on a ship and in the way. This seems like a real easy problem to fix. Some simple import tariffs could get a lot of the cruft out of the way in no time, and they could be eased back too.
- gonesilent 6y agoWe still have Trump's tariffs to deal with, more will just be yet another burden on consumers.
- CameronNemo 6y agoThese aren't perma-tariffs meant to punish consumers. These tariffs would just take enough goods off of the ships so that essential goods can pass through. In 4-6 months, they could start phasing out. Maybe even sooner.
- dkdk8283 6y agoTrumps tariffs are designed to bring back jobs to the USA. We shouldn’t be giving so much money to China.
- lasagnaphil 6y agoThe real problem is that because of the dollar’s (still) hegemonic status as the world reserve currency, dollars will never be cheap enough for manufacturing jobs in the US to come back. Trump’s tariffs really can’t do anything about it.
- Retric 6y agoHigh shipping costs are effectively a tariff on bulk goods. It’s not particularly effective as shortages drive up prices.
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoSadly I don't think it works like that. Ignoring the usual long lead time on tariffs, and the difficulty in applying such rules (Socks now have 10x import duty. Ah but not medical support stockings. And socks on baby clothes are exempt, but if the socks are sold as a bundle ...) The real problem is that the cruft is already in the system. If we did something clever and said all non-urgent shipments get delayed and the urgent ones come through we would have 1. Some containers have both important and cruft in them. 2. The cruft containers are on the upper port side of the ship. If we don't unload those the ship will topple. If we unload but don't onward ship we have a ton of containers literally sitting on the dock. 3. If we sort that out, the cruft orders are part of the game now - the container of socks is going to come back loaded with medical computers. But now they don't have a container to come back in. No the solution to this is transparency. A global blockchain / ledger (not The blochchain), would let people see some of the worst problems ahead. But that tech exists, but not the usage of the tools or the trust.
- fencepost 6y agoTried to buy a printer lately? Perhaps a computer? Part of the crap availability is likely due to the chip/component shortages that have gotten a lot of press, but some is also due to shipping. I was looking at low- to mid-range workgroup printers and business-class desktop PCs for some clients recently. From at least some manufacturers the ones that were available were selling for at least $50-100 above MSRP depending on models, or you could order at normal prices (don't bother looking for discounts!) with estimated delivery end of May or in June. This article makes me think there's a chance those might be optimistic.
- WWLink 6y ago> Tried to buy a printer lately? I did! I noticed B&H had the model I wanted in stock, but the store was closed over the weekend for a holiday. So I checked back right before the store opened and placed the order JUST as it JUST as ordering opened up again. Not 5 minutes after I ordered the printer, the page went from "in stock" to "more on the way" lol. I received the printer a week later. Most places had it a month+ out. Ugh, and that was easy compared to getting some computer parts right now.
- Stratoscope 6y agoA few weeks ago I got a new ThinkPad X1 Extreme from work to replace my awful System76 Thelio Major. I was interested in checking out the X1E because I was due for a personal ThinkPad upgrade too. Last week I decided I liked it and went to see what Lenovo had available. All of the nice X1E's with the UHD display were showing "more than 12 weeks" delivery time! The next day I remembered that the ThinkPad P1 is exactly the same machine as the X1E with a different GPU. Lenovo is wacky like this with their model names. Some of those were showing 8-12 or over 12 week delivery too, but they had one P1 configuration in stock the way I wanted with UHD, 64GB, 1TB and an empty SSD slot. It shipped the same day I ordered it, arrived Friday and is great! And was just $1625 plus another $149 for three-year premier support since I ordered it through Corporate Perks (who I highly recommend). Would have been $900 more if I bought it directly on lenovo.com, even at their "sale" price. The machines ship direct from Lenovo either way. So I thought I'd tell my friends and colleagues and checked again yesterday. Nope, all gone now, this model went up $200, and it along with all the other nice ones are "more than 12 week" delivery too.
- johncalvinyoung 6y agoThis situation is a mess for anyone waiting on something that's sitting in a container in Shanghai, or on a ship in the queue in Long Beach. A friend's business has a critical LCL shipment that was supposed to arrive to their supplier (likely receiving a whole container, but not many containers) last week, but is stuck on a ship somewhere. That's stressing out my friend the logistics manager ahead of an upcoming product launch. And no telling what the next product in queue is going to take in terms of component sourcing. Yikes.
- kossTKR 6y agoIs it just me or does it seems like a lot of things are headed for disaster? The positive thing is that a lot of capital is floating around ready to be invested in a coming post-covid boom, but at the same time hundreds of thousands of companies worldwide are either already bankrupt or close to - then there's these shipping issues that seem non resolvable in the near term - and worst of all a lot of industries already seem way overvalued, especially the housing markets i many cities. If the economic bubble bursts, then shipping slows down while thousands and thousands of companies close, and is bought up by megacorps laying off millions to automation and centralisation, while QE and other tools are slowly becoming unfeasible because of the gravity of climate change and a disappearing petrodollar hegemony. So many confounding factors ending in an inflationary nightmare! Is this take way too pessimistic?
- ping_pong 6y agoIf I understand correctly, if you want to get something shipped, you can't pay a fixed price anymore. You have to pay spot, which is exhorbitant. So not only is there a massive delay in getting your goods shipped, there is a massive extra cost.
- heliodor 6y agoI got the opposite understanding from the article. People are willing to pay extra for immediate needs but the slots are sold ahead of time: > For the month of May, everything on the trans-Pacific is basically sold out. We had one client who needed something loaded in May that was extremely urgent and who was ready to pay $15,000 per container. I couldn’t get it loaded
- maxgashkov 6y agoWe're a small export shop based in Japan. It's becoming increasingly difficult to find containers to ship even to APAC region. 'Difficult' = not just expensive, I'm talking we're not able to get on the ship period, no matter how much we'll pay. So, for us service is deteriorating because we're not able to fulfill obligations and lose money. For our customers service is deteriorating, because they are not able to buy goods that will be delivered in a timely fashion. This goes on for 3-4 months now, and this is definitely a problem, even if it doesn't look so from outside.
- angry_octet 6y agoIt seems like time insensitive freight is absorbing 100% of capacity, so the spot price is going vertical. Big customers are getting most of their freight booked, but no slack is hurting ad hoc shipments. Like a short squeeze.
- reillyse 6y agoIt’s not an efficient market.
- angry_octet 6y agoIt beats me why companies are not reselling their future freight contracts. If I was, e.g., shipping 500 TEUs of carpet that was a restock, I'd consider selling some on the spot market. But the mechanisms to do this at scale are not in place. It highlights that liner companies (e.g. Maersk) are leaving cash on the table by selling capacity at rates which don't reflect demand, although perhaps they prefer long term stability. I also wonder if significant demurrage costs were incurred by the logjam at ports, and that disincentivized charter shipping for a period.
- xxpor 6y ago>It highlights that liner companies (e.g. Maersk) are leaving cash on the table by selling capacity at rates which don't reflect demand, although perhaps they prefer long term stability. It seems like there's an opportunity here for a bidding based shipping company. I can't even begin to fathom the time or capital required to start a new container shipping company from scratch though these days.
- tbabb 6y agoIt's sort of analogous to "thrashing" in computer software. Once a resource is overtaxed past a certain point, the inefficiency of being in an overtaxed state causes the system to handle the load even worse than in normal conditions, which exacerbates the overload, causing it to get worse ad infinitum.
- treeman79 6y agoWhat spend money on real ram. We can use the hard drive as free memory. At 12 I learned a lessons about that thrashing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]