3 ms·
Why does anyone think you can get people to be ethical just by teaching them ethics? Knowing what other people say about ethics doesn't have a clear path to str
by whatshisface 6y ago
Why does anyone think you can get people to be ethical just by teaching them ethics? Knowing what other people say about ethics doesn't have a clear path to strengthening your conscience, which is the only "motivation" most people have to be ethical in the first place.
- remram 6y agoIt might not make the companies/professors ethical, but might help the employees, grad students, or more importantly test subject notice bad behavior.
- cptskippy 6y ago> Why does anyone think you can get people to be ethical just by teaching them ethics? Because you can teach ethics in much the same way you teach security best practices. Lots of developers practice security theater without actually believing it's all necessary. The same can be done with ethics.
- fallingknife 6y agoPeople who write insecure software typically didn't intend to, so you can teach them. People who do unethical things intended to do unethical things, so teaching is useless.
- cptskippy 6y agoI would argue that Hanlon's razor applies. Most people aren't thinking about ethics, they're just trying to solve a problem. When a product manager asks them to implement a dark pattern to trick users into clicking something, they aren't thinking "heh... fools, I'll show them", they're thinking "Sure thing boss, whatever you say". It's not that these people are unethical, it's that it's never a consideration. I was in a meeting once where business was discussing abandonment and it was suggested that if a user filled out a form 100% but never clicked submit, it was reasonable to assume that after 20 minutes if the window was still open then we should just automatically submit the form because that was their intent. There was no malice in the thought or question of ethics, the person who suggested it thought it was a helpful suggestion and would improve the product and reduce abandonment. When I framed it from the perspective of the end user they quickly shot down their own idea.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Why does anyone think you can get people to be ethical just by teaching them ethics? Teaching ethics isn’t about getting people to be ethical who aren’t inclined that way, its to make people who are basically well-intentioned aware of ethical issues in the field and get them in the habit of thinking about ethics in the context of the work, both in planning and executing their own and looking at other work in the field of interest. > Knowing what other people say about ethics doesn't have a clear path to strengthening your conscience, which is the only "motivation" most people have to be ethical in the first place. Teaching ethics isn’t about motivating ethical behavior any more than teaching compilers is about motivating people to write them.
- kwertyoowiyop 6y agoI’m going to be generous and propose that most people behave ethically most of the time, including the UMN researchers. There is a lot of discussion in this thread about the basic question of whether or not the project was ethical. Anyone can have a blind spot when making such judgements. An ethics course could help people better understand the principles of ethical behavior, which would lead to a logical shared conclusion about this. In other words, I think it’s as much about knowledge as it is about conscience.
- asciimov 6y agoThe decision on the ethics of this experiment isn't up to us, nor was it up to the researchers. It should have been left to an IRB for an approval, which most likely wouldn't have approved of this research in its current state. The lack of oversight is the problem. Because now it calls into question the work of the grad students, the papers sponsor who oversaw the work, the department, and the school as a whole. It is a significant damage to their reputation. At some of the research places, doing unapproved research is grounds for immediate termination, regardless of tenure. As for the students, they would have been investigated, most likely expelled for ignoring protocol or denied their credits for the semesters the research took placed and put on academic probation. The department as a whole would also be looked into.
- grandmczeb 6y agoAt least according to the researcher’s letter[1], the UMN IRB did look at the study after the fact and determined approval wasn’t needed. > The IRB of UMN reviewed the study and determined that this is not human research (a formal IRB exempt letter was obtained). [1] https://www-users.cs.umn.edu/~kjlu/papers/clarifications-hc.pdf https://www-users.cs.umn.edu/~kjlu/papers/clarifications-hc....
- rriepe 6y agoYou're thinking of morality. Ethics are just the rules that an organization follows. It's more about process, expectations and standards than it is about any particular moral imperative.
- fhrow4484 6y ago> Why does anyone think you can get people to be ethical just by teaching them ethics? Because studies say so? https://mitsloan.mit.edu/ideas-made-to-matter/can-ethics-be-taught https://mitsloan.mit.edu/ideas-made-to-matter/can-ethics-be-... "The central finding is striking: those passing the older exam, with more rules and ethics coverage, were 25% less likely to commit any kind of misconduct"
- jvanderbot 6y agoRight: If everyone knows something is wrong, people are less likely to take the risk of getting caught. Even if it's not those bad actors who change, the bad actors don't act badly because everyone else would recognize it as wrong.
- jvanderbot 6y agoBy showing what is right and wrong to those who are conscientious enough to act as watchdogs and whistleblowers. You can't make a bad actor good by showing the rules, but you can make a neutral actor aware of exactly what needs to be reported, and give them a forum. Without training, right and wrong are not normalized and standardized, leading to fuzzy feelings and confusion about what can be done.