5 ms·
The biggest problem with "alternative" platforms is just the lack of app support. I used to have a Nokia N9; great phone. But it didn't support WhatsApp and I
by arp242 6y ago
The biggest problem with "alternative" platforms is just the lack of app support.
I used to have a Nokia N9; great phone. But it didn't support WhatsApp and I was out on the loop on the WhatsApp chat all my other coworkers were in.
Then there's things like banking apps, flight check-in apps, food ordering apps, dating apps, etc. etc. Can you do without those? Sure, of course. But if I want to order food where I live then the only option is to use an app.
No platform will have any chance of any sort of adoption unless it supports some way of running those apps. There are options here, for example Jolla/Sailfish OS can run Android apps (no idea how well that works in practice; the latest update says it supports "Android 9, and the support for Android 10 is already nicely on the way").
It's a "vendor lock-in" ecosystem that's worse than the Windows lock-in of yesteryear IMO.
Since I don't really use my phone all that much I decided to "just use an iPhone" (because it's the only phone that's not huge), even I think they're really horrible.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- skykooler 6y agoI use Sailfish OS and the android compatibility layer is decent, but not perfect. Some apps have issues understanding the network connectivity state, and photos taken with the Sailfish camera app sometimes don't show up in the Android file selector until the compatibility layer is restarted. Other than that, most apps work fine. (I mainly use it for spotify, slack and maps.)
- Calamity 6y agoUnless PWAs really took off, in which case, you wouldn't need to develop for the custom linux phone - you would just need a supported browser.
- ficklepickle 6y agoPWAs will continue to be neglected. They don't allow invasive tracking like native apps, and they don't get a 30% cut. The web is dead. Kids today grow up using the "google app". They did what AOL couldn't. I'd love to be wrong.
- megous 6y ago> It's a "vendor lock-in" ecosystem that's worse than the Windows lock-in of yesteryear IMO. For regular companies, if they want to shoot themselves in the foot by not being on the web, they're welcome. It's not such a huge issue as it would be with government for example. Also "any chance of any form of adoption" is a bit overstatment. I still use a dumbphone, and if I migrated to pinephone, lack of the kind of apps you mention would certainly not concern me. Even then, many apps have web alternatives here, or alternative GPLed clients for Linux (that includes whatsapp, apparently), that can be made native on pinephone.
- arp242 6y ago"Not being on the web" doesn't seem like a huge footgun. There are probably more people with a mobile phone and no traditional computer than the other way around, especially if you go outside of the US and Europe. Revolut, Grab, Gojek, Tinder, WhatsApp, and many more are all successful that offer a mobile-first solution, with either no web/desktop client or just as a an additional client (usually with fewer features, and/or still requiring access to a smartphone). > Also "any chance of any form of adoption" is a bit overstatment. I still use a dumbphone Of course it's possible; but depending on what your interests in life are you will pay a price, and in practice for the vast majority of people the price is too large to use a non-Android/iOS compatible device. > many apps have web alternatives here, or alternative GPLed clients for Linux (that includes whatsapp, apparently), that can be made native on pinephone. Unless they somehow hacked the encryption, you're still going to need a connection to the phone's WhatsApp client.
- Vrondi 6y agoIf you're using Whatsapp, you've got zero interest in privacy anyhow, and so you're never going to consider these issues in the first place.
- mdoms 6y agoWell first of all that's just total BS, but secondly this thread isn't even about privacy. None of this is. In fact your comment is the very first mention of that word in this thread.
- swiley 6y agoI keep hearing this and it's totally wrong. Desktop Linux has a huge app ecosystem and arguably has more high quality software than Android does. All of this works on the pinephone and other similar devices.
- arp242 6y agoOkay, so how can I chat to my friends or companies with WhatsApp on Linux? How can I order food similar to Grab or Gojek on Linux? How can I get a date on Linux like Tinder? You can't. Sure, there are technological solutions to all of those, but in the real world that alone is pretty much useless.
- ta9999 6y agoTinder does have a web interface, so does doordash (I've never head of Gojek but I'd imagine it does too.) I thought WhatsApp also had a web interface but I wouldn't use it anyway and there are similar chat apps that do so why would you?
- arp242 6y ago> I've never head of Gojek but I'd imagine it does too. You imagine wrong. > I thought WhatsApp also had a web interface but I wouldn't use it anyway and there are similar chat apps that do so why would you? The web interface is just a proxy to the phone app. The other "similar apps" don't have all my contacts on it.
- Vrondi 6y agoYou can use Watshapp multiple ways on Linux, including the web browser version [https://itsfoss.com/whatsapp-linux-desktop/ https://itsfoss.com/whatsapp-linux-desktop/]. Although, if you're using Whatsapp at all you're either massively ignorant or stupid. I mean, giving Facebook your phone number is just not wise.
- arp242 6y agoAnd you still need the phone app for that Linux client; everything is routed through that. Good grief, I keep bloody repeating this. Do you people actually read anything? > Although, if you're using Whatsapp at all you're either massively ignorant or stupid. I mean, giving Facebook your phone number is just not wise. I'm a normal human being who values social contact and doesn't want to pester all my friends in using some other app, and a lot of businesses use WhatsApp here too. I am neither "ignorant" nor "stupid". This is literally the worst of HN right here. Do you even listen to what people have to say and consider perspectives outside of your own?
- Vrondi 6y agoYou can do the banking (from most banks) and food ordering from a web browser on your smartphone. No apps required. Grubhub, Uber Eats, Doordash, all those sorts of things. Most of them have a web version, and you can use that instead of an app most of the time. Just shake loose the Apple-induced app mentality that keeps you locked in.
- arp242 6y agoAside from that most of those specific services aren't available in my location, you really can't. Do you think I'm stupid and haven't tried?
- sneak 6y agoA lot of hardware devices require use of an app these days. Any with wifi will also require use of location on ios and are thus unusable if you have location services disabled systemwide. I just returned some IP cameras recently because of this.
- summm 6y agoNo, it's the bad hardware. With high-end hardware, it would be no problem to just run something like anbox and immediately have most of the important apps running. Except asshole apps that require DRM/safetynet of course, but I don't use them on my current android phone anyway.
- pmlnr 6y ago> The biggest problem with "alternative" platforms is just the lack of app support. Websites.
- meltedcapacitor 6y agoI dream of a dual phone (conceptually 2 phones glued back to back) where you do web and open stuff on one side, and the inevitable proprietary apps on googled-android on the other side, with a quick button to freeze the prop side (for power saving and mitigating spying). (Or same where the 2 phones are somewhat multiplexed on a single screen, preferably in hardware.)
- fsflover 6y agoYou can do it on Pinephone with two different independent operating systems, one on the eMMC storage and the other on the microSD card. When you put in the microSD card, the devices boots from it. Otherwise it boots from the internal storage.
- anoncake 6y agoBecause of this issue, open APIs should IMO be mandatory for all commercial services.