6 ms·
> if the subtle bugs were not detected, they corrected and removed the latent bugs and educated maintainers who accepted them. Last I looked, this was claimed
by yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago
> if the subtle bugs were not detected, they corrected and removed the latent bugs and educated maintainers who accepted them.
Last I looked, this was claimed but unverified since they have yet to give any way to identify the patches in question.
- fluidcruft 6y agoPublicly disclosing the patches would actually harm the reputation of any maintainer who accepted them and expose them to harassment and potential employment issues, so I strongly suspect an IRB would not allow it. It's entirely possible to fix bugs and educate without disclosing that the bugs were deliberate or part of the research.
- zymhan 6y agoYou're skipping the part where the IRB would have to approve injecting vulnerabilities into a public software project, a process which involves obfuscating and lying to humans.
- fluidcruft 6y agoRight, but according to what's said about the study design, they (1) fixed an existing bug (2) introduced a new bug, and if maintainers didn't notice the new bug, (3) followed up with a patch removing the new bug Overall there's benefit in that an existing bug is removed and no introduced bugs persist. I don't see why IRB would be likely to object to this.