3 ms·
People keep confusing publishing with distribution. She's self-distributing, not self-publishing. In fact, her publishers in the UK and the US are getting a cut
by eridius 15y ago
People keep confusing publishing with distribution. She's self-distributing, not self-publishing. In fact, her publishers in the UK and the US are getting a cut of the Pottermore sales. The fact that users won't be able to download the books via the Amazon and iBooks stores but have to go to Pottermore and download the (presumably ePub) ebook directly are a consequence of her self-distribution. And it's a terrible idea. Users love centralized stores where they can find all their content with a single search, and most users have never run across an epub outside of these stores. If you can't search for it on Amazon or iBooks, it might as well not exists as far as these casual users are concerned.
Yes, obviously the popularity of Harry Potter is going to do a lot to teach casual users about the ability to get eBooks via other mechanisms than the centralized stores. But it's akin to trying to sell the physical books using a small independent bookstore (that just happens to be in everybody's town) but not stocking it in the big chains such as Borders. And really, it just strikes me as greedy. The only compelling reason to try and self-distribute is to avoid the 30% cut that Amazon or Apple would take. She's couching this as being a DRM-Free maneuver, but providing DRM-free ebooks on your site doesn't mean you have to take them off of the centralized stores too. Anybody who cares about the DRM issue can get it from you, and everyone else can get it from the store. And it may surprise you to realize that the DRM-laden books from the iBookstore are far more convenient for consumers than DRM-free epubs. I can buy a book on my iPad, then re-download it later on my iPhone without having to remember where I got the original epub or without having to manually sync it on to the device. And I can easily delete it when I'm done reading it and then re-download it again if I want it back for whatever reason. And I believe Amazon's Kindle app has a very similar experience.
J.K. Rowling, I love your books, but don't you think you're rich enough already? Give up that 30% and let me have my convenience back.
- maggit 15y agoThe lack of convenience of epub-books is caused by the lack of content only available in epub format. If DRM-free epub books were to become the dominant format, the convenience would come. You argue that Rowling must be doing this for the money and that she will likely sell fewer copies because the distribution channel is foreign to the buyers. This doesn't quite add up. The other extreme analysis would suggest that Rowling is sticking her neck out for epub, trying to push it to the dominant position to force ereaders to take the format seriously. Both analyses are extreme. The truth usually lies between the extremes.
- eridius 15y agoI don't understand your position. The iBookstore is purely ePub. Amazon has already said they are adding ePub support to Kindle. ePub is already the dominant ebook format for interchange (I don't consider PDF to be ebooks). If Rowling were to sell her books on the iBookstore, they would be every bit as much ePub as if she distributes them herself. What's more, the iBookstore doesn't mandate DRM, so even the argument that she's doing this in order to promote DRM-free is a red herring. Sure, by all means distribute the ePubs yourself. Rowling can publicize DRM-free ebooks using the ePub format. But there's no reason for her to avoid also selling her books on the existing bookstores. Let the consumer choose which place to buy their book from. The only reason that makes any sense to avoid selling on the iBookstore is a desire to avoid giving the 30% cut to Apple. And convenience goes out the window as a result.
- maggit 15y ago> I don't understand your position. That's fully understandable. I based my comment on several misunderstandings. So, with my newfangled knowledge, I might say that "self publishing of epub books" would become awesome if it were more common. Instead, however, I will refrain from digging myself deeper into this hole :)