5 ms·
If you want to understand the USA or figure out why something here is the way it is, the answer is usually "because it lets corporations extract the most money
by ryandrake 6y ago
If you want to understand the USA or figure out why something here is the way it is, the answer is usually "because it lets corporations extract the most money out of regular people." Everything, from seemingly odd little cultural quirks to enormous institutions like how we do health care, systems that were deliberately designed and things that emerged organically: everything is the way it is because it optimizes wealth transfer from ordinary people to corporations. That's usually the most straightforward explanation.
- kilroy123 6y agoI wish more people realized this.
- ycuser2 6y agoA little bit off-topic: If you want an explanation in Germany what things are the way they are, it's often because "otherwise the insurance wouldn't pay in worst case".
- unityByFreedom 6y agoGiving loans is a good thing. With them, as the comment above yours points out, people finance education, cars, and homes that they can afford to pay off later due to having a higher salary than before. Predatory loans are bad and governments do try to crack down on those. Going from "it's easy to get credit in the US" to "the US lets corporations steal from regular people" is a bit much.
- dmos62 6y agoI somewhat agree with what you said, but I think you sidestepped the intriguing question of why so many people in US seem to use credit.
- leetcrew 6y agotime value of money and capital gains tax make it less efficient to pay cash for large purchases. why don't people in the rest of the world use credit?
- xwdv 6y agoMoney now is worth more than money later, why is that a hard concept to understand?
- dmos62 6y agoFor one, I've never felt that way. If I were a business, that might be different.
- unityByFreedom 6y agoI don't think I sidestepped it. People use credit to better themselves because they can. Maybe you are asking why more capital is available to lend and I think that's a good question.
- yrro 6y agoOn the other hand, the abundance of credit has driven up the prices of education, cars, homes, etc.
- Caprinicus 6y agoCar prices in America are among the lowest in the developed world though. It’s difficult to compare education as you’re getting a wildly different product depending on what specific university you go to.
- ntwalker 6y agoThey pretty much have to be. The infrastructure of the US is such that if cars cost what they do in Europe then a massive section of the population would be entirely locked out of the economy unable to hold a job.
- klmadfejno 6y agoWhen people need something, prices tend to go up, not down.
- TapWaterBandit 6y agoYou've got this backwards. 1. The average American is considerably wealthier than the average European. 2. Cars are so expensive in Europe relative to America due to regulations/taxes/etc which are applied by governments (the alleged protectors of the people's welfare). 3. You've got causation backwards in regards to infrastructure, the US infrastructure is the way it is BECAUSE cars are cheaper, cars aren't cheap due to the needs of infrastructure.
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoGiving loans with 0 interest is a good thing, however, giving loans with anything above 0% interest ins a terrible thing. We've known this for literally thousands of years.
- unityByFreedom 6y agoIf you're willing to give me an interest-free loan then I will take it and invest it in an index. Generally speaking, discounted loans are only available from governments or friends for specific purposes like education or health when they want to invest in people. Even then you still have people taking advantage because money is fungible. It's hard to do this in a sustainable manner.
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoThe premise is that the economy must not be based on loans, it's not sustainable as we are seeing today (not to mention it's parasitic). Loans are given out for charity purposes. If you want to invest your money, there are many moral ways.
- frockington1 6y agoId rather take a 30 year mortgage out at 4.5% and invest it elsewhere as 4.5% is less than my expected return.
- patentatt 6y agoAnd mortgage rates are much lower than that now too, <3% is quite realistic
- frockington1 6y agoI recently heard Denmark has negative mortgage rates for natural born citizens. Losing money if you don't take it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- watwut 6y agoThere is something wrong about punishing people who don't want loans, however. And making it necessary to have or use credit card, so that you build up your credit score in a maze of rule, despite you consistently being able to pay with debit card or cash is exactly that.
- ImPostingOnHN 6y agoThey aren't being punished by not using credit cards, they're just choosing not to avail themselves of the benefits of using credit cards. If you pay your bill every month, then a credit card is like a debit card plus benefits like up to 20% of the purchase value in points, not to mention benefiting from the time value of money.
- watwut 6y agoCredit score matters for whole host of things like when you want to buy a house. So yes, you are penalized for not having it. > benefiting from the time value of money This is just nonsense. There is no additional gain from waiting till end of month till you pay.
- ImPostingOnHN 6y agoI'm sorry, my post must have given the impression that I was talking about credit scores instead of credit cards, which is what I was talking about. As for your other point, if there were no benefit from floating money for 2 months, then there'd be no benefit from doing that an indefinite number of times, which conflicts with the time value of money, an established, mathematically basic concept.
- refurb 6y agoThat’s a very cynical view and not accurate. Having lived in other countries, I actually missed the benefits that robust competition drives. Consumers in some countries are paying fees that went away 20+ years ago in the US. And as grandparent says, the robust protections offered in the US are a huge plus to consumers. In other countries they aren’t so generous as to forgive fraud and the like.