4 ms·
My impression is that there are already way too many people working for the military industrial complex. It would be much better if the US would scale down the
by lispm 15y ago
My impression is that there are already way too many people working for the military industrial complex.
It would be much better if the US would scale down their oversized military and then it also might consider working on goods that advance the life of people and which might actually be interesting to others so they can be sold.
The military jobs is actually one reason the US lacks competitiveness in some areas (see the huge trade deficit).
This works so: getting rich is very important.So young people go to finance and other gambling like activities. The more engineer interested people find jobs in the military. There they work on extremely costly projects like nuclear aircraft carriers, nuclear submarines, nuclear weapons, drones, fighter planes, etc. These projects come with a huge price tag. The technologies used, the specifications used, the processes used are mostly incompatible with what a civil market needs. So the military engineers are naturally trained in the wrong direction. For example a vehicle constructed for the military is heavy, provides protection, has a huge payload, is robust, has infrastructure for certain types of equipment, etc.. Think of a tank or a hummer. Most of these requirements don't fit into what is needed for, say, automobiles. There we need to look at design, comfort, fuel efficiency, etc. But the US cars mostly (not all) are oversized, bulky, fuel inefficient, ugly. Why? Because the engineer culture constantly has an influx of different values coming from military engineering.
For them it is more important to drive securely through the streets of Bagdad, and not through some large US city.
Now, I think there is a need to work on topics like cyber security, but it may help at the same time to reduce other projects like the large spying agencies and much of the military. Currently these are expanding in the wrong direction.
- berntb 15y agoAs a counter argument, consider DARPA. They do important R&D that no one else do. (As far as we know; it is a relatively open process). You could make quite a good argument that military, academic and industrial research are partly orthogonal; they complement each others. But I can agree that to waste money and really build the military equipment is mostly a waste of money. :-)
- lispm 15y agoThe D in DARPA is for 'Defense'. For some time it was just ARPA. They added the D so that nobody makes the mistake to misunderstand the nature of their research: advanced research for military. Automated warfare, weapons of the future, soldier of the future, robot drones, ... The other stuff like material, sensors, etc. is just basic research needed for weapons. I would propose to shift the research money to projects like cleaning up nuclear weapon production sites, energy efficiency, cleaning the old coal power plants and more. Probably more people are endangered by the emissions of the aging coal power plants than from enemies in foreign countries...
- berntb 15y agoMy point was, the research money for DARPA are well spent -- and probably increase human science and technology in better ways than most any other use of that money. Including e.g. emergency health care. If you have that much trouble with weapon research I'm sorry, but don't throw out the advanced prosthetics with the water. (Sorry for coming in late.)