2 ms·
Giving up the fight yields the better outcome only when the other party doesn’t come over and eat you or kill you no? It isn’t about dominance over all - it’s
by lazide 6y ago
Giving up the fight yields the better outcome only when the other party doesn’t come over
and eat you or kill you no?
It isn’t about dominance over all - it’s about survival and the complex intertwining of all the various strategies (good, bad, failing) being tried simultaneously with the hope that theirs wins. Sometimes it’s domination. Sometimes it’s teamwork. Sometimes it’s passivity.
As any individual player, you have to pick one - and sometimes it wins, sometimes it loses. Most strategies exist not because they are always ideal, but because having the selection is essential and necessary to long term survival in a fundamentally unpredictable environment. A species that only does one strategy at once is going to go extinct when the environment changes suddenly.
I’m definitely not equating all actions as equal, or saying everything has equal cost. I’m noting that nothing, including no action, has no cost, and that assuming a player in the game (you or someone else) will definitely lose or definitely win for a given survival criteria has a very low degree of predictive accuracy in the real world.
- rhn_mk1 6y agoOf course, you're right about survival. Sometimes the rational strategy is to fight. What I'm contesting is the view that predicting outcomes is useless. I gave the example of economies and ecosystems together with prisoner's dilemma to illustrate that we do indeed have a models that are accurate in predicting at least first order effects. First order effects are not everything, of course, but it doesn't seem sensible to throw away our knowledge coming from game theory (or cybernetics? or plain life experience) and settle on not being able to predict which choices are net positive and which are net negative. As with any estimation, there will be those that can't be evaluated with any certainty, but also clear winners and losers.