4 ms·
It'd be great if we could get to substantive debate instead of thought-terminating cliches like 'who gets to decide'. A moment's thought will suggest a range of
by anigbrowl 6y ago
It'd be great if we could get to substantive debate instead of thought-terminating cliches like 'who gets to decide'. A moment's thought will suggest a range of possible answers, and one can then advocate for one's favorite. It's unhelpful to stymie discussion of real phenomena by throwing up one's hands in performative horror.
None of these institutions can be trusted, therefore the idea of "controlling misinformation" itself is anathema to a free society.
I think the institutionalization of lying is anathema to a free society, because honest people waste valuable time debunking liars, and it's faster to spread lies that truth.
How about you offer some positive suggestions for engaging with that issue instead of negating others' attempts to discuss it?
- Sophistifunk 6y ago> How about you offer some positive suggestions for engaging with that issue instead of negating others' attempts to discuss it? How about I don't, because in a free society nobody gets to vet what dumb "news" I'm allowed to see.
- Covzire 6y agoAh yes, the "Stop wasting your time demanding your freedoms and tell me exactly what will finally convince you to bow down to me" defense.
- zarp 6y agoDefinitely agree that important problems like this require diverse opinions and meaningful dialogue, but I don't feel that pointing out the failures of human institutions is an attempt to shut down discussion. Rather, I think the point being made was that we need to reframe the problem at hand; instead of trying to "control misinformation" maybe we need to work on ways to _amplify_ true information in ways that render misinformation powerless.
- anigbrowl 6y agoThat'd be great, but suggestions like that are in short supply. Education for better truth-detection is a popular one, but takes a long time to pay off and doesn't amplify, as such.
- livinginfear 6y ago> "It'd be great if we could get to substantive debate..." We've had substantive debate after substantive debate on this issue. The "thought-terminating cliche" of "Who gets to decide" really is the only sensible conclusion to this issue. The ability to be heard is to wield political power. "Big Tech" organizations understand this. I don't believe for a second that the concern-trolling that follows this topic around is ever in good faith. The movement for so-called "anti-misinformation" is an application of political power. This debate has been forced on society by online platforms who have become a bottleneck on the proliferation of information, and are using it as a means to protect their own interests. > "I think the institutionalization of lying is anathema to a free society, because honest people waste valuable time debunking liars, and it's faster to spread lies that truth." Every side of a political debate thinks that the other side is either misinformed, or dishonest. The interests of political entities with diametrically opposed views cannot be reconciled. The SPLC and someone like David Duke (I had to grasp for an example here) probably both think that a great bulk of their effort is spent debunking the lies of the other, and what can we conclude from that? Is there any empirical proof that either is lying and that the other is correct? > "A moment's thought will suggest a range of possible answers, and one can then advocate for one's favorite" What happens when all of the answers support incompatible, irreconcilable worldviews? (see above)
- TuringTest 6y ago"Who gets to decide" is clear: oneself, by listening to what others have to say, and using that to build your own web of trust about who to listen to. "What happens when all of the answers support incompatible, irreconcilable worldviews?" You mean, as with all the information that exist in the world? That is a direct consequence of there being more than one person with the ability to think. The solution to that is to get informed, carefully selecting and contrasting your sources, and building a mental model of your own. It doesn't hurt when others publish their own views on what they think of others' statements. What hurts this process is when their comments are based on demonstrably false information.
- textgel 6y agoCorrupt authorities are happy to label anything they don't like as "demonstrably false" so we're back to square one.