5 ms·
I'm wondering more about the effects the increased cleanliness will have on people's immune systems --- all the masking, social distancing, constant hand saniti
by userbinator 6y ago
I'm wondering more about the effects the increased cleanliness will have on people's immune systems --- all the masking, social distancing, constant hand sanitiser use, etc. is, in addition to reducing exposure to COVID, also reducing the exposure to the countless other pathogens that people are normally exposed to. Does the lack of exercising ones' immune system have a cost too?
- jakeogh 6y agoThe masks aka 'face coverings' are the easily the dirtiest objects in the airstream of the unfortunate people wearing them. The psychology is beyond bad. https://www.pnas.org/content/118/17/e2018995118 https://www.pnas.org/content/118/17/e2018995118 https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7010e3.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7010e3.htm (nice margin of error... 1.5% lets wear them forever!) Why not forever? Why not cover the eyes too? Maybe the whole head? Even better... why leave the house? Wouldn't that be be smarter? Perhaps... masks... at home?. Maybe a class of special Amazin' vans could fulfill every delivery need? Even sex would be safer. https://www.cosmopolitan.com/uk/body/health/a32754935/wear-face-masks-sex-coronavirus/ https://www.cosmopolitan.com/uk/body/health/a32754935/wear-f...
- antibuddy 6y agoYour hyperbole will not fly well here. Generally speaking the rationale behind masks is heavily flawed and there is yet to be a study to prove that masks help in a pandemic. They sure work for limited amounts of time in specific use-cases, especially with training and when you can wash your hands before putting them on. Day-to-day for longer durations at a time they seem detrimental actually, due to the fact that you have to touch your face more often (especially with glasses), wear them for too long and reuse them often.
- freeflight 6y ago> Generally speaking the rationale behind masks is heavily flawed and there is yet to be a study to prove that masks help in a pandemic. This is only anecdotal, but as somebody working in healthcare, mostly with autoimmune compromised patients in ambulate care, there's most certainly been a very noticeable effect among those patients, and even myself. I will usually get a cold at least once, sometimes twice a year, forcing to take sick days. Yet that last year I wasn't sick once. We've had to administer way less antibiotics therapies, the hospital stations we work together with are super happy about how well their patients are doing now, particularly the children. Kind of funny to think about: The way we've been living for a year has always been their way of living. But when we all do it, that apparently even gives a kind of "herd protection" to those who really depend on these measures not to get sick.
- antibuddy 6y ago> This is only anecdotal, but as somebody working in healthcare, mostly with autoimmune compromised patients in ambulate care, there's most certainly been a very noticeable effect among those patients, and even myself. And that is certainly due to masks? I ask because there are generally speaking more measures in place, especially in hospitals/nursing homes like fewer visitors (if any) for example. > We've had to administer way less antibiotics therapies, the hospital stations we work together with are super happy about how well their patients are doing now, particularly the children. And again, is that due to or despite using masks? But since I am questioning the rationale, it would be nice if there would be a good explanation why it is better for symptomless people to touch their face more often, wear masks beyond their intended duration and reuse them (because it is impractical otherwise especially with mandatory medical/FFP2 masks)
- freeflight 6y ago> And that is certainly due to masks? I didn't specifically point masks out anywhere, it's most certainly the combination of all kinds of measures, but wearing masks and taking care of proper hand hygiene has been a rather normal part of life for many people with autoimmune diseases for a long time before any pandemic came around. In many Asian countries it's absolutely normal to wear a mask when sick, to prevent further spread possibly to the weaker among society. That's done not because we like to make people do things, we do that because it's been established as good practice in these circumstances. > But since I am questioning the rationale, it would be nice if there would be a good explanation why it is better for symptomless people to touch their face more often A hygiene regime isn't some binary thing where one failure of perfect compliance ruins the whole effort. Particularly with examples like "touching face more often", why would you even do that? You put on the mask and you leave it on, the constant touching, particularly with dirty hands, is really down to a lot of people being lazy/careless or trying to wear the mask as little as possible. > wear masks beyond their intended duration and reuse them (because it is impractical otherwise especially with mandatory medical/FFP2 masks) Their intended duration is, once again, a best case scenario often designed for completely sterile conditions. Depending on the use a FFP2 can easily last a week. Just like surgical masks they can actually be handwashed with soap to get a good reduction of whatever might have collected up in there. Of course that doesn't work forever, just like this current situation ain't forever. But one could hope that we learn at least in a couple of places from this. Like the aforementioned example of people who caught something voluntarily wearing a mask, without getting weird looks. Somewhat more readily access to hand-sanitation is also a big plus, when previously a lot of people didn't really care about it, many still don't, even tho that's one of the simplest ways to stay healthier.
- mattmaroon 6y agoA lot of people wonder this first part and the answer is definitively no because immune systems generally don’t work that way. It’s (mostly) not something general purpose like a bicep. Getting sick with one diseases mostly does very little for you with most other diseases. You can lift weights at the gym and build your arm muscles, then use those muscles to lift or push other things more effectively, because muscles are general purpose tools. Most of your immune system is more like a key. It’s specific to one thing. There are some exceptions but overall the fewer viruses you encounter the better. As for the exercise: yes. There’s already preliminary evidence that exercise is highly coordinated with covid outcomes.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoStill lots of debate as to how the immune system works. If we understood it there wouldn’t be millions of people suffering from allergies (some who get it after moving to ‘clean’ western countries)
- frutiger 6y ago> As for the exercise: yes. There’s already preliminary evidence that exercise is highly coordinated with covid outcomes. GP asked “lack of exercising one’s immune system” not “lack of exercising” in general.
- xyzzy123 6y agoHi, I'm surprised by your "definitively no" as I understood this as still an open question - particularly with respect to autoimmune risks. Do you have any resources to help me understand your position better?
- skue 6y agoThere is the Hygiene Hypothesis, which is the reverse: Decreased exposure to some pathogens, especially when young, can make the immune system overly sensitive and thereby increase the risk of atopic and autoimmune disorders.
- riggsdk 6y agoOn the (maybe?) reverse: I grew up on a farm and later moved to a big city to study computer science. It was only then that my allergy kicked in. I wonder if that would ever have happened if I had gone the farming route in life :P In any case, life in the big cities seem to mess with our immune systems.
- bsou 6y agoThis may be due to what trees are planted in cities: https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/botanical-sexism-cultivates-home-grown-allergies/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/botanical-se...
- kevinmchugh 6y agoAre people still using lots of hand sanitizer? Why?
- ascorbic 6y agoMy kids have been coming back from school with the backs of their hands bleeding because they're so dry from being forced to constantly use sanitiser all day. This is because government guidelines have not been updated since it became clear that it's not transmitted by contact. We've had to tell them to use the smallest amount possible, and only on their palms.
- skinkestek 6y agoAs far as I'm aware the only reason to use hand sanitizer is because soap (which is more effective - again AFAIK but this has been told since the start) is even more damaging do the skin when done often.
- zo1 6y agoLet's not forget the incredible "convenience" factor of waterless hand sanitizer. Who needs a pesky basin, soap & running water when you can just spray this magical liquid on your hands and be done in a jiffy.
- aspaviento 6y agoThe purpose of the sanitizer is not to prevent contagion by contact, it's for you to make sure that your hands are clean before touching your face (mouth, nose, eyes). That's how you get infected, the virus get onto your hands for whatever reason and you touch your face. So technically it's true it's not transmitted by contact directly but it does indirectly.
- ascorbic 6y agoYes, I understand that, but that's still a vanishingly rare route of transmission. The way you get infected is by inhaling aerosols.