2 ms·
Life as we know it cannot start without at least iron, cobalt and nickel, besides the 5 lighter elements H, C, N, O and S. Iron, cobalt and nickel are the mini
by adrian_b 6y ago
Life as we know it cannot start without at least iron, cobalt and nickel, besides the 5 lighter elements H, C, N, O and S.
Iron, cobalt and nickel are the minimum set of elements required as catalysts and, as far as we know at this time, life cannot appear without them.
Actually life can appear using Fe, Co & Ni, when both dihydrogen and carbon monoxide are available in the environment. When only carbon dioxide is available instead of carbon monoxide, molybdenum or tungsten becomes also necessary.
So at least the elements around the iron peak are needed, which are produced in supernovas. Realistically, for the evolution of more complex life forms, also a few of the heavier elements that are produced in intense neutron fluxes are also required.
So no, according to current knowledge life was impossible 12 billion years ago and I cannot see any workaround, because the catalysts are at least as essential for life as the light elements that compose the bulk of the living matter.
- joshuahedlund 6y agoThank for those details. (And yes I get the arguments that "things could happen that are outside of our capacity to imagine" but while true at some levels it can only take you so far with fundamental finite properties like the number of elements in the periodic table and the compounds you can make with them)
- rbanffy 6y ago> according to current knowledge life was impossible 12 billion years ago At what point in time we can expect the first supernovas to seed planets with heavy elements?
- 1_person 6y agoMy understanding is that the earliest stars would have begun to form only a few hundred thousand years after the event and begun to explode not terribly long after that on account of their mass and rapid reaction rate, seeding the early universe with some amount of nucleosynthesis product almost from the outset. Of course, I think it was rather a while longer before it cooled down enough for things other than raging thermonuclear fireballs to find hospitable.
- mrfusion 6y agoHow does all life use tungsten? I’ve never heard of that.
- adrian_b 6y agoI have said "molybdenum or tungsten". Most living beings use molybdenum, but tungsten can replace molybdenum and it is used for this purpose by some living beings (mostly by Archaea). It is pretty certain that the common ancestor of all existing living beings already had molybdenum enzymes, while tungsten began to be used later, as an adaptation to higher temperatures. Nevertheless, there was a hypothesis that maybe before the oxygenation of the oceans tungsten was used in preference to molybdenum, because oxygenated molybdenum compounds are more soluble than oxygenated tungsten compounds while in reduced environments their solubility properties are reversed. However this hypothesis is most likely wrong, because it is contradicted by the distribution and phylogeny of the molybdenum enzymes and tungsten enzymes, which are consistent with the universal use of molybdenum already much earlier than the evolution of the ability for water photolysis and with the gain of the ability to use tungsten as an alternative only in certain archaea and bacteria. The earliest life forms were probably dependent on having ammonia and carbon monoxide in their environment, as sources of carbon and nitrogen, in which case molybdenum is not strictly needed. The use of molybdenum enzymes enabled the use of the more abundant carbon dioxide and dinitrogen as sources of carbon and nitrogen. This achievement must have happened some time before LUCA (last universal common ancestor), which already had these enzymes.
- Gatsky 6y agoThe workaround is that we are totally wrong about theoretical predictions stretching back billions of years.