4 ms·
Yes, but assuming equal mass of radio active material and identical radiation output something with a half-life of 1000 years is less dangerous, radiation-wise
by Someone 6y ago
Yes, but assuming equal mass of radio active material and identical radiation output something with a half-life of 1000 years is less dangerous, radiation-wise (it still might be more poisonous)
Caesium is often brought up in this kind of discussions. I think one reason might be because it decays fast enough to be harmful and still slow enough to be harmful for considerable time.
Another reason might be that more of it gets released in your typical nuclear accident. I wouldn’t know whether that is true.
- bluGill 6y agoMy point is about what is considered a long time, not relative dangers. Caesium is bad for a few hundred years. Some things are not as bad overall, but over the next 10,000 years is worse. Caesium in fact has been through one half life, and so is half as bad as it was at the start.
- Pyramus 6y agoWhy would there be disagreement about what is considered a long time? You are arguing that longer half life = bad, shorter half life = less bad, which misses the point. An effect with a shorter half-life could be a lot worse/more dangerous/threatening (potentially apocalyptic) than an effect with a longer half life.