5 ms·
I'm actually finding the responses between Telegram and Signal's announcements interesting. While there were some shady things with Signal a lot of people were
by godelski 6y ago
I'm actually finding the responses between Telegram and Signal's announcements interesting. While there were some shady things with Signal a lot of people were upset about the feature in general saying that a messaging app should just stay a messaging app as well as callbacks to how Telegram failed. So I was kinda surprised to come into this thread finding everyone being so positive and encouraged by the superapp aspects.
- wrinkl3 6y agoImo the main difference is Signal locking you into an arcane cryptocurrency, while Telegram provides you with a large choice of mainstream fiat payment processors. I agree that the features are not that different, but Telegram's approach feels much more palatable.
- godelski 6y agoI see that as a big difference too, but still a large fraction of the complaints were purely about the payment aspect. Remembering back to Telegram's payments 1.0 a lot of people were excited about it then too. I'm just curious why people are much more cynical about Signal.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rOOb85 6y agoTelegram does not care about your privacy. It's always been an after thought. Of course they would implement non privacy respecting payments. Signal is all about privacy. It trumps everything else. There are no "mainstream" payment options that align with their privacy requirements. It's not a 1:1 comparison. They both want to achieve the same goal(payment integration) buy have vastly different requirements.
- newscracker 6y ago> Signal is all about privacy. It trumps everything else. Strong disagree with this claim. Signal exposes your phone number to others when you chat. I can add random phone numbers to my address book and find out if those numbers are tied to a Signal account and get to the profile even. Telegram hides phone numbers by default and also has settings to prevent such enumeration, wherein you cannot know that I’m on Telegram by adding my number to your address book unless I also have your number in my address book.
- wrinkl3 6y agoEven if you accept that Signal absolutely had to integrate a cryptocurrency, MobileCoin is still such a weird choice. There are privacy-focused coins with a proven track record out there (e.g. Monero and Zcash), while MOB is a no-name project which would never have been most people's preferred payment method.
- pcthrowaway 6y agoCurious if you've actually looked into the reasons for choosing something besides Monero/Zcash I'm in the cryptocurrency space though I don't know too much about privacy coins. However, I've seen some abstracts of studies auditing the true privacy of Monero. Specifically, it can de-anonymize users who make multiple transactions to the same recipient due to its design. Now, I haven't personally looked into Mobilecoin deeply, and am highly skeptical at the moment. But I do think there's a valid reason to shy away from Monero based on the above, or due to it still being PoW (which is environmentally unsustainable). Signal does seem to care about privacy, and perhaps ethics to some degree. Whether or not it's "proven" (in the sense of having a large number of people using it) is quite meaningless. I really like that the CEO of Mobilecoin, who has been active in engaging with various communities, has been getting a ton of very rigorous questions here in HN, and I don't think his responses have been illuminating enough to instil trust. But I don't think it's fair to write it off as a good choice either. Presumably, Signal has access to information about Mobilecoin that we don't (which is a bad smell for a cryptocurrency, but I do hope the information about who owns how much Mobilecoin becomes public soon enough). I'm also very interested in what the implications of Signal being a non-profit are here. Are they required to publish information about their dealings?
- Saris 6y agoAt least for me it was due to Signal pushing it with their own cryptocurrency as the only option.
- eitland 6y agoSignals selling point was secure messaging. Now they seem to be diverging from that. Telegrams selling point was a better WhatsApp, and IIRC this started back when WhatsApp was still unencrypted (yes, not point-to-point encrypted but unencrypted). Since then they've always taken the lead over WhatsApp everywhere except on E2E-encryption. That's the difference IMO.
- rOOb85 6y agoSignal is still a secure messaging app. Signal will always be a secure messaging app. They have ignored feature requests to maintain secure/private messaging. Secure communication is paramount to signal. There is 0 evidence signal is diverging from being a secure messaging app. Are they adding non-chat related features? Yes. Are they making their app any less of a secure chat platform? Absolutely not.