3 ms·
>You could never have crypto in an anarchist vacuum. This seems like a strawman to me? You can be for replacing the world's monetary system with cryptocurrency
by gruez 6y ago
>You could never have crypto in an anarchist vacuum.
This seems like a strawman to me? You can be for replacing the world's monetary system with cryptocurrency, and still believe in having a government with police, roads, and schools.
- littlestymaar 6y agoIt's not really a straw man because the most vocal advocates of cryptocurrencies tend to be libertarians[1]. Obviously not everyone is like that, but it's still the vocal crowd. That being said, I'd be curious to here pro-crypto arguments from someone “believ[ing] in having a government with police, roads, and schools”. This is especially interesting to me, because “school” appears in this list. [1] which cannot really be qualified as anarchists IMHO, but that's another topic.
- gruez 6y ago>I'd be curious to here pro-crypto arguments from someone “believ[ing] in having a government with police, roads, and schools”. This is especially interesting to me, because “school” appears in this list. Is there something inherently contradictory between "a government should collect taxes and provide police, roads, and schools", and "the government shouldn't be entrusted with the ability to print money and/or dictate monetary policy"?
- littlestymaar 6y agoKind of, because people believing that schools should be provided by the government are usually in favor of some government intervention in the economy (even if limited, nobody's talking about Marxism-Leninism here). And monetary policy is a key part of what government intervention means, especially if you don't want the government to run the businesses directly. And respectively, most people being against government controlling monetary policies do so because they don't want the government intervening in the economy at all (and many of them are in favor of private school). BTW, in most if not all developed economies, the government don't control the monetary policies, the central banks do (and they are independent from governments, by design because people against government intervention made it this way).
- caffeine 6y agoIt’s not a straw man. There is a substantial faction that believes in the dream of replacing traditional trust based society with trustless executable contracts. Those people discount just how much underlying social stability matters, and how meaningless an executable contract would be in a violent environment.
- gruez 6y ago> There is a substantial faction that believes in the dream of replacing traditional trust based society with trustless executable contracts. >Those people discount just how much underlying social stability matters, and how meaningless an executable contract would be in a violent environment. How did we go from "let's use smart contracts to enforce business contracts, rather than the courts", to "abolish the entire justice system"?
- the_local_host 6y agoIf paying taxes becomes voluntary, people are only going to pay for policies that benefit them, rather than what is in the public interest. Social stability, and fairness, would be likely to suffer.
- gruez 6y agoBut why would they be voluntary? You still have corporations that have to file annual reports. They pay salaries to their employees, which would be reported. The sales they make would still be subject to VAT/sales tax.
- dnautics 6y agonobody ever does anything in the public interest unless it is beneficial to themselves, or they are threatened with jail.
- the_local_host 6y agoExactly, which is why neutering tax authorities would lead to plutocracy, where the rich stay rich and the poor have no recourse. A fair society can't rely on the goodwill of the wealthy.
- jcranmer 6y agoGiven the number of takes I've seen that are "but you haven't included the cost of aircraft carriers for fiat" (when you talk about Bitcoin's energy consumption problem), it isn't all that much of a stretch.
- randomopining 6y agoWith a truly crypto/defi setup, nobody would have to pay taxes. Everything would be zero-sum and no one would be incentivized to have to pay taxes to a central party to ensure the things you just listed exist. If you are rich and have 1000 BTC in various wallets, able to avoid capital controls, etc... why would you pay the 45% biden cap gains? Thus society loses out and rich whales get to hodl
- Jiocus 6y agoYou describe a problem that is beyond any particular technology of choice in tax evasion. These problem already exists in society, and has existed since before the advent of cryptocurrencies. Tax evasion, in the individual style you describe, can be detected in lifestyle choices and consumer habits. Generally, the burden is on you to explain how you've been able to spend more than your official tax records report.
- randomopining 6y agoYeah so? Crypto improves the ability to evade. You must agree with that. Thus it will increase the problem of people benefitting from society but not paying back into society. Taking resources that would never be able to grow in a vacuum.
- Jiocus 6y agoNo, I don't share that view. I think cryptocurrencies seem, at most, equal to conventional evasive techniques, maybe even less useful when factoring in the hoops and overhead in actually translating the funds into real world goods and services. It's also unknown what the future holds in regard to effective tracing capabilities, retroactively, by law enforcement and agencies. My view is based on crypto and society ‘as is’ today. I would have to imagine a different society, with a radical adoption of crypto, to support your argument. But I would if that was the case.