8 ms·
What Doomed a Sprawling City Near St. Louis 1k Years Ago?
- adolph 6y agoNarratives of ecocide, when a society fails due to self‐inflicted ecologic disaster, have been broadly applied to many major archaeological sites based on the expected environmental consequences of known land‐use practices of people in the past. The wood‐overuse hypothesis suggests that tree clearance in the uplands surrounding Cahokia led upstream erosion, causing increasingly frequent and unpredictable floods of the local creek drainages in the floodplain where Cahokia Mounds was constructed. More frequent and unpredictable flooding in the floodplain would increase the risks involved within bottomland agriculture to “a point where less productive, but more predictable, upland agricultural strategies became the optimal solution to a growing problem”. The presence of a stable ground surface (Ab horizon) from Mississippian occupation to the mid‐1800s does not support the expectations of the wood‐overuse hypothesis. Ultimately, this research demonstrates that pre‐Colombian ecological change does not inherently cause geomorphic change, and narratives of ecocide related to geomorphic change need to be validated with the stratigraphic record. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/gea.21848 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/gea.21848
- mc32 6y ago>” and narratives of ecocide related to geomorphic change need to be validated...” Why are there “narratives” when it comes to archeology? I realize there are favorite or predominant hypotheses, but they should not become “narrative”. I really dislike when everything becomes narrative.
- readflaggedcomm 6y agoNarratives are chains of events, which can be used to explain an outcome. Not every narrative is political.
- mc32 6y agoTo me narrative have fleshed out stories with unsupported bits and pieces. I’d prefer just stating what is understood at the time (which obviously can be wrong and disproven layer on but at least it’s in good faith).
- kqr 6y agoIn these situations, the evidence is rarely clear cut. Part of establishing the belief in the evidence is investigating whether or not it can fit into a plausible-but-ultimately-speculative narrative. In other words, if you can't even construct a coherent story of causation that incorporates your evidence, then maybe you have misinterpreted your evidence. That's why a narrative is an important part of the puzzle. They are not to be taken as gospel -- they're just a basic sanity check of the evidence. Edit: I'm not dismissing your perspective! I would have said the exact same thing a couple of years ago. I'm used to evidence being either obviously true or obviously false, or at least being able to establish a Bayesian posterior belief based on incontrovertible assumptions. What changed for me was that I read some monographs in anthropological history (or is it historical anthropology? I keep forgetting which is which.) These make for incredibly frustrating reading for someone like me. It's all anecdotes and narratives and no clear sets of underlying principles. But that's precisely why it's been so meaningful for me to read them. It's really widened my perspectives on both humanity and that type of research.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoI imagine too the narrative, not despite, but because of the "holes" gives researchers new areas to focus their investigation. Then either buttress the narrative by filling in the holes or to challenge it. A friend was reading a paperback in the 70's that suggested dinosaurs were warm-blooded. I thought it was an insane premise (because I was maybe 12 years old) but there does seem to have been a tidal shift in how dinosaurs are perceived vs. how I was taught as a child. No doubt it was someone with a theory or narrative that gave pause to some of the researchers in the field, kindled the imagination of some young researchers....
- 6y ago
- guerrilla 6y agoA narrative can be a hypothesis, a hypothesis for the [hi]story (i.e. sequence of events) of what happened.
- adolph 6y agoNarratives are stories. In this case a story used to describe a conjecture. Unfortunately researchers found the story convincing enough that Since the publication of the wood‐overuse hypothesis, no attempts have been made to evaluate if erosion in the uplands and/or increased flooding in the floodplain did indeed occur during Cahokia's occupation. The authors have a potential solution in that conjectures that cross academic divisions should include support from related academic fields or from new interdisciplinary ones like geoarchaeology. Moving forward, we propose that to move past these older narratives of ecocide, there needs to be increased engagement with obtaining both archaeological and environmental data to address these older theories, a need for researchers who are trained in interdisciplinary research, as well as increased support for long‐term, interdisciplinary collaborations. The interdisciplinary field of geoarchaeology is especially equipped to help us move forward, as long as the members of the field remain engaged with developing anthropological theory.
- intergalplan 6y agoIt's archaeology's version of a theory. You see a huge city that appears to have vanished pretty fast, so you come up with some ideas about how/why that happened, like, say, ecological collapse (hypothesis). Once you find some plausible evidence that for that, you flesh out what that would look like more broadly. Now you have a theory (narrative) which should have some explanatory power. Then, as you encounter other evidence, you expect it to fit with and support that theory (narrative). If it doesn't, it may turn out your theory (narrative) was wrong, or at least incomplete, just as in the rest of science. Just like theories in other fields, these narratives can be kind of sticky and survive longer than the evidence suggests they should. It's not a perfect mapping, but that's basically what's going on.
- FridayoLeary 6y agoa tornado?
- JKCalhoun 6y agoTornados are not wide, area-effect disasters. They're forgiving in that regard: preferring a relatively narrow swath of absolute destruction.
- pettusftw 6y agoThe 2013 Moore, OK tornado was 1.08 miles (1.74 km) wide at its peak. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_Moore_tornado https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_Moore_tornado That's nowhere near the widest, just the widest F5 that comes to mind. 11 days later the widest tornado on record struck on the other side of the OKC metro, and would've been an F5 in a populated area: Officially, the widest tornado on record is the El Reno, Oklahoma tornado of May 31, 2013 with a width of 2.6 miles (4.2 km) at its peak. This is the width found by the National Weather Service based on preliminary data from University of Oklahoma RaXPol mobile radar that also sampled winds of 296 mph (476 km/h) which was used to upgrade the tornado to EF5 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tornado_records https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tornado_records
- jandrese 6y agoDisease, war, or as the article suggests ecological devastation are more likely.
- linuxftw 6y agoA tornado with a particular placement could be a precursor to all of these things. Missouri has had some of the deadliest tornado's on record. Supporting thousands of people requires a lot of food, and if a sizeable portion of your crop is destroyed by a major weather event, people have to leave town.
- oblib 6y agoI live in Missouri and have spent some time at Cahokia. They have an awesome Visitors Center with a huge display of artifacts there. My wife and I have also visited several sites in the Yucatan including the museum in Merida where they have a huge number of artifacts. When we mentioned to an employee at the Visitors Center at Cahokia that the art and artifacts were very similar to those we saw in the Yucatan and it seems plausible that those cultures were known to each other they responded with a statement that was a scripted response that denied any connection to any other culture and insisted there is none at all. It sounded exactly like something a lawyer would craft and they ignored everything we brought up that implied their could be any connection. From what I could gather the reason for that is if any connection to a living tribe of indigenous peoples could be proved the privately owned lands surrounding the Cahokia site where there are mounds, and there are a lot of them, could be claimed as sacred sites to those tribes and would have to be returned to them. So my take away is the State of Illinois is actively dissuading research that could provide more insight to who lived there and what actually became of them and anyone who tries to prove otherwise is booted out of the conversation.
- tptacek 6y agoI'm not sure if random conversations at visitors centers are really the way this kind of research proceeds. Illinois mints quite a few archeologists every year, at a series of rather large universities, none of which give even a fraction of a shit about real estate interests around Cahokia.
- oblib 6y agoI didn't say archeologists were dismissing the connection. I said the Chokia Park employees were, and they did so in a very scripted manner and refused to even discuss it. Go there and test it out. It was a very strange thing to observe.
- tptacek 6y agoYou would like me to go test out what happens when a random person attempts to advance archeological theories by confronting park employees about them?
- Tiktaalik 6y agoSeems like ecocide only gets pulled out as a theory for mysterious culture collapse when the next best alternative is "I have absolutely no idea." Are we really scraping the bottom of the barrel here and dreaming up something that probably didn't happen, or are there genuine, on the record, circumstances of well known and understood communities accidentally committing some sort of (minor to catastrophic?) ecocide on themselves that they had to deal with? Eg. Messing up their home and having to move on.
- addaon 6y agoThe loss of trees on Pacific islands seems like a decent example.
- thrower123 6y agoThe toy examples of Polynesian islands get a lot of play here, although if you rule out the extremely marginal and isolated places like Henderson, Pitcairn and Easter islands, there's not much to go on.
- bartread 6y agoThey've never taken out a settlement the size of a city but there have been a couple of tailings dam collapses in recent years that have led to the deaths of (in one case) 270 people and (in the other) displacements of hundreds of people, along with widespread downstream pollution: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brumadinho_dam_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brumadinho_dam_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mariana_dam_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mariana_dam_disaster Then of course there's the drying up of the Aral Sea starting in the second half of the 20th century, due primarily to the diversion of the rivers that feed it for the purpose of irrigation, which has had a devastating effect on the surrounding communities that used to depend on it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aral_Sea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aral_Sea
- thamer 6y agoThis reminds me of the theory that the Rapa Nui on Easter Island also suffered from self-inflicted "ecocide", cutting down all their trees to build their legendary Moai statues and ending up with no birds, unstable soil, erosion… all that comes with it. This narrative resonates with a lot of people given our current climate crisis and can seem like an ominous warning, but it is also disputed. Here's an article supporting this theory: https://writingscience.web.unc.edu/2017/09/the-ecocide-of-easter-island/ https://writingscience.web.unc.edu/2017/09/the-ecocide-of-ea... An one debunking it: https://theconversation.com/the-truth-about-easter-island-a-sustainable-society-has-been-falsely-blamed-for-its-own-demise-85563 https://theconversation.com/the-truth-about-easter-island-a-...
- idlewords 6y agoI wrote a bunch about Cahokia back in 2015, in the context of exploring the New Madrid earthquake fault in the region: https://idlewords.com/2015/07/confronting_new_madrid.htm https://idlewords.com/2015/07/confronting_new_madrid.htm The Cahokia mounds are an amazing artifact and you should go visit if you are anywhere nearby!
- haspoken 6y agohttp://archive.is/tcDhG http://archive.is/tcDhG