4 ms·
> When the axe descends, the only sentence can be "You have violated the ToS." > I am not sure what the alternative would look like, but for anyone with compla
by mschuster91 6y ago
> When the axe descends, the only sentence can be "You have violated the ToS."
> I am not sure what the alternative would look like, but for anyone with complaints about the current situation, it is important to examine just how we got here.
One alternative could be to restore the authority of the processes that societies have evolved over the last two hundred years - courts. Given that modern social networks essentially act as public space, a gateway between the digital and meatspace world, they should also be regulated by independent authorities.
- krapp 6y ago>One alternative could be to restore the authority of the processes that societies have evolved over the last two hundred years - courts. Given that modern social networks essentially act as public space, a gateway between the digital and meatspace world, they should also be regulated by independent authorities. That would set a precedent that any site with any user supplied content must require intervention and approval by a court before any form of moderation can take place, or at least that all sites must require court approval for their terms of service. which by extension means all speech on the web will be under direct government control. That would include Hacker News and any blog that allows comments. This is a much greater degree of control over freedom of speech than exists in public spaces in the real world - where people can speak freely generally without government enforced moderation, and in any case websites are not public spaces. So on top of everything else, governments would assert unprecedented control over free enterprise and freedom of association. And it doesn't matter where you decide to draw the line, perhaps only requiring this level of regulation for sites with a certain number of users, this being Hacker News I shouldn't have to point out the potential slippery slope in having the government decide where that line is drawn. The situation we're in now is bad, but needing a judge to sign off on every moderation action would be much, much worse.
- mschuster91 6y ago> The situation we're in now is bad, but needing a judge to sign off on every moderation action would be much, much worse. I had not meant that every moderation action would need a judge, but that every person should have the legal right to appeal and plead their case in front of a judge instead of hitting stone walls.
- lawtalkinghuman 6y agoWhat the civil court system desperately needs: more lawsuits from people who got banned from web forums.
- mschuster91 6y agoAt least in Germany, you can file a c&d order ("Abmahnung") without ever having to see a court. Seeing a court is the escalation option in case the counter party does not react to your Abmahnung. And besides: that access to legal protection is what taxes and court fees are paying for!
- krapp 6y agoMaking every moderation decision potentially liable to lawsuits is functionally no different than require a judge to sign off on every decision, since it creates the incentive for everyone to litigate every decision they disagree with, no matter how small. But nothing social media platforms are doing is illegal. A judge is just going to tell you that you agreed to the platform's terms of service and they have the right, including Section 230 indemnity, to moderate content on their platform.
- CaptArmchair 6y ago> Given that modern social networks essentially act as public space But that's the thing: they aren't public spaces. The number of people which have their content hosted on a private platform is inconsequential to the legal nature of the platform. Social media are very much subject to legal regulations and lawmaking. Calling a space which is governed by a private entity that doesn't represent you / answer to you, as "public" is a contradiction. The worst you can do is persist this notion to a point where enough people believe they are public spaces. That's the most direct way of legitimizing their dominance in modern telecommunication networks.
- mschuster91 6y ago> But that's the thing: they aren't public spaces. They are the de-facto places where online discourse is held, and at least German courts have acknowledged that even speech that borders on hate speech is a part of public opinion forming (e.g. https://www.idowa.de/inhalt.gerichtsurteil-nach-sperre-facebook-muss-profil-wieder-freigeben.f2006d0b-05c8-42ee-8cfd-50b0ec18cd76.html https://www.idowa.de/inhalt.gerichtsurteil-nach-sperre-faceb... or https://www.e-recht24.de/news/facebook/11029-neues-facebook-urteil-meinungsfreiheit-wichtiger-als-gemeinschaftsstandards.html https://www.e-recht24.de/news/facebook/11029-neues-facebook-...). > Calling a space which is governed by a private entity that doesn't represent you / answer to you, as "public" is a contradiction. It is not, even in the meatspace. Spaces that are open to the public yet governed by private entities are also covered under the freedom of assembly (e.g. airports, see https://www.lto.de/recht/hintergruende/h/bverfg-zur-versammlungsfreiheit-kein-demo-verbot-am-frankfurter-flughafen/ https://www.lto.de/recht/hintergruende/h/bverfg-zur-versamml... or train stations, see https://www.stuttgarter-zeitung.de/inhalt.gerichtsurteil-zum-demonstrationsrecht-neue-perspektiven-fuer-s21-gegner.3be315c0-45ae-45b8-bf69-7af748c5aee5.html https://www.stuttgarter-zeitung.de/inhalt.gerichtsurteil-zum...). > That's the most direct way of legitimizing their dominance in modern telecommunication networks. In Germany, telecommunications providers are actually banned from terminating your access by law (https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/tkg_2004/__45k.html); https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/tkg_2004/__45k.html); the only exceptions are non-payment and spoofing fraud. The reason for this is that access to telecommunication networks is seen as a vital basic right to participate in society.