4 ms·
If only the web was supported by visitors contributing to hosting costs of a visited page directly out of their internet bill, instead of advertisement supporti
by asdff 6y ago
If only the web was supported by visitors contributing to hosting costs of a visited page directly out of their internet bill, instead of advertisement supporting the web, and visitors paying a flat fee to their ISP regardless of their use.
Blogs could be sustained with little readership considering how cheap it is to host a lightweight website that sees little traffic, and larger websites like HN would pay for their hosting and on top of that maybe even have some funds to hire another dang. All of this could come without any advertisement, without dark patterns, tracking, tapping into our subconcious or primitive brain, and all the other evil genius ideas to come out of the advertisement industry. I can't help but think that this would create a better and perhaps less hostile place for everyone.
- teddyh 6y agoAlso a more surveilled place. By definition, this system would require everyone’s activities to be tracked and stored.
- codetrotter 6y ago> [...] and larger websites like HN would pay for their hosting and on top of that maybe even have some funds to hire another dang. All of this could come without any advertisement, without dark patterns, tracking, tapping into our subconcious or primitive brain, and all the other evil genius ideas to come out of the advertisement industry As long as more traffic still means more profit there would still be plenty incentive for websites to engage in evil tactics against their users, in order to ensure that the users spend as much time as possible on that site. I too want a web without advertising, but I don’t believe for a second that all of the problems associated with advertising will go away even if advertising itself did. Some problems might disappear, others not, and new problems will appear in the place of problems that did disappear. After all, there are very many people out there who have gotten really good at coming up with evil tactics. These people would still be out there, and in demand, even if advertising disappeared.
- nine_k 6y agoI would say that hosting a blog has an effectively zero monetary cost, that is, not distinguishable from the noise floor of daily spending, like an extra latte. For static blogs, even several completely free options exist. The real cost of maintaining a blog is the time one spends to compose, edit, proofread, sometimes illustrate a blog post. And no, you don't think about a post only while you're working in it; you think in background, too. This cost can hardly be remunerated by every reader paying a few cents, unless your readership is in tens of thousands at least, and the money allow you to actually free up some time for writing.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> This cost can hardly be remunerated by every reader paying a few cents, unless your readership is in tens of thousands at least, and the money allow you to actually free up some time for writing. Extrapolating further, people spend orders of magnitude more time, bandwidth, and server-side CPU resources for everything else they do on the internet: Scrolling JPEGs on social media sites, streaming gigabytes of Netflix movies. Sending a 100KB blog post page to someone might take 0.00001% as many resources as streaming a 2-hour Netflix movie. If servers were paid according to resources used, blog authors would receive virtually nothing relative to all the multimedia based services.
- prox 6y agoI just want a tipjar system. I put a small amount in it for the month. And whenever I read a good article I can tipjar it. Alternatively maybe something that was on dragon’s den BBC : https://gener8ads.com/ https://gener8ads.com/ , where you get paid for seeing ads or can opt to be completely anonymous.
- kelnos 6y agoI really wish micropayments would take off, but psychologically it seems they just don't work. There's a huge chasm between spending $0 and spending even $0.01. The mental effort involved in "taking out your wallet" vs. not doing so is huge. Meanwhile it seems that most people consider viewing ads to have zero cost to them (whether that's true or not), or use ad-blockers.
- esperent 6y agoThere's a huge chasm now, for sure. But only when it comes to online spending. In the real world, if someone offered me something useful for 0.01 I'd pay it without a thought (except for wondering why it's so cheap). If we can get over the initial weirdness and make it completely seamless (as easy as dismissing a cookie banner) I'm sure people would get used to paying a cent for every blog post they read. On the other hand, if there's a thousand different micropayment platforms each with a different way of getting past the paywall and of adding funds, then I don't think it'll be an easy path to adoption.
- ysavir 6y ago> In the real world, if someone offered me something useful for 0.01 I'd pay it without a thought (except for wondering why it's so cheap). In the real world, though, you won't be getting 247 such requests per hour. And that's the crux of the issue: quantity vs quality.
- naturalauction 6y agoI mean I'd assume it would work similar to pay as you go data, in that you just get charged in the background. Not sure how you'd deal with sites trying to bill their users a ton without the users finding out though - maybe they need to click a button to continue every certain number of requests or amount of data used.
- esperent 6y agoI don't see such requests, no. But they happen every time I turn on the water or anything electrical. They are completely seamless and I get feedback at the end of every month whereby I can think, hmm, I should be more careful to turn off the AC when I'm going out. But on a daily basis I don't have to think about it much. This is what I mean by seamless. If you're reading 247 different sources of information in an hour, unless you're doing some kind of heavy research, you're probably overloading your brain in any case. How many blog articles can you read in an hour? Less than ten, probably more like 5, if they're actually worth reading.
- robertlagrant 6y ago> If only the web was supported by visitors contributing to hosting costs of a visited page directly out of their internet bill, instead of advertisement supporting the web Why would this stop ads? In this case, ads still make you more money; your hosting costs just go down a little.
- dan-robertson 6y agoDoesn’t this just encourage websites to become even more bloated as they are paid by the byte?
- meheleventyone 6y agoSadly by paying sites for views whether by advertising or directly from the user you encourage maximizing "engagement" so end up with all the dark patterns, click bait and tracking regardless. Free to play games are a great example of good and bad ways this ends up.
- progval 6y ago> If only the web was supported by visitors contributing to hosting costs of a visited page directly out of their internet bill It was one of the ideas behind Project Xanadu: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Xanadu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Xanadu Discussed in this sub-thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26217015 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26217015
- Ygg2 6y agoIf web was supported like that, you'd still earn extra for having ads. On top of that.
- christophilus 6y agoI think the incentives would still be similar in that world. Your goal would be to maximize payment. It you’re paid per view, you’re incentivized to maximize views. Low-grade clickbait would possibly be even worse. If you’re paid by duration of time on a page, you’d maximize engagement/ addictiveness, etc.