3 ms·
> Its a good reminder that things we think are common sense (like the government being involved in murder but not in legislating how much jewelry a girl can wea
by wolverine876 6y ago
> Its a good reminder that things we think are common sense (like the government being involved in murder but not in legislating how much jewelry a girl can wear) are not necessarily so. They are very much cultural based. And these are both human cultures. What would an alien culture think is common sense?
First, I think the word "culture" is extremely loaded and ambiguous, and stereotypes great masses of individuals each with their own opinions, and to make static things that constantly change. But that said, whatever it is, it exists somehow.
IMHO this relativism argument - that it's nothing more than local 'culture' - is greatly overstated. The evidence is that individual liberty is a principle embraced by people almost every place that they have had the choice: The U.S., almost every country in Europe, Japan, China (where they have a choice - in Taiwan, in Hong Kong until very recently, and in Tienanmen Square in 1989 - they strongly advocate for it), Korea, India, almost every country in Latin America, Tunisia, Syria (where they had a choice), Benin, Botswana, etc. etc. In addition, people risk their lives to travel from repressive countries without traditions of liberty to free countries and they strongly embrace the freedom. My ancestors did. Finally, you don't see people migrating the other way.
(I don't see how speculating on unknown, non-human, intelligent lifeforms informs the discussion.)
- whakim 6y agoI feel that you've kind of missed GP's point, which is that we tend to take for granted the functions of the state, when in fact those functions have shifted over time. For example, it was not until relatively recently (i.e., the 20th century) that providing a social safety net came to be considered a core competency of governments. To take another example: the Roman Empire provided free rations of grain and olive oil (the annona) to all citizens of Rome and Constantinople for several hundred years. This was an incredibly big deal because it a) set a high base level of demand for bulk goods that enabled the huge economies of scale upon which Roman long distance trade operated; and b) enabled the populations of Rome and Constantinople to reach levels that no European city would again equal until the Early Modern period. Romans probably viewed the annona like modern Americans view social security. Romans would (probably) have thought social security ridiculous, whereas most Americans would view the annona as a large scale encroachment by the state on market pricing of commodities.