7 ms·
Loser-Pays makes lawsuits fairer in Europe. It could work here, too.
- joejohnson 15y agoIt seems like the real impetus for this kind of law (in the US) is that lawyers would oppose it. The article touches upon this at the very end.
- dminor 15y agoExtensive discussion last time this was posted: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1792353 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1792353
- bradleyland 15y ago"The practical case for loser-pays is equally compelling. Litigants naturally think too well of their cases; loser-pays pushes them to size up their prospects more realistically. It also curbs the brand of extortion, so routine in American law as almost to have lost its ethical taint, by which lawyers use the costs of the process itself, or the risk of a fluke outcome found in any trial, to strong-arm their opponents into settlement." I'm facing this very scenario right now. We're being sued by a lawyer who is working on contingency for a client who is so delusional it makes me sick to my stomach to think about it. The really ugly side of this is that lawyers of the ilk that are suing us find specific loopholes through which they can (or attempt to) attach you personally, even if you're incorporated. We're being strong-armed to settle, and will likely pay these jerks something, just to have it go away. If "loser-pays" applied here, this lawsuit would have been wrapped up after the very first round of inquiry.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- vannevar 15y agoWhile 'loser pays' might benefit your particular case, it's easy to imagine an equal number of scenarios where a guilty corporate defendant uses the threat of running up huge legal fees to discourage valid lawsuits against it. The result is a windfall for corporations with no net improvement in actual justice. To put it another way, it decreases the likelihood of frivolous plaintiffs but increases the likelihood of frivolous defendants.
- ldar15 15y agoAccording to TFA that's not how it works in Europe: if you deliberately run up costs, the court will not assign them to the loser. Only reasonable fees are passed on to the loser. And the loser can challenge.
- vannevar 15y agoA big corporation can run up an awful lot of perfectly legitimate legal fees. And the challenge remedy is not going to be much comfort to an indigent plaintiff as it's unlikely his lawyer is going to take that challenge on contingency.
- groby_b 15y agoAt least in Germany, what is a reasonable fee is strictly regulated and tied to the total value disputed. At the very least, you'll know the cost (roughly) at the outset of the case. Good luck trying that kind of regulation in the US.
- a5seo 15y ago@vannevar you have obviously never been sued or threatened on a meritless claim by a multi billion $ company. Loser pay is a significant equalizer because let's say the case is speech related, the ACLU will defend you all day long necuase their attorneys get paid in the end. I imagine other attorneys would take up your defense for similar reasons...
- vannevar 15y agoHow often is an individual sued by a corporation on a free speech case, compared to the number of times individuals sue corporations because they've been harmed? I'd guess that ratio is something on the order of 1000 to 1 or more in favor of individuals suing corporations. Unless you're Oprah, it's pretty unlikely that a corporation is ever going to sue you for something you say.
- zacharypinter 15y agoNot so sure about this: "It also curbs the brand of extortion, so routine in American law as almost to have lost its ethical taint, by which lawyers use the costs of the process itself, or the risk of a fluke outcome found in any trial, to strong-arm their opponents into settlement." There was a great interview on SGU with Simon Singh, the British writer who was sued for libel by the British Chiropractic Association. He talks about how they kept on inflating their costs during the lawsuit to try to force his hand, knowing that he'd have to pay an exorbitant amount if he lost. Relevant links: http://www.theskepticsguide.org/archive/podcastinfo.aspx?mid=1&pid=271 http://www.theskepticsguide.org/archive/podcastinfo.aspx?mid... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon_Singh http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon_Singh
- vessenes 15y agoLibel laws are extremely strong in the UK; the closes thing we have here would be anti-trust laws. As a fun historical example, Richard Branson felt BA was acting monopolistically in England; they both kept Virgin out of Heathrow for some time, and one of their senior execs badmouthed the airline in England. Virgin took the court to New York State (since, you know, JFK Airport), won the anti-trust case there, then returned and won the libel case in the UK based on evidence in the US case. At least, that's how Branson tells it.
- cynicalkane 15y agoFor frivolous litigation, the loser pays, but the standard for litigation being frivolous is pretty high. Maybe there could be a position in between loser always pays and loser almost never pays. Say, loser pays if there's no "reasonable" argument for his side of his case, analogous to how you only go to jail (in theory, anyway) if there's no reasonable doubt that you are innocent.
- ldar15 15y agoIANAL, but TFA states that this would also happen here in the USA because many states have a one-way loser-pays.
- iwwr 15y agoLet's not forget that legal fees are not entirely the fault of the litigants. The burden of laws and rules is so great, you need expensive experts to navigate it. The weight of the laws themselves is promoting abuse and injustice. Consider the analogy of a number of prisoners being forced to walk through a different minefield each day. Even if they are given a map to memorize the night before, it does not make the event fair.
- anamax 15y agoDoes Europe have punitive damages? Who gets them? The US does and they go to the winning plaintiff, which is sort of odd. After all, if someone is fined for assulting me, I don't get that money.
- thirdusername 15y agoSweden (and by extension probably all of Scandinavia) doesn't do punitive or exemplary damages.
- davidw 15y agoPretty much everything I've ever seen from "reason.com" is material promoting a libertarian viewpoint. Not that there's anything wrong with that, but it's pretty much just politics.
- psadauskas 15y agoProbably because its the website for a libertarian magazine? They don't even pretend that's not the case, unlike something on Fox News... From the about page: Reason is the monthly print magazine of "free minds and free markets." It covers politics, culture, and ideas through a provocative mix of news, analysis, commentary, and reviews. Reason provides a refreshing alternative to right-wing and left-wing opinion magazines by making a principled case for liberty and individual choice in all areas of human activity.
- davidw 15y agoThe point being, for those who missed it that this site is not for the discussion of politics. There are plenty of other places to trot out the same old tired discussions.
- vannevar 15y ago"Loser pays" doesn't seem consistent with libertarian philosophy, in that it advocates government interference in what should be a private economic matter: how one pays for one's legal representation. It is consistent with corporatism, however, which I suspect is closer to Reason's true philosophy.
- lawnchair_larry 15y agoI've noticed that in most of the US, "Libertarian" means the opposite of what it does elsewhere. Aside from the Tea Party 2.0-esque "libertarians", most libertarian philosophy is consistent with preventing private corporations from being bullies. It's a bit counter-intuitive, until you consider that there is no freedom if the rich man makes the rules.
- vannevar 15y ago
- tzs 15y agoComparison between the US and Europe in this area is close to meaningless, because of fundamental differences in how the two tend to view the roles of the judicial and executive branches of government in the enforcement of laws. The US has a greater tendency, particularly in the areas of civil rights but also torts in general, of structuring the law so it gives the injured party a private right of action, which they enforce in courts, and leaving the executive out of it. Europe has a greater tendency in these areas to have the executive branch deal with enforcement.
- Derbasti 15y agoSo you are saying the US gives even more power to the powerful and wealthy (e.g. corporations) and even less power to the poor regardless of who is right. One might argue that a court should exist for deciding about justice, not budget.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ScottBurson 15y agoI just found this comment from Walter Bright on a previous thread on this topic. I think it's brilliant: Loser pays can work when the amount the loser is liable for is the minimum of his legal fees or his opponent's legal fees. That puts the maximum he is liable for under his own control. I love this idea, as it completely prevents the scenario where a well-financed plaintiff uses the most expensive lawyers and runs up a huge bill, just to add to the defendant's risk and encourage a premature settlement. Under this rule, if you want to spend a bunch of money on good lawyers to improve your chances of winning the case at all, go ahead, but you won't collect more in fees by doing it, unless your opponent does the same (as they presumably will if they can afford to).
- B_ 15y agoExactly.
- vannevar 15y agoThis is an appealing idea at first glance, but it really doesn't accomplish anything for plaintiffs represented on contigency. They get charged nothing if you take the rule literally, and if you use the plaintiff's attorney's costs they could often be as high as the defense costs. The rule still punishes indigent plaintiffs who bring lawsuits in good faith to litigate genuine disputes.
- leot 15y agoI think powerful plaintiffs frivolously suing indigent ones is far more common than the other way around, and a much bigger problem. Without some kind of loser-pays it's always possible for wealthier individuals to sue poorer ones and win a war of attrition.
- vannevar 15y agoArtful trolling. Well played...
- Havoc 15y agoI find it bewildering that anything else is in use anyway.
- MaxGabriel 15y agoThis title could use a [1995] tag
- dholowiski 15y agoLoser pays in Canada too. There's way less lawsuits but even if your in the right you might not sue, simply because you can't afford to lose.
- B_ 15y agoLook at who pays the bills at Reason. That's who would benefit from any policy recommendations they have. "Fair" has nothing to do with it. If you want to make it "fair" then reform the rules to where no party to a case can spend more than the other. If I bet my friend that I and a friend could beat him and a friend a two-on-two basketball, and he shows up with Kobe Bryant, would that be fair? What if that bet stated that the loser pays the bills for dinner at the winner's choice of restaurant? Is that fair? Yes, it would be a stupid bet to make. But the proposed policy change makes that bet no longer a choice but a matter of law.
- kalleboo 15y agoQuoth the article: «A common fear about loser-pays is that the side who loses a routine dispute will get handed a bill for 10,000 hours from Cravath, Swaine & Moore. But European courts are well aware of the danger that successful litigants will overinvest in their cases and gold-plate their fee requests. They carefully control the process to prevent that danger, giving the losing side a full chance to dispute a fee award, requiring that work be reasonable and necessary, providing that elite lawyer rates not be paid if a Main Street lawyer could have done the job, and so forth.»
- vannevar 15y agoThey carefully control the process... Meaning they heavily regulate what can be charged. Why is Reason so enthusiastic about regulating attorneys but screams bloody murder if the government tries to regulate doctors or the energy industry?
- itswindy 15y agoProblem with it that even if you are right, you'll think twice about suing, so it works both ways.
- yason 15y agoCompared to the US, loser-pays would also cut cown the number of lawsuits because plaintiffs would think twice or thrice before suing. That would definitely be a good thing: a court is an awfully frictional and expensive way to settle disputes and should rightly be reserved to the most pressing ones that seem to warrant the corresponding financial investments. Anything that can be settled outside of courts should be.
- blue1 15y agoin Italy the judge decides who has to pay the costs. Loser pays everything only if he loses badly, so to say.