3 ms·
> Maybe the automakers will make their own fabs. Which is what is really needed. Seems like a massive investment in something that isn't their core competency
by dehrmann 6y ago
> Maybe the automakers will make their own fabs. Which is what is really needed.
Seems like a massive investment in something that isn't their core competency (at all) for a 6-month disruption that hits ~once a generation+. It'd be a lot cheaper to just pay a foundry for reserved capacity, to stockpile a year supply of chips, or engineer cars to have more options for chips.
- AJ007 6y agoIf Intel couldn’t keep up with the latest fabs I can’t believe an automaker could start from 0 and have any remote chance of success. Volume would be too low to make it work financially even if they could.
- thetinguy 6y agoOld processes don’t disappear when the cutting edge manufacturers switch to smaller features. A lot of jelly bean parts, like the kind that go into a car, are made with larger features that are easier to work with. I think manufacturing is a core competency for automakers. While there are significant differences between car making and chip making, I don’t think you should discount an automaker’s ability to manufacture things.
- dehrmann 6y ago> I don’t think you should discount an automaker’s ability to manufacture things. Have you see infotainment UIs? Edit: my point was actually how bad they are. Carmakers don't do tech well.
- majewsky 6y agoI haven't seen car UIs in a hot second, so honest question: What's in there that cannot be done with, say, chips from 2008?
- flyinglizard 6y agoHigh resolution displays everywhere running fancy 3D graphics, trying to emulate good old analog dials and controls in their responsiveness. Many 2021 cars no longer have a single analog dial in them. It’s all done by pushing a ton of pixels from a CPU that’s probably not older in process than 14nm.
- hulitu 6y ago> > I don’t think you should discount an automaker’s ability to manufacture things. > Have you see infotainment UIs? > Edit: my point was actually how bad they are. Carmakers don't do tech well. Android UI and Win 10 are also terrible. And at least Win10 comes from someone who claims a lot of experience in this field (although some claim that they just stole the ideas).
- cptskippy 6y ago> Android UI and Win 10 are also terrible. MacOS is pretty awful as well, just differently bad.
- __turbobrew__ 6y agoYou dont need 5nm transistors to run your vehicle. 10 year old processes would probably be enough for automotive needs.
- inetknght 6y ago> or engineer cars to have more options for chips You mean like having open standards that consumers can plug-and-play their own devices into? That's absurd. /s How would auto makers vendor-lock consumers after that?
- Lucasoato 6y agoThis is such a shame, companies sould be forced to design their infotainment system in order to let customer installing software from different vendors in it.
- photojosh 6y agoThis is a solved problem with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, no? I don't care one bit about the quality of the built-in system.
- hulitu 6y agoYou mean open standards like the web, amp and floc where google controls 90% of the market ? Or the PC where wintel controls 80 % ? Who will be responsible when your google analitycs powered control unit will cause the airbags to deploy during driving ?
- oceanplexian 6y agoLots of industries have to plan for black swan events that hit once in a generation. But even then that's hugely optimistic. TPS/Lean has been in widespread use since what, the 80s? What happens when war breaks out, or we end up in a serious Geopolitical Conflict (Trade War), or run into another energy crisis or shipping crisis like what happened with the Suez Canal. Owning your supply chain is a core competency. It's just that a few decades of relative global stability has allowed us to bury our heads in the sand in exchange for a few short-term optimizations.