3 ms·
> The author writes, ... “None of this is to paint Feynman as a villain”. I feel this is disingenuous. I read that statement very differently. Her essay is ab
by gumby 6y ago
> The author writes, ... “None of this is to paint Feynman as a villain”. I feel this is disingenuous.
I read that statement very differently.
Her essay is about the pervasive and accepted sexism in physics and astronomy. Her use of Feynman is of course a hook, but also shows that this is a longstanding, accepted trend, and accepted in such a way that those who wish to lionize him simply ignore it.
She shows that people objected in the past but were brushed off.
She also shows that people who object today are brushed off. And that other professors are given the same treatment (e.g. people who objected "ruined [Ott's] career" rather than considering that he ruined his own.
And by saying "None of this is to paint Feynman as a villain" she is being explicit that he was embedded and part of a longstanding culture. You're even selectively ignoring the rest of the paragraph in which she expands on this very point.
You can't change the past but you can change the present and this is what the author is asking for.