2 ms·
There are lots of possible solutions: - Explicitly advertise that you're buying access to the content for x years, not buying it outright - Allow for non-DRM
by crazygringo 6y ago
There are lots of possible solutions:
- Explicitly advertise that you're buying access to the content for x years, not buying it outright
- Allow for non-DRM content download either as standard, or as a guaranteed backup option
- If a company goes bankrupt, bankruptcy proceedings ensure that users' content licenses are transferred to another provider at no charge, funded with liquidation proceeds -- with priority over contractors, lenders, investors, etc.
There are lots of solutions.
- Jiro 6y agoWhether it explicitly advertises buying content for X years is hardly relevant in this case. The issue is that Apple claims the right to shut it down at any time. If they promised 5 years and shut down the account after a month, the same issue would come up.
- crazygringo 6y agoI was addressing the parent's comment about making content available forever being uneconomical. My original, root comment was already about the immediate issue with Apple.
- Diggsey 6y agoRight, but then they would only need to refund content purchased in the last 5 years.
- pureliquidhw 6y agoLots of similar replies. I meant if a DVD costs $25 and a digial download comes with a long-tail(forever per the comment I relied to) then how much should it cost? More I would imagine. Sure they could advertise longer rental lengths, or clearly tie it to the business (which is probably buried in the ToS already). But if congress legislates digital purchases to be available forever with a 100% refund attached, how much should that cost? It seems wholly uneconomical from a provider side. We all work in IT, but in an enterprise situation, you know how quickly LTS is de-prioritized. I would price a true forever digital licence in the $100's because you have to account for so many variables like storage(what country(s) can I store this movie in), bandwidth (what quality must I provide), and regions(where can I watch this). I would love a world where I can stream whatever, whenever, forever after a purchase but someone has to manage that, and forever is an insane horizon. Even 100 years is crazy! WWI-ish to today! And if they offered DRM free downloads, are you ok with it being one time? What if it was watermarked? Would you be willing to secure your copies? At some level a business will want to make money on their product and prevent piracy. I dunno. I want cheap, widely available, drm free media too, but I understand why it hasn't come to be yet.