6 ms·
Seriously. It's well past time that Congress passes a law explicitly to that effect -- if you lose access to purchased content, whether because your account was
by crazygringo 6y ago
Seriously. It's well past time that Congress passes a law explicitly to that effect -- if you lose access to purchased content, whether because your account was terminated or the content was removed, you get 100% refunded. End of story. Any TOS to the contrary are invalid.
- pureliquidhw 6y agoHow much should that digital content cost then? Make a DVD once, never think about it again. To offer digital copy that loses no value over time and must be available forever seems like a bad deal from the publisher's side. To offer a one time download code seems far more tenable.
- rileymat2 6y agoThere could be other ways to manage it, like specifying how long the rental would be valid for (I think iTunes started this way with movies), instead of alluding to the idea that you are buying it forever as part if a personal library.
- ratww 6y agoThen make it non-DRM downloadable content that will be playable forever at the discretion of the consumer, like music bought on iTunes, then. Or at least mention the period for when the licensing will be honored during “purchase” and stick to it. Honestly I don’t understand anyone having any sympathy for publishers or Apple. They were the ones who chose to use the current method.
- yarcob 6y agoThen they should advertise it as a one time download or a limited time rental. I don't have an issue with that. But they shouldn't advertise "store your purchased movies in the cloud for free" when they only do that as long as it is convenient for them.
- tomjen3 6y agoYou don't have to keep offering it. You just have to not turn of DRM servers or offer the download without DRM in the first place.
- floydnoel 6y agoBecause the marginal cost of a digital file is too darn high?
- CJefferson 6y agoIf the download had no DRM, and I could freely copy it, I would have much more sympathy. Usually transfering to another machine is hard, or impossible.
- ImprovedSilence 6y agoDo files from itunes have drm on it these days? I thought waaay back in the beginning they did have it, but then at some point they went drm free. (At least fir music) At what point did they sworch back?
- vondur 6y agoMovies have DRM. Music doesn’t.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoMusic does not have DRM (which is great!), but everything else you can purchase does—books, audiobooks, movies, apps, etc.
- crazygringo 6y agoThere are lots of possible solutions: - Explicitly advertise that you're buying access to the content for x years, not buying it outright - Allow for non-DRM content download either as standard, or as a guaranteed backup option - If a company goes bankrupt, bankruptcy proceedings ensure that users' content licenses are transferred to another provider at no charge, funded with liquidation proceeds -- with priority over contractors, lenders, investors, etc. There are lots of solutions.
- Jiro 6y agoWhether it explicitly advertises buying content for X years is hardly relevant in this case. The issue is that Apple claims the right to shut it down at any time. If they promised 5 years and shut down the account after a month, the same issue would come up.
- crazygringo 6y agoI was addressing the parent's comment about making content available forever being uneconomical. My original, root comment was already about the immediate issue with Apple.
- Diggsey 6y agoRight, but then they would only need to refund content purchased in the last 5 years.
- pureliquidhw 6y agoLots of similar replies. I meant if a DVD costs $25 and a digial download comes with a long-tail(forever per the comment I relied to) then how much should it cost? More I would imagine. Sure they could advertise longer rental lengths, or clearly tie it to the business (which is probably buried in the ToS already). But if congress legislates digital purchases to be available forever with a 100% refund attached, how much should that cost? It seems wholly uneconomical from a provider side. We all work in IT, but in an enterprise situation, you know how quickly LTS is de-prioritized. I would price a true forever digital licence in the $100's because you have to account for so many variables like storage(what country(s) can I store this movie in), bandwidth (what quality must I provide), and regions(where can I watch this). I would love a world where I can stream whatever, whenever, forever after a purchase but someone has to manage that, and forever is an insane horizon. Even 100 years is crazy! WWI-ish to today! And if they offered DRM free downloads, are you ok with it being one time? What if it was watermarked? Would you be willing to secure your copies? At some level a business will want to make money on their product and prevent piracy. I dunno. I want cheap, widely available, drm free media too, but I understand why it hasn't come to be yet.
- anonymousab 6y agoHaving to run DRM servers in perpetuity lest you be financially ruined seems like an appropriate tradeoff and counterbalance to DRM. If you really want such a high level of control, then it accordingly comes with a high level of responsibility.
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoContent gets removed from Netflix all the time, especially after they pivoted to their own production versus hosting content produced by others. How much should I get back?
- alex_g 6y agoA netflix subscription is access to content, not a purchase of content.
- berkes 6y agoIndeed. And the model makes this very clear too. On Netflix there is a button 'watch', while on iTunes and many others, the button says 'buy', 'purcase' etc. One implies a transaction, the other implies using already accessible content.
- sebasvisser 6y agoMight be the reason for Apple Arcade...because the buying-but-not-owning-business model is EOL
- berkes 6y agoI doubt it is EOL. There is demand for "owning", so there is a business-model there. It might be shrinking or changing, but at least for a niche, it will stay. For example e-books. I try to buy as many from the authors (or their publishers) themselves. Surprising how often an author sells their book themselves. DRM-free, almost always cheaper. Owned-by-me. As opposed to e.g. my "kobo", which I cannot backup and download for that inevitable moment that Rakuten/Kobo decides to close my account, "pivot" or stop offering services.
- sircastor 6y agoI’m reminded of a parody report noting Netflix was trialing a “browse only” plan, so you and your partner can argue endlessly about what to watch, but never have to make a choice. [1] https://www.theonion.com/netflix-introduces-new-browse-endlessly-plan-1819595604 https://www.theonion.com/netflix-introduces-new-browse-endle...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jbay808 6y agoUnfortunately, this would probably force them to treat purchase revenue as a liability on the accounting books.
- elcomet 6y agoWhat's the problem with this ? I'm not familiar with accounting.
- martin-adams 6y agoIt means that all revenue could at some point trigger a refund, for example if they want to exit the media distribution business and shutdown the services. That would be an expensive thing to do. I suspect any law would state it has an availability period before refunds are not eligible.
- MereInterest 6y agoThat's only if they design the distribution system such that it relies on the existence of the servers. If I start up Age of Empires 2 (assume in a computer or older VM such that compatibility isn't an issue), I can start a multiplayer game through LAN without any issue. If I start up a game of Overwatch, I cannot play against somebody in the same room without connecting through Blizzard's servers. It is perfectly reasonable for a company to be liable for refunds if they want to deliberately take products or features away from users. In order for a company to avoid this liability, they must provide a way for those features to still be available to users, even if the company no longer supports the product. This is pretty easy and straightforward to legislate. A media company that provides distribution of individual works (like Steam or Apple, as opposed to subscription services like Netflix), must provide a method for users to easily and automatically back up all purchased content. A company that runs servers necessary to the use of a program (e.g. matchmaking servers for video games) must provide the server executable, in a form that can run on currently-available commodity hardware, and must allow the client to select a privately-owned software. Companies that don't meet these requirements would still hold full liability for refunds if they remove product features later on.
- gpm 6y agoRefunds aren't sufficient, you are owed whatever the replacement cost is. If the good is no longer available except for at 10x or 100x the price, you are owed that. If the good is no longer available at any price, but the person with the liability is capable of making it available, they should be required to do so (or negotiate a contract with you that buys out your rights, but you should be free to decline that or to set whatever price you want). This is especially relevant in the digital realm where it's an especially effective tactic to undercharge to try and starve competitors, and then raise prices.
- crazygringo 6y agoThat's unreasonable, wouldn't be practical, and goes against precedent. The analogy here is if you buy a vacuum cleaner from a store and it doesn't work because of a defect. You bring it back and get your money back. The store isn't required to provide you with another working vacuum cleaner. If the vacuum cleaner is no longer manufactured, they're not required to find one in mint condition on eBay that's 10x or 100x the price. If you got to consume the media you bought for months/years and you get a full refund, I'd say you have nothing to complain about.
- edrxty 6y agoThe bigger the asset, the more it approaches the parents suggestion. If a rich person buys an expensive asset and it is defective, they're often owed for loss of use/revenue because they have the power to negotiate purchasing contracts that provide this. Us poors do not have this capability.
- gpm 6y ago> and goes against precedent. On the contrary, this is with the precedent, damages due to breach of contract, theft, destruction of property, etc are cost to replace not the original cost. And specific performance (i.e. requiring someone perform the action to fulfill the contract) is available if monetary damages aren't calculable (i.e. there is no replacement on the market).
- 6y ago
- fpoling 6y agoAs other already pointed out, this should only apply to DRM media. DRM-free should imply that the customer is responsible for it once the transfer is done.
- alpaca128 6y agoI'd love for this to happen, not just for the amusement of seeing all the giant corporations suddenly jumping to DRM free distribution to save tons of money, and Tim Cook explaining for 5 minutes how innovative Apple was with reinventing their content distribution model.
- jrockway 6y agoI think Apple killed off DRM on music in the late 2000s and indeed, Steve Jobs was quite pleased with himself when announcing it. (What's old is new again -- Epic is basically doing the same thing to Apple now. It all starts when an entrenched monopolist receives an open letter, apparently.)
- kmeisthax 6y agoThe funny thing is, Apple had an iron grip on the music market because of DRM. If you wanted to license music for digital download, the music industry demanded DRM, and Apple had the only DRM consumers had any faith in. You couldn't use an alternative DRM scheme with iPods; FairPlay was Apple's proprietary technology and it was the only DRM iPods would recognize. The music industry only caved on DRM specifically because they realized they had written Apple a blank check. Had Apple not had a long and storied history of trademark litigation from The Beatles' record label (also named Apple), they could have started directly signing artists themselves. The difference between then and now with the Epic lawsuit is that iOS has no sideloading option. Going DRM-free meant you could sell music on iPods without paying Apple. For software, the closest equivalent would be webapps on iOS, but that usually entails rewriting significant parts of your app and losing access to certain functionality. You don't get push notifications, you can't access native UI so all your UI code has to be redeveloped to something worse, and so on.
- YeBanKo 6y agoI would suggest as an alternative to a refund a way to download you content with reasonable notice(30-60 days) in open formats.