6 ms·
> When will the Elon fanatics stop listening to his bullsh*t? When someone else will sell us a car. I literally just ordered a model Y, with the $10k FSD pack
by ajross 6y ago
> When will the Elon fanatics stop listening to his bullsh*t?
When someone else will sell us a car.
I literally just ordered a model Y, with the $10k FSD package. Would I have bought something else if I could get it? Maybe. But this is here, and I can get it. Look, the product as it exists today is real and has value. Maybe you're not exited by it, but I am. And I can buy it. And I just did.
I'm old enough to remember when "make something people want" wasn't considered "bullshit" on this site.
- sanderjd 6y agoLots of electric vehicles exist and work great.
- ajross 6y agoNone with the kind of autonomy features we're discussing here. And FWIW: my judgement was that the model Y was still a win as a pure EV choice, though I agree that the other manufacturers are getting much closer there.
- unityByFreedom 6y agoThe whole point of this post is that Tesla's autonomy capabilities have been way overhyped. Another poster above says they were smart for not purchasing FSD, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26933022 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26933022
- sanderjd 6y agoI guess I see your point in the context of this thread. But it's hard to see it in the context of my life where EVs are a big deal while all this self driving hype is just a silly side show. My car is pretty easy to drive already...
- litoorachure 6y agoNot so much if you live in North America. There are a few plug-in options, but it seems like the good ones are staying in Europe and Japan because in 2021, the big automakers still don't think there's a market for EVs in the Americas. Tesla does see a market in the Americas, so they actually sell cars here. That gives them a big leg up, even among people who don't like them.
- Twirrim 6y ago> Not so much if you live in North America. There are a few plug-in options, but it seems like the good ones are staying in Europe and Japan because in 2021, the big automakers still don't think there's a market for EVs in the Americas. We have, and love, our Chevrolet Bolt. In addition to the Bolt, Kia, Hyundai, Volkswagen, Porsche, Audi, Jaguar, Polestar (Volvo), and more all have electric vehicles, all available in the US.
- sanderjd 6y agoYep, I live in the US. There were tons of Leafs were plugged in every day at my office pre pandemic. More of those than Teslas. Also plenty of Bolts there. I see lots of non Tesla EVs on the road every day.
- aflag 6y agoSure, no one is disputing the car's existence. The problem is it being promoted as something it is not.
- jeffbee 6y agoSelling people something they want, but not actually delivering it to them, is different.
- ajross 6y agoAgain, I submit myself as an existence proof to the contrary. The FSD package as it exists gets you autonomy on highways already. That alone was enough for me to buy it. The beta looks pretty acceptable to me too, and I look forward to that feature rolling out. Exactly what am I not getting? This really seems like a strawman kind of thing. You're inventing a product and a market that don't correspond to real cars or consumers, and then arguing about what those consumers "really" wanted or what the car was "supposed" to do, and not what they actually want or what the hardware actually does. I don't see how that's helpful to anyone other than an investor short on TSLA. The way to prove that this is a garbage product, again, is to make a better one.
- chakhs 6y agowhat you're not getting is level 5 self driving, that Musk keeps advertising for years. If you know that what you're paying for is L2 then all good, enjoy your new car :) The problem people have is the misleading lies, like L5 being right in the corner, I'm pretty sure many fell for it.
- thazework 6y agoYou are not getting full self driving.
- jeffbee 6y agoIf you take delivery of this thing and you’re pleased with what it does that’s fine, but it is demonstrably not the thing it’s seller says it is, which in the aggregate consumer protection realm isn’t fine.
- joshribakoff 6y agoThe fine print says what it is when you buy. This is a thing in almost all industries when it comes to marketing.
- hogFeast 6y agoI have no idea how they can legally get away with this. Seriously, how is this legal? Charge $10k for pixie dust. Even for SV, this is an unbelievable abuse of consumers.
- 0-_-0 6y agoSelling software should be illegal?
- wdb 6y agoPersonally, I am disappointed what you get for $68k after taxes in my country when buying the Model Y.
- andy9775 6y ago> "make something people want" It's more of a "the other options suck" kind of thing with Tesla, no? > Would I have bought something else if I could get it? Maybe.