3 ms·
All these "stores" have the same wording in their TOS: "this content is licensed, not sold", et c. They all use the terms "buy", "sale", "purchases", "owned",
by sneak 6y ago
All these "stores" have the same wording in their TOS: "this content is licensed, not sold", et c. They all use the terms "buy", "sale", "purchases", "owned", and other similar words in the UI. There's a clear contradiction here, and they shouldn't get it both ways.
It's very obvious (to those who know how FAANG walled gardens work) that it's a rental and contingent upon them not evaporating your account for some stupid reason. It's entirely non-obvious to the layperson.
Courts clarifying the first sale doctrine here would help a lot.
IMO, one should be able to resell or transfer software or media licenses they've already paid for. Moving online from physical media shouldn't suddenly shaft the consumer and make their media purchases evaporate when they die or lose their email address.
- strogonoff 6y agoTransferrable software/media licenses present a challenge that can be either a technical or a social/economical one. There is a high temptation to abuse the system due to the ease of making a copy. On one hand, it can be attacked with a zero-trust outlook from technical angle (DRM). On the other hand, in a society with higher minimum quality of life and satisfaction eliminating required trust may do more harm than good, as really no one would want to go through the trouble of making illegal copies. I strongly agree that “selling” something you do not get to own should not even be a valid concept.
- infogulch 6y agoMaybe this is the real killer use-case for NFTs?
- xur17 6y agoHonestly, it is a decent use case. Sell NFTs that grant the owner the right to play / use a certain song, movie, ebook, etc. Ideally have some sort of file storage layer that only grants the ability to stream the content if you own the nft - not sure how feasible that is, so the alternative is to establish a few providers that can stream the content, and get paid a small amount for their services by the movie studios. Reselling rights don't have to be granted, and if they are, they could even include "fees" for reselling to limit a rental market from taking place.
- strogonoff 6y agoI don’t like the approaches involving NFT (and blockchain in general) because no matter how you spin it, it’s ultimately following the zero interpersonal trust route.
- indymike 6y agoWe should require that the person who is having an account terminated be compensated by refunding the purchase price, plus interest.
- heisenbit 6y agoAmazon at least here in Germany offers either to rent or to buy. Now whatever their ToS say, there is a certain expectation to the word "buy" and I'm fairly optimistic that courts here would take a dim view on clauses in ToS allowing a one sided revocation. Even if it is only a license to stream it is a property right. In B2B one may put some twisted clauses into contracts but in B2C such attempts are regularly reigned in.