4 ms·
I learned my trade by playing. I suspect that many other people on HN also did. Now I do something very different, and that also came from playing, as did many
by nicbou 6y ago
I learned my trade by playing. I suspect that many other people on HN also did. Now I do something very different, and that also came from playing, as did many of the skills that made it possible.
I still write code, but it's entirely for fun. It's a completely different experience from closing tickets in an office.
I do many other things that aren't very cost-effective, just because they're fun. They might not pay the rent, but they keep me sane enough to do the things that do. For Mr. Feynman it was playing the bongos.
Do things that don't matter. Aside from the doors it can unlock, it's just damn fun.
- agumonkey 6y agoI wonder how much is made by very simple emotions: - playing - competition - noble obligations (helping someone else) I keep looking at adult life in dismay because what people consider work would barely amount to 20 minutes of soccer when we were kids. We used to run wild for hours, hurt ourselves, attempt everything that could work and we kept asking for more. Can we plug that back into daily adult jobs ?
- klondike_klive 6y agoWe can get you another beanbag for the breakout area...
- nicbou 6y agoI really wish there was a PE class for adult, where you stretch, run around the track, then play some random sport for about an hour. One day it's cops and robbers, another it's grass hockey, and nobody knows in advance.
- mmcnl 6y agoYou could argue that having fun is the end goal of things. Why do we do things that we consider important? Why is it important? Somewhere down the line everything we do should enable someone having fun. If not, then why bother?
- visarga 6y ago> Why do we do things that we consider important? Fundamentally, to survive. To self replicate. We're self replicators.
- saalweachter 6y agoYou can't really make a learning system that doesn't play. Physical play is how we train, develop and calibrate our bodies; mental play does the same for our minds. If we one day build AGI that doesn't skip and dance and draw and make up silly stories for the fun of it, that will surprise me a lot more than the other way around.
- visarga 6y ago> If we one day build AGI that doesn't skip and dance and draw and make up silly stories for the fun of it, that will surprise me a lot more than the other way around. I agree, it would be sad if AI wasn't able to play with human culture. Culture is crystallized intelligence.
- bserge 6y agoIt wouldn't need to skip and dance, though. Mental play is just randomly trying to piece together different information and see the results (physical play is simpler, a subset of mental play, basically continuous calibration). It's like having 12 puzzle sets and just taking pieces from each, trying to fit them with others and seeing the results. Sometimes something interesting shows up. Our brains do it constantly, all the time, 24/7. Most often the results are garbage and discarded, but sometimes something interesting/useful comes out, so it's tagged as such and stored for further processing. The data used for such play is everything we have stored in memory, recalled either randomly or, more often, based on current circumstances/needs/wants. An AGI would only play with what it has. And what it has available would be up to the creators. If it's built to imitate a human, it will have to be loaded with the same data as a human. And I mean all of it, everything from birth to current age or death (that varies a lot by individual, by the way). Basically, you'd have to recreate a whole human life's experience for this hypothetical AGI. Otherwise it won't be even close to a human. But such an advanced AI would most likely be built for specific purposes, which would save a lot of resources. It can play all it wants with that limited data, improve it and create new stuff. But it won't be able to do things like applying information from bird flight to car building, because it will simply not have that data. Just my musings.
- visarga 6y ago> Do things that don't matter. Aside from the doors it can unlock, it's just damn fun. I found this discussion about open-endedness being very illuminating about doing stuff that are just fun. A revolt against objectives. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhYGXYeMq_E&t=2192s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhYGXYeMq_E&t=2192s
- kirse 6y agoDo things that don't matter. I've been thinking about this recently and realized that my brain is capable of drawing an incorrect conclusion about the "mattering-ness" of something based on limited data, typically a feeling arising from personal values. The thing is, everything we do does matter, and it's one of the reasons why the Bible instructs us to "walk by faith, not by sight". On the cosmic scale of things, we don't have all the information to truly calculate whether something does (or does not) matter. In that regard, choosing to live as if what we do always matters seems like the preferred and life-giving approach.