3 ms·
"If anything, they should have learned something about not treating human beings as persons and not as involuntary guinea pigs." Perhaps the entire "tech" indu
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago
"If anything, they should have learned something about not treating human beings as persons and not as involuntary guinea pigs."
Perhaps the entire "tech" industry needs to learn that lesson. Non-technical end users should be entitled to that same level of trust as nerds. I can download free open source code, extract a tarball and build the software without worrying too much about scanning through all the files first for phone home/telemetry/OriginTrials nonsense.^1 However non-technical end users who use programs compiled for them by "tech" companies with ads and surveillance as their "business model" are not entitled to the same trust. I cannot think of any justification for the difference.
- sombragris 6y agoVery good point. We seriously need to learn this lesson as you said.
- barry-cotter 6y ago> Perhaps the entire "tech" industry needs to learn that lesson. Audit studies are conducted all the time where researchers lie to people and waste their time. > Factors Determining Callbacks to Job Applications by the Unemployed: An Audit Study > We use an audit study approach to investigate how unemployment duration, age, and holding a low-level “interim” job affect the likelihood that experienced college- educated females applying for an administrative support job receive a callback from a potential employer. First, the results show no relationship between callback rates and the duration of unemployment. Second, workers age 50 and older are significantly less likely to receive a callback. Third, taking an interim job significantly reduces the likelihood of receiving a callback. Finally, employers who have higher callback rates respond less to observable differences across workers in determining whom to call back. We interpret these results in the context of a model of employer learning about applicant quality http://www.econ.ucla.edu/tvwachter/papers/audit_study_FarberSilvermanVonWachter.pdf http://www.econ.ucla.edu/tvwachter/papers/audit_study_Farber...
- shard 6y agoThis is a very good point. I did not find anything objectionable about that experiment when I first read about it. And if the companies experimented upon had complained like the kernel maintainers did, I would have dismissed it as them covering up their bad process. This is actually making me consider that the submitters of the bad patches shouldn't be treated differently than the job application researchers.