4 ms·
People love to analyze apologies after the fact, but it seems totally unfair to me. Once someone has said an apology you can take the text of it and turn it int
by astrange 6y ago
People love to analyze apologies after the fact, but it seems totally unfair to me. Once someone has said an apology you can take the text of it and turn it into anything you want and say it proves they were lying.
- deagle50 6y agoYep, it's called accountability. Would you prefer people acted without regard for others knowing that magic words can be spoken after the damage is done?
- astrange 6y agoI would prefer you not go around saying someone is "apologizing wrong" because you've found the magic formula to turn all apology text into "I'm sorry you feel bad". There's no point in making a statement like that the original person can't respond to, anyway.
- deagle50 6y agoI get what you're saying and I don't want that that either. But I also don't think a simple apology that doesn't attempt to justify one's actions can be so easily flipped.
- shkkmo 6y agoAn good apology needs to demonstrate an understanding of why what was done was wrong and ideally includes concrete steps that will prevent anything similar from happening again. You seem to be implying that one apology is as good as another and that is absolutely not true. To me is is absolutely unfair to expect that people will treat a zero effort "sorry your feelings were hurt" apology the same as a deeply heartfelt apology by someone who feels deep remorse. By it's nature, an apology should be an act of making amends to a person your have wronged. If the words of your apology don't do that, you have failed, even if you had good intentions. If the author of the apology isn't a native speaker of english, this seems like a document of sufficient significance to merit asking a friend or colleague for a proofread. (Which you should do in a case like this even if English is your first language.)
- denton-scratch 6y agoThe researchers can no longer be trusted at all. The apology should have come from the University ethics board.