6 ms·
Agreed. I'm glad that people and companies are trying different solutions for our energy challenges, but I see so many examples where the basic physics make the
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
Agreed. I'm glad that people and companies are trying different solutions for our energy challenges, but I see so many examples where the basic physics make these solutions impossible to scale, that it seems like these are primarily just schemes to suck government money.
Gravity solutions like these will never be feasible, because as you point out, gravity is just plain too weak of a force. I mean, it looks like pumped hydro will be viable, but when you think of the sheer mass of water that can be pumped behind the Hoover damn you realize stacking a bunch of bricks is ridiculous in comparison.
There was another recent article on HN about a giant tidal generator, and I was glad to see the top comment pointing out that basically over 50 years all these tidal projects have been failures (at least when it comes to ever being able to provide decent power in a fashion that shows it can scale).
It's time we start calling out these schemes for what they are, because they take funding away from solutions that we now we'll need now to fight climate change.
- ionwake 6y agoPlease excuse me if I am terribly ignorant. In my head, liquid must be easier to play with than a solid. So displacement of water or air should be done. The displacement of air, being pumped into a balloon under water seems like a great idea. I know many solutions must have been thought of, but is the inflate balloon under water , then let it float up - the most efficient way of storing energy? Lithium batteries wear out, but are more energy dense and so arent comparable ( regardless of size). Forgive me for ruminating I think this is a problem with an already identified solution though?