3 ms·
Guys, when you give people the ability to share things, they'll share things with each other that aren't true. Facebook is as much to blame for this as Gutenbe
by renewiltord 6y ago
Guys, when you give people the ability to share things, they'll share things with each other that aren't true.
Facebook is as much to blame for this as Gutenberg is.
The extent to which people will go to avoid accepting that grandpa actually is racist is astonishing. No, dude, Facebook didn't make grandpa racist. It gave your racist grandpa the ability to talk to other racists.
Facebook accurately detects that your grandpa wants to talk to racists and gives him that ability.
- chrbutler 6y agoI think that's a fair counterpoint, but I'm not sure it covers the whole charge. What Facebook does is both to limit the diversity of opinion to which a single user is exposed, as well as extend the reach of particular points of view (those on the more extreme end, which are more "performative"). That creates validation of points of view that can be expressed harmfully, and creates a gathering cloud of cultural force that would likely not exist without it's influence.
- lupire 6y agoThe algorithms radicalize people: https://www.wired.com/story/christchurch-shooter-youtube-radicalization-extremism/amp https://www.wired.com/story/christchurch-shooter-youtube-rad... Just because Facebook and Youtube managemt aren't doing as intentionally as Fox News management does, doesn't make the effect not real.
- rkk3 6y ago"Facebook is as much to blame for this as Gutenberg is." The invention of the printing press is a good analogy to Facebook; it catalyzed the Protestant Reformation which caused centuries of persecution, war and unrest in Europe. Communication media are very powerful tools that have far reaching effects. It's not about "blame".
- chrbutler 6y agoWhat Facebook and Gutenberg have in common is that money controls the flow of information. But that's where the comparison ends. If Gutenberg had built his printing press to only print information that would fit within one's existing preferences, then it would have been a lot like Facebook. But the reason we know about Gutenberg is because it did the opposite.
- m0llusk 6y agoOkay, but if I see something shared that I know to be false and can demonstrate to be false with links to robust summaries of evidence and argument from trusted sources then how do I respond? The Facebook model is that I have no real alternative except to share opposing views with others in my bubble. It is fine for your grandpa to talk to racists, but if he shares his newfound junk with me then I should be able to flag it and link the truth such that any viewer of his posts can see how others see it.
- bsder 6y ago> Facebook accurately detects that your grandpa wants to talk to racists and gives him that ability. Facebook ENCOURAGES grandpa to talk to racists because that increases "engagement". And they block his contact with non-racists. That's a gigantic difference. Okay, let's say grandpa is racist. But he has to keep it toned down because his grandkids don't like that talk and admonish him occasionally. Facebook, however, gives him positive reinforcement to be racist. And he will now argue with his grandkids because he has the social validation from Facebook and Fox that "It's perfectly okay to be racist, and there are lots of racists just like you." And Facebook will match him with more people who are increasingly racist because that increases the engagement further. Facebook amplifies the tendency rather than damping the tendency. And eventually all his grandkids can do is quit coming to see him because he's now a lost cause. We saw this in the January 6th insurrection. Lots of people didn't get the fact that they were participating in an insurrection because their social validation circle was too closed to point that out.
- tester756 6y agoEnvironment changes people, so if you sorround people with racists, then they're likely to become racists Social media made a lot of things go insanely viral and cause damage: Trump, Brexit, BLM... All of those just divide people