4 ms·
The problem with all this data is that it doesn't inform us of who is actually committing crimes. If we are overly fixated on racism by the police and confuse
by nerdponx 6y ago
The problem with all this data is that it doesn't inform us of who is actually committing crimes.
If we are overly fixated on racism by the police and confuse correlation with causation, we might entirely miss other structural/systemic factors that might be leading (or forcing) black people to criminal behavior more often than white people.
I am aware of some research that tries to estimate propensity to actually commit crimes using victim surveys instead of police data, but I see so many conflicting results from different academic fields that I don't feel like I can form an opinion.
All I know is that measuring disparities in arrests is not enough and cannot possibly be enough to distinguish police racism specifically from other racial disparities.
- stadium 6y agoThe police don't get to decide who committed a crime, the judicial system does. Yours is the same argument that George Floyd deserved what he got because he was a criminal. Being arrested or frisked by police does not a criminal make. Conviction does. It's a duck.
- OJFord 6y agoIt seems oddly philosophical to suggest that a crime hasn't been committed until its would-be committor has been convicted... Regardless of what you want to call it in the time between the event later deemed criminal, and the sentencing, surely you see that that's what GP was referring to? That there may be differences in demography of 'who is involved in these events'.
- stadium 6y agoIt's not philosophical, it's the law. And GP dismisses the overwhelmingly higher rates of arrests for non whites as not being a systemic racism issue and assumes that white people commit fewer crimes with no data to back it up. > If we are overly fixated Sorry but that is gaslighting and victim blaming. Tell the parent of a black teenager to not be overly fixated on police reform.
- nerdponx 6y ago> It's not philosophical, it's the law. All of these are considered crimes in all jurisdictions I know of in the USA: theft/burglary/robbery, violence or threat thereof, and reckless endangerment. If you commit one of those acts, you have definitionally committed a crime, even if you are not convicted in a court of law. > dismisses the overwhelmingly higher rates of arrests for non whites as not being a systemic racism issue I encourage you to re-read what I wrote, because that isn't what I said. My post raises a question of causality. There are several common proposals for why arrest rates for blacks are disproportionately high: 1. Police are racist, so they arrest black people at higher rates than other people, regardless of criminality. 2. Criminal law is written specifically to target black people. 3. Black people, due to systemic racism elsewhere in society, end up committing more acts-that-are-legally-defined-as-crimes, and this eventually leads to a greater number of arrests. 4. Actual racist ideology, which is generally vile and I will not repeat it here. The reality is probably a combination of explanations 1-3, and there is surely mutual causality among them. Any serious attempt to understand the problem must attempt to disentangle these explanations from each other. > assumes that white people commit fewer crimes with no data to back it up I said that we specifically don't have good data, but it's not safe to assume that all demographics commit crimes at the same rate. See above. > Sorry but that is gaslighting and victim blaming. Tell the parent of a black teenager to not be overly fixated on police reform. This is a bad faith misrepresentation of what I wrote. If anything, the media getting stuff kinda-wrong but still raising awareness is a net positive. Also it should be obvious that police reform is necessary, and obviously people will care the most about the issues that affect them personally. Moreover, nothing ever seems to get done without single-minded people focusing intently on a single problem. We need people working on all aspects of the racism issue, including racism in policing and law. But you simply cannot look at the arrest numbers and assume that the discrepancy is definitely and entirely because of police racism. It would be fallacious to do so, and if you intend to put forth policy based on data then you should try to avoid logical fallacies in the process.
- throwawayboise 6y agoThe police do get to decide on probable cause that a crime has been committed. That's not enough for punishment, but it is enough for arrest and investigation.
- kar5pt 6y agoIt seems like a completely different argument to me. He's not arguing that committing crimes (or being involved in events that may be legally deemed crimes after the fact) means that someone _deserves_ to have force used on them. He's saying that it makes sense that police would be more likely to use force against people who are more frequently involved in said events.
- stadium 6y ago> it makes sense that police would be more likely to use force against people who are more frequently involved in said events Hence the systemic racism problem in a nutshell. It only makes sense through the lense of human bias and racism. Are those "people" really more frequently involved in said events, or are they more frequently policed?
- runako 6y ago> The problem with all this data is that it doesn't inform us of who is actually committing crimes. Arrest records do not provide this data either. If an area or activity is policed at a lower rate, it will look like fewer crimes are committed there. Example: there have been public "420" festivals all over the country dating back to well before the recent legalizations. These were not accompanied by mass arrests, despite mass public lawbreaking. Drugs and underage drinking are endemic on college campuses. Somehow police are unable to arrest these lawbreakers. If you prefer finance, what percentage of financial fraud do you believe results in an arrest? Or consider the discretion allowed to police in deciding when to arrest someone for riding an unlicensed bicycle. There are many other examples of less-policed spaces. Arrest records frequently tell you more about who is permitted to break laws than the number of crimes committed somewhere.
- stevenicr 6y agovalid points, but I think some may read this as 'police choose to penalize based on race' kind of proofing. I recently had some deeper insights around this. I have witnessed reasoning for these things being different at different times over the years, but the main factor has been calls/reports/complaints from the communities. Busting people at an airbnb in a quite retirement neighborhood as opposed to a college campus, drug complaints blocks from an elem school in a low income area as opposed to breckenridge, co - (which told it's police to leave weed alone many moons ago) - these things are not driven by a nationwide predisposition from those who swear allegiance to the blue cult of the country.. these things are actually driven by the individual community in most cases. I'll admit sometimes that 'community' could be real-estate developers looking to gentrify or whatever- sometimes it could be 'x color people who fear Y people at X place' - and the bicycle thing in the news recently was probably someone complaining and pointing out safety concerns - which had bad optics when viewed through the 'but you don't do that to X percentage of other bikers' - sure.. I also understand there are places where people don't call cops do to fears or reprisal - and I don't think this is a color of skin thing so much. I'd love to deep dive in this further, but my point is that it's not so much cops as a whole are some type of way - it's often more a reflection of individual neighborhoods and communities and their tolerance or lack of tolerance for various things - and often that is what is reflected in reports more than number of crimes committed in X or Y place. Thankfully these things can change - sadly I already see some of pendulum swinging the other way however. In places where people are finding additional freedoms through "progressive DA's, and progressive law changes" some are not considering how their use of such affects other near them. So I expect an ebb and flow of these things based on how annoyed people are by effects - no matter the color of those involved. Now you can point out disproportionate court cases, pleads, incarcerations and all those kinds of stats and get similar points made - and certainly there may be places that look at racial things - but I believe there it is more of an issue of socio-econimc access to legal assistance more than anything - and that is complex too.