3 ms·
About 2, I am fairly sure it is against every oath they take, and it may very well be malpractice as well. Also, with a default opt-in, the pool to get organs f
by kaba0 6y ago
About 2, I am fairly sure it is against every oath they take, and it may very well be malpractice as well. Also, with a default opt-in, the pool to get organs from dramatically increase.
And I’m not sure whether you meant that you were a doctor, or was it just a hypothetical, but usually car crash victims are not operated on by organ transplant specialists, so the doctor’s patients will not intersect, making your point purely theoretical.
- anfogoat 6y agoPlease take one quick glance at your country's politicians, police or intelligence services. How many oaths did they take? The fact is oaths are just hollow ceremony.
- kaba0 6y agoIf you want a more “rational” model of a doctor, why should he/she have a worse success rate by not saving one of his/her patients? And while there are bad, even borderline evil doctors out there, I think statistically you are much more likely to find a morally corrupt politician than a doctor, especially in countries with public healthcare.
- spoonjim 6y agoOath or no, if you could save 3 young people’s lives for one old person’s life, wouldn’t you do it? If I was a doctor I would at least want to, I don’t know whether it would be feasible.
- renewiltord 6y agoWell, if you're a doctor, you want to for a fee. Very few organ transplant surgeons work for free.
- kaba0 6y agoAs I said, you only “know” the old person dying in front of you, you are not simultaneously at a children hospital where 3 young people waits for a liver and two kidneys. Hell, not even the liver and kidney transplant happen at the same hospital. So this is indeed a purely hypothetical scenario. And while it may seem like the trolley problem, it is not, because there is a huge indirection in whether those organs can be used at all, are required at this time and whether they will truly save someone else. So instead of the still morally questionable 1-3 trolley problem you instead have one where you can either direct the trolley on a track with one person in sight or another with noone on it. And at the distance, both tracks branch randomly and most of them go through 3 young person, and maybe slightly less kills them in the second case.