4 ms·
the common definition of a natural process is one that happens without human intervention. you are applying a different definition that is problematic. by your
by em-bee 6y ago
the common definition of a natural process is one that happens without human intervention.
you are applying a different definition that is problematic. by your definition murder could be considered natural
- dqpb 6y agoMurder is natural. I never said everything natural is good. I merely said that everything is natural.
- em-bee 6y agouhm, bringing up natural as an argument in defense of the creation of sentient beings heavily implies that you consider everything natural as good. since we obviously agree that murder is not good, and you also agree that not everything natural (by your definition of natural) is good either, using natural in support of your argument no longer works. this doesn't invalidate your argument. we can still discuss whether creating sentient beings is acceptable or not. just arguing whether it is natural or not does not help us here
- 0_gravitas 6y agohttps://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/natural https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/natural only one sub-item of these fifteen definitions of natural say "no human intervention". Lets look at the definition for nature: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/nature https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/nature Definition 2b is succint: "an inner force (such as instinct, appetite, desire) or the sum of such forces in an individual" According to this, murder is in fact quite natural. I don't like arguments about definitions, because they're a cheap way out: "x is (not) bad because its y"; they also force discussions about all the wrong things, ignoring the core of what both parties care about regarding the issue.
- em-bee 6y agoI don't like arguments about definitions i agree. i do however like to clarify definitions so that we all know what we mean. i am quite happy to continue the discussion with OPs definition of natural, because now that we understand what that definition is we can get back to the actual core of the issue.