2 ms·
This is such a weird take. The driver nag is a reminder to ensure driver attention, it's not designed to be a security feature. Of course you can defeat it.
by ajross 6y ago
This is such a weird take. The driver nag is a reminder to ensure driver attention, it's not designed to be a security feature. Of course you can defeat it. So what? You can put a brick on the accelerator of a Model A and get it to "drive itself" too!
There have always been an infinite number of ways to deliberately behave unsafely in a car. Why did we only start caring now?
Edit to propose an answer to my final question: what we have here is a confounding prior. If your prior is "Tesla Autopilot is Inherently Unsafe", then the driver nag feature becomes understood as a safety feature ("Tesla Autopilot Needs Supervision"). Thus, a failure of the driver nag becomes evidence for your prior, magically ("Tesla Autopilot is unsafe BECAUSE the Driver Nag Can Be Defeated"). And thus the clickbait.
(And FWIW: I continue to believe that this recent crash did not in fact involve autopilot at all, but we'll see.)
- mhh__ 6y agoHasn't Musk stated that it's impossible though?
- buffet_overflow 6y agoHe's been wrong before. His statements should be taken as marketing, not gospel.
- dzhiurgis 6y agoOne comment that struck me on Twitter is that others track your eye attention, where Tesla only does steering wheel, which is annoying and kinda pointless...
- ajross 6y agoRight, but Consumer Reports doesn't get to the front page of HN with a headline like "Tesla Driver Nag is Annoying and Kinda Pointless". FWIW: there is a driver camera present, and it's enabled in the FSD beta. It's not clear exactly how it's going to be deployed, though. Needless to say there are privacy concerns with that kind of technology.